Clayton’s POV
“Well that was a shit show.” My little brother, Cary, chuckled darkly as we walked upstairs together after the dinner party.
“Which part?” I snorted at him. “The part where our dear older brother acted like an epic prick all night? Or maybe the part where Mallory showed up looking like a damn Goddess, making me drool all over myself? Or better yet, the part where her fucking Alpha boyfriend showed up and had his hands all over her all night, making my wolf insane with jealousy?”
“Yeah, Roan was losing his mind too. But I’m not worried about the boyfriend.” He shrugged as if it was an easy obstacle to overcome. “We’re Alphas too, and we have history.”
“Are you fucking kidding me right now?” I shook my head in disbelief. “You’re right about her having a history with us, a terrible one. We tormented her for most of her childhood. She couldn’t get away from us fast enough when she left for the academy. Meanwhile, she meets her Alpha prince charming there and he’s probably been treating her like his queen for the past two years. We never should have treated her so badly all those years!”
“So, we’ll just have to start treating her like a Queen too. Prove to her how sorry we are and how much we’ve matured. Give the asshole Alpha a little friendly competition.” He says like it’s the simplest solution in the world.
Cary flopped down on my bed, stretching out and propping his hands behind his head. His confidence truly amazed me sometimes. Admittedly, the three of us had pretty big egos and none of us had any problem getting girls, not that Colt tried anymore. But something told me winning Mallory away from her boyfriend, or even getting her to trust us enough to consider it, would be a bigger challenge than we’d ever attempted before.
”I think you might be a little too sure of yourself.” I professed. “And even if we could win her over, it would be a lot of work. It’s not worth the effort for just another lay.”
“Maybe I don’t want just another lay.” Cary said, making me blink in surprise. He’d never actually dated a girl in his life.
“Are you serious?” Had I entered some kind of alternate universe? That couldn’t be my real brother talking.
“Why not? I mean, who wouldn’t want her? She’s fucking gorgeous! She’s obviously talented and smart. And she’s always been the perfect combination of sassy and sweet.” He sang her praises. “If I’m being honest, I think I’ve always wanted her. I just didn’t know how to act on it after the way we treated her.”
“Yeah, me too. And you’re not wrong. Anyone would be lucky to have her.” I admitted. “But she doesn’t have her wolf yet. What if she leaves us for her mate. What if it’s him?”
“We’ll cross that bridge when we come to it.” He answered nonchalantly, shrugging again.
“Colton would never go for it.” I reminded him of our brother’s current “Darcy hung the moon” philosophy.
“We’ll see!” Cary said with an evil smirk.
I was about to argue but my father's voice in my head cut me off.
“Boys, I want to see you in my office in five minutes. Family only, Colton.” He linked all of us, but specifically made sure Colt wouldn’t bring Darcy, which I was sure went over like a lead balloon.
When we entered dad’s office, Colt was already there, leaning against the wall next to dad’s desk with his arms crossed over his chest. The pissed off look on his face left no doubt as to his current mood. Meanwhile, dad was sitting behind his desk with mom sitting in his lap, ruffling his hair through her fingers, the picture of tranquility.
“Good, you’re all here. Have a seat please.” He said politely, but it wasn’t a request. “Your mother and I have something we want to discuss with you.”
Colton made no effort to hide his aggravation but complied, knowing he didn’t have a choice. An Alpha’s order was an Alpha’s order, dad or not.
“What’s this about dad?” I asked, anxious to get to the point. It couldn’t be anything good, Not when we got called into the principal’s office like this.
“Wasn’t it great to see Mallory again?” Mom answered my question with one of her own.
“Yeah, it was great!” Colt dead-panned. “Did you call us all here to rehash dinner or was there something important you wanted to talk about?”
“That’s enough, Colton!” Dad barked. “You will show your mother some respect!”
Colt nodded curtly and mumbled out an apology.
“Actually, Mallory is the reason we called you here. We have a proposition for you and would like you to hear us out.” Dad said.
“What kind of proposition?” Cary asked warily.
“We’d like you to spend some time with her. See if you’re compatible together. And hopefully, one day she’ll become your Luna.” Mom laid out their idea.
“No!” Colton growled immediately.
“We aren’t finished son.” Dad’s patience was clearly dwindling. “We aren’t forcing you into anything. We just want you to give it a chance. You heard about her accomplishments at the academy. She would be a strong Luna for this pack. If things were to work out, I would hand the Alpha title to you as soon as your union was complete. But if you find you aren’t compatible, you can continue to wait for your fated mate.”
“Did it escape your notice that she already has a boyfriend?” Colt pointed out. “And I have a girlfriend who I already intend to take as my chosen Luna.”
“No!” I protested. “You know we can only have one Luna. If I’m going to settle for a chosen mate, it’s not going to be her.”
“That’s a no for me too!” Cary agreed. “Actually, not just no but FUCK NO!
“Alright, that’s enough!” Dad cut us off. “Clay and Cary, your feelings on Darcy are duly noted. What do you think of our proposal regarding Mallory?”
“I don’t know.” I told him honestly. “I’ll admit she’s amazing and I’m intrigued by the idea of getting to know her again. It seems like she’s changed a lot, for the better. But I have concerns.”
“Which are?” Mom Prompted.
“Well, Colt has a point, she does have a boyfriend and they seem happy together. What makes you think she’d even give us a chance? And even if she did, what if we aren’t fated mates? What if she finds hers or we find ours? Someone might get hurt if that happened”
“I agree.” Cary voiced his opinion. Mom and dad both nodded in acknowledgement.
“We would never try to keep you from your fated mate.” Mom started. “But finding her isn’t guaranteed and you couldn’t do better than Mallory for a chosen mate. Besides, you never know, maybe she is meant for you.”
“Or maybe she’s Nathan Richardson’s mate.” Colton argued. “And maybe Darcy is meant to be our chosen mate.”
“Colton, I know you care for Darcy, even believe you are in love with her. But I would caution you not to mistake love for what is really only attractive because it’s safe.” Mom warned. “Finding something real requires risk but anything worth having is worth taking that risk.”
“That’s not-” He started to protest again, but mom interrupted him, raising her hand to quiet him.
“I’m not trying to convince you son. Just asking you to search your own mind. Now, as for Nathan Richardson, I’m almost positive what Mallory feels for him is nothing more than misguided admiration. I’ve seen true love plenty of times in my life and that is not it. I’m less sure how Nathan feels but if Mallory doesn’t feel the same, their relationship is doomed to fail anyway.” Then she winked and added, “All’s fair in love and war after all.”
“Your mother and I are not expecting an answer here and now. We just wanted to plant the seed and give you some time to think about it. We will give you the room so the three of you can talk.” Dad said, then lifted mom in his arms and swept her out of the room.
Carrington’s POV Colton sank into dad’s chair, dropping his head into his hands as soon as our parents left the room. “Well, that was . . . unexpected.” I quipped. Colt looked up to shoot me a death glare, apparently not appreciating my comment. “Geez, sorry.” I huffed under my breath. “I guess we know how Colt feels. What about you Clay?’ Clay took a deep breath and blew it out, looking up at the ceiling. I could’ve sworn I saw his cheeks turn pink, before he finally looked us in the eyes. “If I’m being honest, I kind of had a thing for her before she left. But now, fuck, I’m not sure I could stay away from her if I tried.” He confessed. “And the way Gunner flipped out when he smelled her, I would’ve sworn she was our mate even though I knew she didn’t have her wolf yet.” “I already told you Roan went crazy too. And we all know how Kai reacted. It couldn’t have been more fucking obvious so don’t even try to deny it, Colt.” I stopped him before he even opened his mouth. “
Mallory’s POV Nathan drove me home after dinner at the pack house. I knew he had a long drive back to his territory so I was pleasantly surprised when I invited him in and he actually agreed. He’d already gone above and beyond to pick me up at the airport and drive me home. “Did you enjoy your homecoming dinner, love?” Nathan asked me as we snuggled on the couch together watching a movie. “Mmmhmm,” I hummed blandly. “It was nice, I guess.” “You guess?” he prompted, his way of asking for more information. “It’s just weird being home again.” I elaborated. “I’m super excited to see mom, of course! And it was great to see Alpha Carl and Luna Erika. They’ve always been like family to me. But the triplets were acting weird. I’m almost sure they’re up to something.” “Why do you say that?” Nathan seemed genuinely curious. “They were being nice. They’re never nice!” I told him, remembering how they used to harrass me. “Not Colton. He’s been indifferent since he started dating Darcy. B
Mallory’s POV The sound of my alarm blaring at six am made me jolt upright. I had finally been dozing after a restless night of broken sleep. I was still pissed at Clay and Cary for their behavior last night but mostly I was just confused. I tossed and turned all night, trying to shut out the thoughts continuously assaulting me. Before I left for Luna training, they treated me like I was gum on their shoe, an annoyance to be dealt with. I assumed once I was gone, they would have thrown a party to celebrate. So why, after all this time, did they suddenly decide they enjoyed my company? At first, I thought maybe they’d just devised another way to mess with me. Interrupt my alone time with Nathan and try to keep me so busy I can’t spend time with him just to frustrate me. Or maybe they think he will break up with me and they can laugh at my heartbreak. But I had news for them, Nathan and I wouldn’t break easily, and certainly not because of them. Still, something seemed differe
Colton’s POV “Fucking hell!” I roared, picking up a stupid wolf figurine from my desk and shattering it against the wall. “What the fuck is happening with us?” I growled at my wolf, though I was more angry at myself than him. He was just an animal, after all. “I don’t know.” Kai answered with a wolfy shrug. “She’s beautiful and her scent calls to me. I want her.” “Well you need to stop!” I snarled at him before admitting the truth. “I need to stop.” I was so fucking pissed at myself. Just last night, I’d held Darcy’s hand and comforted her, reassured her I didn’t have feelings for Mallory. It was hard work getting her to believe me after the way I’d acted at dinner, growling at Mallory’s boyfriend and practically drooling over the girl herself. But I’d finally managed to convince her. “Feeling better?” I’d asked her after her tears had finally stopped. “Yeah,” She said, still sniffling. “Not that I ever want you to cry, but your lips are all swollen and puffy, maki
Mallory’s POV I had no idea why I agreed to a movie night with the triplets. I must have temporarily lost my mind. I couldn’t think of another explanation for voluntarily entering the lion’s den, or wolf den as it were, with the three of them. Maybe it was because I was irritated at Nathan for his nonchalant attitude about the whole thing and wanted an opportunity to prove to him I was right about them being up to no good. “I’m so proud of you sweetheart! It sounds like your Alphas are really taking your expertise seriously!” He’d gushed when I’d called him to complain about canceling our date earlier. “They’ve never taken me seriously a day in my life! I’m telling you they are up to something and as my boyfriend, you should be more concerned about it!” I’d argued, but he just laughed it off. I huffed to myself as I headed to the kitchen to grab sodas while the guys ordered the pizza. At least Nathan had agreed to come see me tomorrow. He would be here early in the morning so I
Cary’s POV “What the fuck was that about?” Colton demanded as soon as I returned to the lounge. I was not in the mood to deal with his imperious attitude at the moment. My lips were still tingling with the memory of Mallory’s mouth on mine and all I wanted was to be alone to savor the sensation. Without waiting for an answer, Colt launched into a lecture. “She has a boyfriend! How did you think that was going to end? Did you actually think she was going to throw away their relationship, just roll over and spread her legs for you? Forget about all the shit we put her through growing up?” “Ease up, Colt!” Clay barked at him. “Neither of us are looking for an easy lay here. There is something between us and we know she feels it too. Keep lying to yourself if it makes you feel better but you know it’s true. You want her too and it scares the shit out of you!” “Why the fuck would that scare me?” Colt balked at the idea. “If I wanted her, I would just say so. But I don’t.” “Bull
Mallory’s POV “Goddess damn it!” I screamed, leaning my back against my bedroom door and smacking the back of my head against it in frustration. Nathan had just left after I’d given him some lame excuse about not feeling well and needing to rest. I guess it wasn’t a total lie. My stomach was in knots. Still, I didn’t think he was really buying it but it was the best I could come up with. I’d called him as soon as I got home last night and begged him to come spend the day with me. I told him I was having some trouble adjusting to being home and I thought it would help to have him here. But the truth was, I knew I couldn’t let any of the triplets touch me again. If they did, I wasn’t sure I’d have the will to resist them and I had to resist them. Nathan and I came back to my house after training and I tried to relax and just enjoy being with him, but I couldn’t stop thinking about what I’d done. Guilt was eating at me over kissing Cary behind Nathan’s back. I knew I should just
Clay’s POV “Wh-, what?” Mallory stuttered, her eyes flitting nervously between the three of us. “He said we want you, Mal.” Cary repeated my words, sounding more vulnerable than I’ve ever heard him. “I don’t-” Mallory seemed taken aback at first, but then her back stiffened and her eyes hardened. “I’m not the same girl I was two years ago, the one who let you intimidate her. I’m not falling for the same old games where you try to get me to admit I like you so you can laugh at me and tell me what a naive, stupid little girl I am to think you’d ever be interested in me. Frankly, I’m a bit disappointed you haven’t come up with something more original by now.” “That’s not what we’re doing, Mal!” I implored her to believe me. “Fuck! We were immature idiots back then. We never should have treated you that way. We should have realized how special you were even then.” Mal just stared at me for a minute, processing my words. I held my breath, hoping she would see my sincerity. It s