Share

Chapter 2: mistake 

Author: excelhights
last update Last Updated: 2025-02-14 11:36:07

Elena's pov

My heart seized. Completely stopped working, I froze. His voice had entirely penetrated and cut off the haze of pleasure we were in. This voice belonged to my best friend Asher. 

I had been riding on my best friend all along, I freakout I didn't know what to do.

Asher.

Asher!

I tried to wrap my head around the situation as I felt something heavy dropped in my stomach. Was it fear? Dread? Regret? I wasn't sure. 

With trembling hands I pushed myself off him. My face heated up, the sinking feeling in my stomach growing. "Oh Goddess," I muttered, tears of shame pricking the corners of my eyes. 

“This can't be happening, no I didn't sleep with my best friend. I did not just give him my first. I did not just get rammed by Asher freaking Asher. What have I done? What have i done? I caused this!” I whispered as I felt on the floor.

There was no going back now after this. The line was already blurred. My face was so hot I knew I was so beet red. 

"Ele?" Asher softly called out and his dk twitched. I felt so embarrassed I was naked in front of my best friend. 

"I'm sorry," I found my voice and clenched my eyes tightly as it came out filled with shame and regret. "I thought I was in Jason's room, it was dark . I-”

I choked up, my chest heaving as I fought the bubble of urge to cry. How humiliating. If I had just come with a touch light or my phone I would have noticed it wasn't Jason and this wouldn't have happened. 

I trembled and in the blink of an eye Asher was in front of me holding and hugging me as I cried with silent sobs. 

"Shhh it's okay Elena, I'm sorry." He lifted his hands and soothed my hair. “It's alright.” He said and kissed my head.

It was not okay. We slept together, I mistook him for my boyfriend who was his good friend. And not only that but he and Mel had a thing going on too. The line was more than blurred right now it was trashed. 

I was so fucked up.

I screwed up. 

"I didn't mean-”

I stammered sobbing and burying my face in my hands. All I wanted at that moment was for the ground to open and swallow me whole to avoid this situation. 

"I am so s-orry Asher-," I croaked out, I didn't want to lose him. I definitely didn't want this to come between us. How would I face both Maggie and Jason too? Oh my. 

I winced. Now that the haze of desire had evaporated, the pain of my muscles being pounded and used was very present. It feels like I had been rammed by a truck.  

I winced. Maggie...

How was I so stupid to not have noticed? The mango scent, only Asher would used the shampoo I made them even if he didn't like it. 

And those sounds that had fluttered beside my ear, the grunts of pleasure- was he wolf he was going to be the next alpha.

My face was so hot I scramble pulling myself off his hug picked up my clothes and started dressing.

 Asher reaches out for me, his arms wrapping around my wrist to stop me. I sucked in a breath at the burning feeling his hands left on my skin. 

I had always felt it, but tonight it was way hotter. Almost like a scorching tingling fire, I didn't know why but at this point I didn't care.

"Wait," he said, his voice hoarse. My heart rams against my chest. Don't say anything to embarrass me any further please. I didn't know what more to tell him. Tears burned my vision. 

"We don't have to say anything," his voice is a whisper in the dark, caressing me. I hated the feeling. 

"What?" I frowned, my heart kicking up a notch. 

"We don't have to let anyone know," his thumb brush against my wrist as if trying to soothe me, maybe. "This can stay between us." 

My heart leaped in my throat. Is he saying that we should pretend this never happened? Would it save our friendship and our relationships?

"Like it never happened?" I whispered, searching for his eyes but it was so dark I couldn't see anything.

 It takes a good while for him to answer.  

"Yes," he replied, his voice hoarse and thick. "Like it never happened. You thought I was Jason and I thought you were Maggie. This was a huge mistake." 

His words feel like a punch in the gut even though they were nothing but the truth. However, he was giving us a way out of this shameful incident and how could I not take it? We could

go back to how things were right? I will be able to face him tomorrow?

Related chapters

  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 3: half truth

    I swallowed and nod. "Like it never happened." I agreed and pulled my arm free of his grip and fixed my clothes.As I left the room and closed the door behind me, the ache between my legs mocked me with a memory that I will never forget. Forget Elena. Forget about it. Everything will go back to normal tomorrow. I chanted in my head as I made my way out of his room and hostel. I still couldn't believe I had mistaken Asher for Jason, straddled him and didn't give him a chance to protest as I practically seduced him. Why hadn't he said a thing? Why didn't he say Maggie's name? If he had I would have known who It was right?I shook my head, blinking back the wave of tears I felt. I sniffled and continued my way and froze when I saw the familiar person, Jason. My heart thrummed. How could I face him after what I had just done? “Hey babe.” He called out as he ran to me with his phone flashlight pointing at me.He looked surprised to see me, as he should since I hadn't told him I'd be com

    Last Updated : 2025-02-14
  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 4: Mate

    I woke up to a throbbing pain between my legs, my body aching all over. I groggily opened my eyes to find Maggie sitting beside me, concern filled in her eyes as she looked at me."Hey, how are you feeling?" She asked softly.I tried to sit up, but a sharp pain shot through my abdomen, making me gasp. Maggie quickly helped me sit up, propping pillows behind me."I'm so sorry, Elena," she said, her voice trembling. "I feel like this is all my fault. If I hadn't been so caught up in my own stuff, I would have been there to stop you from...from… plus I was also the one who encouraged you I'm sorry."I reached out and took her hand, "Maggie, it's not your fault. I made a mistake, and I have to deal with the consequences."Maggie looked at me, her eyes welling up with tears. "But Jason...he's your boyfriend. How are you going to cope? Do you even plan on telling him?”I squeezed her hand gently. "You did nothing wrong, I'm the one who messed up, not you. I really don't know what to do."Ma

    Last Updated : 2025-02-14
  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 1: surprise

    Elena's Pov.It was my boyfriend Jason's birthday today and I wanted to surprise him and give him the only thing I valued so much; my virginity. “You know I have planned for this for months, I don't know if I'd be enough for him and I really don't know how I'd feel with him inside me.” I muttered looking at Maggie, my best-friend's girlfriend.“I understand when I first had sex I also felt the same but girl you'd do great.” She said with a smile.“Alright, I better get going before I change my mind.” I said standing up from my bed and Maggie nodded.It was already late nine p.m. and I hoped Jason was already in his bed. He had texted me early thinking I forgot his birthday.It took me about twenty minutes to get to Jason's dorm room which was next door to Asher, my bestie who was literally the heartbeat of girls in school. We had grown up together so we practically knew everything about each other.I could still remember how I met him, my family relocated from California leaving our

    Last Updated : 2025-02-14

Latest chapter

  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 4: Mate

    I woke up to a throbbing pain between my legs, my body aching all over. I groggily opened my eyes to find Maggie sitting beside me, concern filled in her eyes as she looked at me."Hey, how are you feeling?" She asked softly.I tried to sit up, but a sharp pain shot through my abdomen, making me gasp. Maggie quickly helped me sit up, propping pillows behind me."I'm so sorry, Elena," she said, her voice trembling. "I feel like this is all my fault. If I hadn't been so caught up in my own stuff, I would have been there to stop you from...from… plus I was also the one who encouraged you I'm sorry."I reached out and took her hand, "Maggie, it's not your fault. I made a mistake, and I have to deal with the consequences."Maggie looked at me, her eyes welling up with tears. "But Jason...he's your boyfriend. How are you going to cope? Do you even plan on telling him?”I squeezed her hand gently. "You did nothing wrong, I'm the one who messed up, not you. I really don't know what to do."Ma

  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 3: half truth

    I swallowed and nod. "Like it never happened." I agreed and pulled my arm free of his grip and fixed my clothes.As I left the room and closed the door behind me, the ache between my legs mocked me with a memory that I will never forget. Forget Elena. Forget about it. Everything will go back to normal tomorrow. I chanted in my head as I made my way out of his room and hostel. I still couldn't believe I had mistaken Asher for Jason, straddled him and didn't give him a chance to protest as I practically seduced him. Why hadn't he said a thing? Why didn't he say Maggie's name? If he had I would have known who It was right?I shook my head, blinking back the wave of tears I felt. I sniffled and continued my way and froze when I saw the familiar person, Jason. My heart thrummed. How could I face him after what I had just done? “Hey babe.” He called out as he ran to me with his phone flashlight pointing at me.He looked surprised to see me, as he should since I hadn't told him I'd be com

  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 2: mistake 

    Elena's povMy heart seized. Completely stopped working, I froze. His voice had entirely penetrated and cut off the haze of pleasure we were in. This voice belonged to my best friend Asher. I had been riding on my best friend all along, I freakout I didn't know what to do.Asher.Asher!I tried to wrap my head around the situation as I felt something heavy dropped in my stomach. Was it fear? Dread? Regret? I wasn't sure. With trembling hands I pushed myself off him. My face heated up, the sinking feeling in my stomach growing. "Oh Goddess," I muttered, tears of shame pricking the corners of my eyes. “This can't be happening, no I didn't sleep with my best friend. I did not just give him my first. I did not just get rammed by Asher freaking Asher. What have I done? What have i done? I caused this!” I whispered as I felt on the floor.There was no going back now after this. The line was already blurred. My face was so hot I knew I was so beet red. "Ele?" Asher softly called out and

  • After A Nght With My Bestie    Chapter 1: surprise

    Elena's Pov.It was my boyfriend Jason's birthday today and I wanted to surprise him and give him the only thing I valued so much; my virginity. “You know I have planned for this for months, I don't know if I'd be enough for him and I really don't know how I'd feel with him inside me.” I muttered looking at Maggie, my best-friend's girlfriend.“I understand when I first had sex I also felt the same but girl you'd do great.” She said with a smile.“Alright, I better get going before I change my mind.” I said standing up from my bed and Maggie nodded.It was already late nine p.m. and I hoped Jason was already in his bed. He had texted me early thinking I forgot his birthday.It took me about twenty minutes to get to Jason's dorm room which was next door to Asher, my bestie who was literally the heartbeat of girls in school. We had grown up together so we practically knew everything about each other.I could still remember how I met him, my family relocated from California leaving our

Scan code to read on App
DMCA.com Protection Status