All Chapters of A Love That Shouldn't Be: Chapter 31 - Chapter 40

She chatted away with her brother for an hour or so, mostly about the stingrays, the coral reef dive, embarrassing the trio that had hit on them. "Sorry if I got a little carried away then. I just get so tired of guys just staring at these embarrassing things all the time. I wish there was a way for them to stare at my brain. I hate not being listened to."Mike sat quietly next to her, letting her vent, knowing that she just needed someone to lay her troubles out to.Finally, she took a break from her verbal rampage. Mike looked over and smiled. "I don't know how much this means, since I'm your brother and all, but I like you just the way you are."She laughed at the corniness of his statement. "I think you have been in the sun too long," she said, laughing."I know it sounds like a speech from a guidance counselor, but I think you are perfect. I think you are more beautiful than any of our sisters. I think that if you let yourself, you could feel more beautiful than you do. I think y

Upstairs, Mike stirred slowly from his slumber. Something felt really, really good. He knew Danni was next to him and could feel her naked body pressing gently into him. Wait, that wasn't right, she was on top of him he realized, as he felt something warm pressing down on top of him. He slowly opened his eyes, and she was staring at him, smiling as she lowered her lips to his. She arched her back and lifted her hips, pulling him out of her and then slowly lowering her hips and plunging it back in."You are the fuckin' man""Wow," he said finally, "This is definitely a great way to wake up. I could get used to this." He arched his neck and moaned loudly as she slid up and down on his pulsating shaft."I didn't think you would have any complaints, lover." she said quietly, lifting her hips and rocking them gently back down on his cock, sliding slowly down every pleasurable inch. "Oh God, you feel so good inside me," she admitted.She lifted up again and turned over, lying on her back in

Mike figured he would just have to accept the fact that Beth wasn't repulsed by the idea of him fooling around with their three sisters and he wasn't going to get out of having to sit through her brainstorming session. Maybe speaking with her would curb his sexual appetite. She usually worked problems out well enough for the rest of the family as a whole."Second, you aren't forcing yourself on them." she stated, "In fact, they are initiating the contacts and events themselves. Essentially seducing you, correct?"Mike nodded, curious as to where she was going with the theory."So," she continued, "they are attractive and have any number of other options, but are choosing to engage in sexual relations with their own brother as opposed to any other options open to them, correct?"He nodded again, following her logic so far. "So that had me wondering," she stated, then asked, "Was it Danni's close call that caused all this?"He shook his head, remembering that he'd been fooling around wi

Danni was still at Megan's during and after supper. No doubt she was talking about the incident at the frat house with her best friend. Meagan would be upset if Danni hadn't told her best friend of all people, what had happened.Emma and Sarah were still out shopping and didn't get home until just after supper.Mike had enjoyed a plate of something that Beth had conjured up, then went upstairs to his room just as Sarah and Emma came in carrying bags. He decided to try and stay away from the obviously plotting women, figuring nothing good could come of it. All they did was torture him anyways.Beth finished her supper then went to her room, no doubt searching the web for information on her new theory.Sarah winked at Emma and his twin knew that tonight would be the night that they would give their brother the surprise they had planned.Mike was reading his magazine in his bedroom when Sarah opened the door and peered in. She smiled at him and waved a hand to him towards the door. Pulli

Sarah had finally done it, she'd finally gone all the way with her younger brother as she'd so desperately wanted to ever since he'd hit her in the face a week or so ago with his erection. She slowly slid down the length of his shaft, feeling it sliding along her vagina muscles and sending wave after wave of pleasure coursing through her. She flexed her pussy muscles and caused him to arch his back and moan from beneath Emma's hips.Mike couldn't believe how good this felt. He had both arms wrapped around his twin sister's thighs and was assaulting her clitoris with his tongue and biting gently. His eldest sister was sliding up and down his shaft and was slowly picking up speed. He just knew that he'd wake up soon and discover that this was all some wicked dream, maybe even cooked up by his perverted inner voice as payback for some perceived offense.Emma bucked her hips as another orgasm began to tickle itself up her spine and exploded through every pore. She fell forward into Sarah,