Chapter 76: I Give Up

~Emerald~

“Does he make you happy?”

I was stunned in my direction when I heard this from James. As I stared at him deep in his eyes, all I could see was pain. I know this is painful for him but just like what I have said, James has to experience this.

He has to know that he can't have everything.

A deep breath escaped out of my throat as I tilted my head as I spoke, “Yes, I am happy with Gideon.”

‘That's a lie, Emerald. You have to tell James the truth!’ Lilian screamed at the back of my head but I didn't listen to her. I disregard her screams because I can do whatever I want to do.

James, who heard my answer smiled bitterly, tears still flowing from his eyes. He used the back of his hand to wipe the tears.

“You are right. I deserve all of this, and I would forever hold this regret until my last breath. If I couldn't have you anymore, then it's time…” James paused for a moment, and then he continued, “It's time for me to give up, Emerald, but it doesn't mean I'm giving up on loving