Home / Romance / Traded For His First Love / 4. They want me to give up

Share

4. They want me to give up

Author: Meminger
last update Last Updated: 2025-01-24 16:40:58

Reese's POV

Things happened too fast.

Elliot still had Jennifer Durham's unconscious body in his arms while he hurriedly called for an ambulance. My mother-in-law was screaming at me, accusing me of being a murderer.

"Isn't your husband enough? Now you wanted to kill poor Jennifer, you murderer?" She was screaming at me while crying in horror.

The household staff looked at me as if I were a monster. Elliot didn't even dare to look at me.

"But I didn't do anything! She threw herself down the stairs on her own," I said, trying to defend myself, feeling that if I didn't, no one else would.

"Sure, you didn't, did you, Reese?" Florence's sarcasm was heavy, directed at me. "First, my husband threw himself in front of that car to save you, and now this poor woman threw herself to certain death of her own free will. And you really expect us to believe that?"

"Florence, I know you've never liked me, but you have to believe me. I didn't do this; I'm innocent!" I said, crying. Likewise, I was so tired of this, of always being accused of things I hadn't done.

"Just shut up!" My mother-in-law shouted. "All this is your fault, Elliott. I told you not to marry her!"

Elliot, my husband, the man who had sworn at the altar to love and protect me, at this moment said nothing in my defense. He let his mother and everyone else say and think absurd things about me while I felt alone and helpless.

The paramedics came and took Jennifer Durham to the nearest hospital, but with them came the police too. "Mr. Goodwin. Is it true that it was your wife who pushed Ms. Durham down the stairs?" They asked my husband.

Elliot didn't even bother to look at me when he handed me over. "Yes, officer," he answered. "Reese pushed Jennifer with the intent to kill."

"No, Elliot. That's not true; I swear to God I barely touched that woman! Please, you have to believe me," I pleaded, on the brink of despair.

"Enough, Reese!" He bellowed. "It's time for you to pay for all your crimes. Please, officers. Take her away from here." He turned his face away from me.

There was bile in my throat as I saw my own husband not believing me and handing me over to the police without even blinking. "Come on, ma'am. The prison awaits you," the officer said, wanting to put handcuffs on my wrists.

But I dodged. "No. Please, wait... I can prove my innocence," I said, my voice bordering on desperation. I couldn't believe I was just being arrested for something I didn't commit.

At that moment, Elliott turned to me, the impassive expression on his face now giving way to doubt. "You can prove it? What are you talking about?" He asked, perhaps thinking I was crazy.

"Ignore her, Elliot," said Florence, looking at me with a stern face. "She doesn't know what she's doing; she's just babbling."

"But I really can prove it, Florence. I can prove my innocence," I repeated with more conviction now.

"What are you trying to say, ma'am?" The officer asked.

"I'm talking about the security cameras in the house," I said. "They're all over the place, and there's one there in the hallway." I pointed to the small security camera hanging from the ceiling. "All you have to do is check the video and see if I did what I'm being accused of." I looked at Elliot with conviction; my soul was clear, so I would defend myself to the end.

"Can we check the security cameras, Mr. Goodwin?" The officer asked for permission.

"Don't check anything!" Florence continued with her harsh words directed at me. "She's just trying to deceive you. Take her away once and for all and put her in prison, where she belongs!" It was clear my mother-in-law wanted me far away from that house and far from her son; she was truly my worst enemy.

But I turned to my husband. "What do you have to lose, Elliot? Just let them check the security cameras," I said, challenging him. He had accused me of killing his father, but unlike the accident that led to Samael Goodwin's death, I was certain I could get out of this unscathed. Unless he wanted to be unfair to me, he would have to give permission for the footage to be checked.

"Very well," he said. "Gentlemen, follow me to the mansion's security room." He turned and began to walk, leaving his mother completely frustrated. The police followed him, and so did I.

The security video on the monitor revealed the truth; they saw when I slapped Jennifer, saw when she grabbed the railing, and then threw herself down the stairs.

"With this video, we can really prove that Mrs. Goodwin did not push Ms. Durham," the officer said. "She cannot be arrested for this."

I couldn't deny I sighed in relief, as if a great apprehension had dissipated from me. When the police left, I spoke to my husband. "Elliot, I know you have doubts about me because of what happened in your father's accident, but believe me. I am not the person you think I am; we are just victims of all this misfortune." I needed him to start believing in me again because I knew that his reason for not believing me was what was driving him away from me the most.

He sighed, massaging his temples. "There's too much happening right now, Reese. I'm worried about Jennifer; actually, we can deal with this later and focus on what really matters, which is her recovery." He was putting on his coat and then left without looking back.

I swallowed hard. It hurt to know my husband was so concerned about his ex-girlfriend; not only that, I wanted to throw in his face the grotesque and merciless way he was quick to accuse me of attempting to take her life instead of believing my word first. That said a lot about our situation; he believed Jennifer and not me, and if it weren't for the security cameras, I would certainly be in prison now. Suddenly, I felt so powerless, a bitter taste in my mouth, as if the man I had married no longer belonged to me.

I stood there on the porch, watching him get into the car and drive off at top speed to take care of the other woman. "Why do you keep fighting?" It was my mother-in-law, who had approached me, always spewing venom like a poisonous snake. "Can't you see he doesn't want you anymore? Why don't you just give up and leave?"

Related chapters

  • Traded For His First Love    5. An intruder in my house

    Reese POVThe day had barely begun, and I was already enveloped by a sense of desolation. The sunlight, which weakly filtered through the windows, made the world outside luminous, but within me, there was a growing darkness. The mansion, with its familiar scent of flowers, felt like the set of a movie where I didn't want to be. I was anxiously at the window, watching the gate, waiting for Elliot, but each second was a painful reminder of what had happened the night before.Yesterday had been a whirlwind of events that starkly contrasted with the calm and monotonous days I spent in this house since marrying Elliot. It was an onslaught of discoveries and twists, and I simply spent the entire night thinking about it. I couldn't sleep because there was a fear growing in my chest.After all, my husband had come home with another woman and was demanding a divorce, not to mention that Jennifer Durham had thrown herself down the stairs as a way to incriminate and accuse me. Just thinking abou

    Last Updated : 2025-01-26
  • Traded For His First Love    6. Just want

    Reese POVWhen I woke up, Elliot was already beside me, his gaze determined but softened by the morning light filtering through our silk curtains. He looked rested, something I hadn't seen in him for a long time.“Elliot… Good morning. What's wrong?” I asked as I adjusted myself in bed; it was early in the morning."Reese, sorry to wake you like this, but I need to say something," he began, his voice carrying a tone of sincerity that made my heart race.“It's okay, go ahead. What is it?”"I've thought a lot about what you said yesterday," he said. "I know I've made many mistakes, and I want to change that. I'm going to spend more time with Sammy and our family."His words were like a balm to my wounded soul. I could hardly believe what I was hearing; it was as if a dream was becoming reality after so many nightmares. I almost cried with joy but held back, not wanting to show how affected I was."Are you serious?" I asked, my voice a mix of hope and caution."Yes, Reese. I'm going to d

    Last Updated : 2025-02-03
  • Traded For His First Love    7. The danger is lurking

    Reese POVElliot and I spent the entire morning together in bed, clearly not sleeping. It had been so long since my husband had touched me that I had almost forgotten the feeling, and today he seemed to want to make up for lost time in the best way possible. His binding kisses, his large hands sliding over my body, took me to heaven, so we stayed there just enjoying each other, something that seemed to belong to a lost time, something that should have been the right thing to do from the beginning.Moments later, he was lying in bed with me on top of him, resting my head on his chest with his arm over my shoulders. It was simply amazing to be like this with him; I could feel him so close to me, which was completely satisfying.“I need to go now,” he said after a while.I lifted my head to look at him. “But already? You said you were taking the day off today?” I questioned, already missing him.“I know I said that,” he said, smiling at me. “But I just need to sort out some things at the

    Last Updated : 2025-02-04
  • Traded For His First Love    8. Fear of losing you

    Reese POVAfter that memorable morning, I truly saw that Elliot was trying to change. He took Sammy to the park, spending more time with him, trying to build those family memories we had lost. Watching them together, running across the grass, playing ball, warmed my heart in a way I hadn't felt in years. It was as if, for the first time in a long time, we were being a real family.The day was going so well, full of laughter and small moments of happiness, that I almost forgot our recent problems. But then, during our impromptu picnic in the park, Sammy said something that brought me back to reality.“Mom, I'm not going to eat all my cookie. I want to save a piece for Jennifer,” he said with an innocence that broke my heart, showing how much he missed that woman.“Why do you insist on that, sweetie?” I asked with a smile, running my hand over his head, trying to hide my discomfort.“Jen loves cookies,” the boy answered while eating.“Wow! Incredible how Sammy already likes Jennifer so

    Last Updated : 2025-02-06
  • Traded For His First Love    9. I can't give up my family

    Reese POVThe ride back home was silent, except for my son's voice, always animated as he played with his toys and shared how everything was amazing through his eyes. Elliot murmured some things while answering his son, but I could also tell that because of the tension in the air, he was holding back.What did he expect me to do then? Asking me to be okay with Jennifer living in the same house as us was too much for me, and I simply couldn't handle it, especially not with her getting so close to Sammy. Jennifer was the same woman who told me she would take my son for herself, so I would never get along with her.I sighed from the other side of the seat and just watched the landscape through the window. Elliot promised he wanted to change and become a better man, but first, he had to keep Jennifer away from us.When we returned home after the failed picnic, to my dismay, Sammy ran into Jennifer's arms, happy to see her. I stood at the doorway, watching the scene with a heavy heart. The

    Last Updated : 2025-02-07
  • Traded For His First Love    10. A deep pain

    Reese POVWeeks passed, and the dynamics in that mansion were getting weirder by the day. Elliot really started spending more time at home with us, which was good, but at the same time, Jennifer insisted on lingering around, like a shadow we couldn't shake off.Jennifer's motor condition had improved, and she no longer needed the wheelchair. Elliot, with the concern he always showed for her, suggested she use the heated pool for physical therapy.That's how, on a sunny morning, Jennifer showed up at the pool in a white bikini that highlighted her slender figure. "The day is really nice for swimming, don't you think?" she commented, holding her hat high on her head while one hand rested on her waist."Yes, it is! And you require it for your recovery, my dear," said Florence, who was seated on a lounger, watching the scene with a satisfied smile on her face."Just let me finish up here with the floats, and we can start," said Elliot, while preparing the area for the swimming session.Sa

    Last Updated : 2025-02-08
  • Traded For His First Love    11. All over

    Reese POVAfter what I saw earlier, Elliot and Jennifer kissing, I felt broken in a way I never thought was possible. The pain was so sharp it felt like someone had run a blade through my heart. Elliot had promised to change, had given me hope, and now that promise lay in pieces at my feet.Now, we were sitting in our room, a heavy silence hanging in the air, like a dark cloud before the storm. I couldn't look at him; my gaze fixed on the floor, where the patterns of the carpet seemed to mock my pain."Reese," he began, his voice low, almost a whisper of guilt. "I need to tell you the truth."I lifted my eyes to meet his, which were filled with a mix of remorse and something I couldn't identify. "The truth? What truth, Elliot? That you cheated on me with Jennifer?" My voice shook, but there was an underlying anger, a fury for what had been destroyed.He sighed, a sound that seemed to carry the weight of the world. "Jennifer is my lover. Since I met her again, I remembered the first lo

    Last Updated : 2025-02-08
  • Traded For His First Love    12. The surrogate mother

    Reese POVAfter hours of crying and lamenting in the room over my husband's painful words, it felt like each tear had drained a little more of my soul. But reality called me back; I had to make dinner for Sammy. With an effort that seemed to move mountains, I got up from the bed, where each blanket reminded me of a betrayal, and went down to the kitchen.Upon entering, the scene I found was like another blow to my already wounded spirit. There was Sammy, laughing and eating, with Jennifer beside him, who had already prepared his dinner. The table was set with his favorite dishes, and he seemed completely happy and comfortable with her."Since you forgot about him, I made his dinner and took good care of him," Jennifer said, shrugging with that cynical smile that seemed to mock my pain.I felt a lump in my throat. I hadn't forgotten my son; I was just devastated. But faced with that scene, it seemed like I really had failed. I looked at Sammy, hoping to see some sign of longing or need

    Last Updated : 2025-02-09

Latest chapter

  • Traded For His First Love    75. A new woman

    Reese POVWhen I caught Elliot with the doors of my wardrobe wide open, my heart raced in my chest, and a cold certainty settled in: the façade of my supposed marriage to Spencer had come to an end. He stood there, his eyes gleaming with a mix of accusation and hope, his hands still hovering over my clothes as if he could find answers in the folds of my dresses.His question—“What kind of marriage is this where you don’t even share a wardrobe?”—cut through the air, sharp and direct, and I knew I could no longer hide the truth.I sighed, the weight of months of lies crushing me. “Good heavens, how disconcerting…” I murmured, turning my gaze to Spencer, sprawled on my bed, snoring heavily, the smell of bourbon and smoke still clinging to him after an entire afternoon drinking with his friends at the club.“Elliot,” I murmured, keeping my voice low so as not to wake Sammy and Avie, who were sleeping in the next room, exhausted after a day filled with laughter and dinosaurs. “Let’s talk s

  • Traded For His First Love    74. What kind of marriage is this?

    Elliot POVIt was late at night when I dragged Spencer back to Venus’s apartment, the city lights blurring as exhaustion seeped into my bones. The drive had been a nightmare, his dead weight slumped against the door, muttering incoherent nonsense that irritated me even more.“You could shut up, you know—because I’m damn sure if it were me in your place, you’d leave me in the middle of the street,” I grumbled, hauling him along, fully aware he wasn’t sober enough to understand.Stepping into her apartment, the air shifted—warm, familiar, laced with her scent, a blend of lavender and something uniquely Reese. Venus met me at the door, wearing a red silk robe over her nightdress, her smooth, soft skin and delicate feminine features a soothing sight. She was makeup-free, her fresh aura palpable from here. Her dark hair, tousled and loose, was the first time I’d seen it down since our reunion, and I noticed it was still as long as before. She looked light and breathtaking after a long day

  • Traded For His First Love    73. Ernest Williams

    Elliot POVThe lads were still holed up in the club, drinking and yapping away as the hours dragged on. The place reeked of bourbon and weed, the air thick with the haze of their excess. Josh, Andrew, Ernest, and Spencer were tossing back drinks like water, their laughter growing louder and sloppier with each round. I nursed a single glass, the amber liquid barely touched—my mind was too tangled with other things to let loose. Venus kept creeping into my thoughts, her smile from this morning with Sammy and Avie haunting me, and the sting of Spencer’s taunts from the car ride still burned. I couldn’t shake the image of her in that red lace he’d bragged about, and it twisted my gut with a mix of jealousy and longing.By the time night fell, the club’s buzz had dulled into a drunken hum. I slipped out to the balcony, the cool air hitting my face as I lit a cigarette, the ember glowing against the city skyline. My heart ached, a dull throb of missing Reese—Venus—settling in. I wondered w

  • Traded For His First Love    72. Club of the Pathetically Unlovable Dudes

    Elliot POVSpencer Davies dragged me to a luxury club in the heart of the city, a place where only gentlemen with six zeros in their bank accounts could even dream of entering. The air was thick with wealth and arrogance as we stepped inside, the dim lighting casting a golden glow over polished wood and leather.A group of guys was sprawled out on plush sofas, their eyes glued to a massive screen blaring some sport, drinks in hand and smoke from exotic herbs swirling around them. At least there weren’t any obscenities or naked women around—small mercies, I suppose.“Hey, lads!” Spencer greeted them with firm handshakes as he approached, his voice booming with that smug confidence I’d come to despise.I recognized Josh Carter among them, hunched over a glass bong, inhaling the herb smoke with a glazed look in his eyes.“Bloody hell, you lot started early today, huh?” I commented, sinking into a chair beside them, my tone dry as I tried to mask the unease gnawing at me. Being here with

  • Traded For His First Love    71. The Annoying Spencer Davies

    Elliot POVVenus’s suggestion had been damn awkward. Spencer and I, going out together? We had nothing in common—hell, what were we even going to talk about? I hugged Sammy tightly, promising I’d pick him up later, my chest aching with the need to stay, to be part of this moment with Venus and the kids. But I forced myself to step away, descending the elevator with my rival in a silence so thick it felt suffocating. There was nothing to say between us, nothing but the weight of our shared history and Venus’s shadow looming over it all.When we reached the parking lot, I pointed to my car, my voice gruff but steady. “We’ll take my car, right?”Spencer rolled his eyes, letting out an unnecessary, mocking chuckle. “The city’s mine, so I’m driving,” he said, striding toward his sleek black sedan, his movements sharp and confident.I sighed, shoving my hands into my pants pockets, already knowing this day would be a bloody challenge. But I couldn’t disrespect Venus—I could see she was ben

  • Traded For His First Love    70. My kids together finally

    Venus POVThis felt like a dream—watching my two children, Sammy and Avie, communicating for the first time, their small voices filling the living room with chatter about dinosaurs. Sammy’s excitement over his T-Rex book, Avie’s timid but growing curiosity about the big, scary ones—I could barely breathe, my heart swelling with a joy I’d held onto for years, buried under the pain of loss and Jennifer’s lies. It was as if the fractured pieces of my family were finally stitching together, and I stood there, frozen, soaking in the miracle of it all.Sammy sat cross-legged on the carpet, his dinosaur-themed sneakers glowing against the soft rug, holding up a plastic T-Rex figurine for Avie to see. “This one’s the strongest, but I think the Velociraptor’s smarter,” he said, his voice bubbling with enthusiasm, the uncertainty left by Jennifer’s manipulations melting away.Avie, still clutching her favorite stuffed bunny, peeked from behind the couch, her blonde curls bouncing as she edged

  • Traded For His First Love    69. My condemnation

    Elliot POVI stood on Venus’s doorstep, clearly anxious, Sammy’s hand gripped tightly in mine, my heart pounding like a drum against my ribs. It was Saturday, and the crisp, quiet morning stretched before us, the promise of a whole day with her pulsing through my veins.I’d barely slept, my mind racing with anticipation—not just for Sammy’s sake, but for mine. I wanted to be near Venus again, to feel the spark of connection we’d once shared, to see if we could start understanding each other after all this time. Who knows… maybe this could be the start of something new.Sammy shifted beside me, his dinosaur-themed sneakers scuffing the stone step, his wide, curious eyes darting between me and the polished wooden door. “Dad, is Lady Venus really here?” he asked, his voice small but hopeful, the uncertainty left by years of Jennifer’s lies still echoing in his tone.“She is, buddy,” I replied, squeezing his hand, my voice steady despite the nerves churning in my stomach. “She’s excited t

  • Traded For His First Love    68. Fortunately we will be unhappy

    Bethany POV“Lady Venus is a beautiful and very interesting woman, but she really isn’t my type,” Josh said, “so stop hating her to ease your frustration over me not responding to you, okay? Besides, you’re so pretty—stop being so bitter, it doesn’t suit you.” He pinched my cheek in a gesture that was anything but romantic, then reached for my door handle. “Now get out of the car, come on. It’s getting late.”But I pulled the door shut, closing it firmly, and looked at him with my nose tilted upward. “What?” He was confused by my defiance.“I already said, I’m not getting out of here unless you’re with me,” I repeated. “Or would you rather take me to your place? I’ll take any place as long as we’re together.”“You’re not seriously doing this, Bethany, are you? You’re not challenging me like this, are you?” he raged, his brow furrowed. There was danger in his green eyes, but I wasn’t afraid. What more could happen? I was already in deep trouble anyway.“If Lady Venus isn’t your type,

  • Traded For His First Love    67. Everything goes in love

    Bethany POVThe sound of Josh’s car crunching over the gravel of my parents’ mansion driveway jolted me out of my reverie. Josh sat beside me, and since we’d left the restaurant, a morbid silence had hung between us. Every time I spoke, he’d huff, grumble, or roll his eyes as if the sound of my voice alone irritated him. I considered myself pretty, but Joshua Carter’s disdain made me feel like the ugliest, most uninteresting woman in the world.“Alright,” he said after pulling up in front of my house, his voice flat, not even glancing at me. “You’re safely delivered. You can go now.”I looked toward the house through his car window and sighed. So that was it? I’d just get out of the car, and this would end here? For heaven’s sake, things were only getting worse… “Or better yet, why don’t you come in? My parents won’t mind if you sleep with me tonight. It’s kind of fitting, since we’re engaged,” I invited, flashing a seductive smile.He frowned at me as if I’d just said something outr

Scan code to read on App
DMCA.com Protection Status