Share

Chapter Two

last update Last Updated: 2021-02-19 12:17:00

Beth turned and glared at her friend, but the crack of the bat had her eyes readjusting as Sammy connected, sending the perfect pitch flying toward the fence in center field. Clearly, the opposing team hadn’t been sprinting in practice because it seemed to take forever for the Silverton field man to get himself to where the ball had landed. By then, Shane, who’d doubled before Kyle came to bat, was jogging into home, and Sammy was rounding second.

Holding her breath, Beth set her pencil aside and watched the third base coach, one of the other dads, wave Sammy to third. Finally having retrieved the ball, the center fielder, whose arms were as big around as barrels, rocketed the ball to his cutoff man. It was going to be close.

Sammy slid into third, a plume of dust clouding Beth’s view as the third baseman, a lanky guy whose curly hair stuck out around his cap in every direction, reached in for the tag. The ump was right there, and gave the signal as he shouted, “Safe!” and Beth cheered, along with everyone else in attendance. Of course he was safe. She’d never doubted it for a moment.

Standing up and dusting his hands across his white and navy blue striped uniform, Sammy took his hat off, ran his hand through his blond hair, and recomposed himself. For a second, Beth thought maybe he was looking at her as his eyes weren’t quite fixed on the batter, but then they drifted back down, and Lexy breathed in deeply before announcing Tom Black at the bat.

“We scored,” Andi reminded Lexy as soon as she turned the mic off.

“So?” Lexy asked, confused. “I know.”

“It’s nine to two now.” Andi reached across Lexy and changed the scoreboard, and someone down in the bleachers shouted up a snide, “Thank you.”

“Gotta make sure you’ve got the score right,” Beth reminded her friends, trying to keep the annoyance out of her own voice. Her book was right, she’d made sure of that, and now she had a few moments to stare at Sammy while he attempted to trick the pitcher into thinking there was a chance he might try to steal home. Of course, that wouldn’t happen without a wild pitch, but it was fun to watch him take a huge lead off the bag and then scramble back each time the pitcher looked in his direction.

“Sorry,” Lexy muttered in response to her comment. “I guess I should stop staring down the third base line and do my job.”

“Hey!” Beth said turning to look at her friend. “Scorebook is right.”

Lexy laughed, loudly, and Beth shook her head. “Whatever, Lexy. We all know that you’re not here to keep me company. You know, I’ll see Michael at practice tomorrow at the batting cages, and you won’t be there. Maybe I’ll mention….”

“If you do, you’d better never put me on the microphone again.” Lexy’s eyes were narrow behind her glasses, and Beth grinned, making sure her friend knew she was just joking around. She wouldn’t say anything to Michael Splinter unless Lexy wanted her to, even though of all the guys on the team, he was about the only one who ever had anything to say to her, except to ask for a piece of gum. The rest of them seemed to think of her as Shane’s lame little sister.

There had been that brief exchange with Sammy, though, at practice a few days ago. He’d been nice to her, and she’d appreciated being spoken to as a person who had been around baseball her whole life and had some knowledge of how the sport was played. He’d asked her who she thought was going to win the World Series this year, and when she’d said the Blue Jays, he’d been surprised, noting he’d assumed she’d say either the Royals or the Cardinals. She hadn’t had time to go into her thinking, but she hoped she’d have a chance to talk to him about it again soon. Maybe after the game. Tonight.

“It’s four hundred degrees in here,” Lexy groaned, clearing the scoreboard at the end of the eighth. It had looked as if Barryville might win in a mercy rule in the sixth, but Silverton just kept hanging on. Now, with the score twelve to four, it seemed Lexy was ready for Silverton to throw in the towel and chalk it up to a bad opening game.

“When do they play again?” Andi asked.

“Thursday. In Mineral Mines.” Road games were either awesome or horrible. Her dad almost always let her take a friend, and this time of year Beth was very popular with the other girls in the group of four or five she hung out with during the school year. Everyone wanted to ride with her in the off chance one of the cute boys from the team would need a ride, which was usually the case. Sometimes her mom’s mini-van would be full of ball players, and since Shane had to sit in the front on longer trips due to his car sickness, it often meant an uncomfortable ride for Beth next to one of the guys in the middle seat. At least if she had a friend with her, she could sit in the way back and have someone else alongside her who likely didn’t mind squeezing into the back with a guy they hardly knew. The town was small, but Shane was two years older than her, and most of these guys were his age and had heard for the last fifteen years that Beth Monroe was a brainiac, a nerd, and a total loser, thanks to her brother’s propaganda. Few of them wanted to sit in the back next to her….

“Beth, did you hear me?”

Andi was literally jostling her arm, and Beth had to check the scoreboard against her book, not sure if she’d recorded the last few pitches, before she said, “Uh, no. What?”

“I said, who are you taking?”

“Oh, right. I… I’m not sure. I’ll have to wait and see if we have an extra seat.”

“I call dibs,” Andi said, staring at Lexy like a fight might break out if she dared to toss her own name into the hat.

“Okay.” Beth cleared her throat. Sammy was playing first base, and her eyes lingered there a little too long. She thought somehow he had noticed, even though she realized the angle from first up to the booth had to be a difficult one. It was like he could feel her looking at him.

“That’s not fair,” Lexy muttered. “I call the next away game, then.”

The girls were discussing whose turn it was to go with her, but Beth was too busy staring at Sammy to even notice. She knew he wouldn’t need a ride. His dad was a member of the coaching staff, and his parents never missed a game. One good thing about the booth was that Mrs. Burk couldn’t possibly notice how intently Beth was staring at her son. She was an elementary school teacher, known for her sternness, and her husband, who owned a furniture store in town, was a bit kooky. They were an odd couple, and one of the first things Beth’s mom had said when she, unfortunately, became aware of her daughter’s crush was, “Think about what you’re marrying into,” and rolled her eyes. Evelyn Monroe was as honest as the day was long, and while Beth rarely got along with her mother, she had to give her a little credit for that one.

A car drove by blaring “Whomp, There It is,” causing the batter to zone out a bit, and Beth recorded another strike as the first base coach screamed at him to keep his head in the game.

“I love this song,” Lexy declared, flipping the switch on the scorekeeping machine. “Whomp! Fat ass! Whomp Fat ass!” she sang, rocking her head back and forth.

Beth looked up from the scorebook and caught Andi’s eyes across their friend. They both broke out laughing hysterically, and Lexy looked up, confused. “What?”

“Do you seriously think that’s what they’re saying?” Andi asked as soon as she could breathe.

Beth reached over and cleared the board as the hitter headed back to the dugout, but it was too late to avoid Mr. Cooper’s wrath. “Ladies, pay attention, or we’ll have to find someone who can!”

“Sorry, Mr. Cooper!” Beth shouted back down to him. Normally, she’d show him the book was correct, but that was impossible now that she was ten feet above the ground. While her friends might be off-task or distracted, Beth had been keeping score since she was nine years old and had it down. Rarely did she make a mistake, and when she did, it was usually Sammy related….

Related chapters

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Three

    Andi had schooled Lexy in the correct lyrics of the new hit by Tag Team while Beth appeased the plumber by day, umpire by night who still didn’t seem happy with their performance. Luckily, it was the final inning, and they’d all be out of there soon enough. She was ready to get in the minivan and crank up the air conditioning, not that she wouldn’t have to stand around and wait for her dad to load everything up and go over the game with his assistant coaches for a half an hour before he finally headed home. She desperately wished her dad would just let her take the car. She’d had her permit for a few months. But her parents would never let her drive the car by herself until she was fully licensed. Next year, her dad had told her. But then, next year her brother would be in college. This was likely their last summer for Babe Ruth League ball. A pang of sadness hit the pit of her stomach, and her eyes automatically searched for Sammy. This was the su

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Four

    The stairs creaked beneath her feet as Beth felt her way along the bannister, a can of Dr. Pepper in her free hand. Whoever decided it was a good idea to put the light switch at the top of the stairs had been an idiot, and while Beth realized said idiot probably died over a hundred years ago, she really wished the people who’d renovated their house right before they bought it five years ago would’ve considered fixing this problem with the light.And put a bathroom on the second floor.She reached the top step and fumbled for the cord that hung from the ceiling in the narrow hallway that ran past Shane’s closet of a bedroom to hers. Finding it, she gave it a tug and then breathed a sigh of relief at having reached the top without tripping and tumbling to her demise. Of course, the way the stairway curved, she would’ve probably hit a wall before she broke her neck, but reaching the top of the stairs always felt lik

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Five

    Something about Ryan’s tone sounded different, like he wasn’t really all that happy for her, and she wondered if he had something against Sammy. He wouldn’t be the only guy who felt that Sammy’s opinion of himself was a little unwarranted, but Beth couldn’t remember ever hearing Ryan say anything bad about him before. Her eyebrows knit together as she tried to determine how to respond. Should she thank him for the compliment, even if it might’ve been laced with sarcasm, correct him for essentially calling Sammy an ass hat, or explain why his reasoning was wrong? In the end, she did what she always did in similar situations and obliterate any twinkle of hope from her miserable existence.“Actually, once he said that, he walked over to a group of popular girls.” Beth could hear the misery in her own voice. “God, you should’ve seen the way Carly Lyles draped herself on him.” She shook her hea

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Six

    Away games always had her phone ringing, and Beth had decided long ago that she would always take whoever asked first, but she’d taken her friend Brittany who normally hung out with Lexy and Andi as much as she did Beth. Since she’d started a job this summer at the local grocery store, working as a cashier, Brittany was a lot busier than the other girls. Despite the calling of dibs by Andi earlier in the week, they both understood. For Brittany, sometimes being a little bit older could be a drag because she had to work so much, but at least she had her driver’s license and could drive them around the square—when she wasn’t working or grounded.The next Tuesday the game was away again, and she’d taken Lexy after a rock paper scissors battle to the death between her bespectacled friend and Andi. There hadn’t been any tears at the resolution, but there had been some narrowed eyes and veiled threats. Beth assured And

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Seven

    The booth was relatively quiet for most of the game, and Beth was able to concentrate on the game for once. While she didn’t like to think her friends were upset at her or each other, at least Mr. Cooper didn’t have to turn and shout at them about the score being wrong. He did have to ask the people in the bleachers to keep it down a couple of times, however, and by the second time, Beth began to realize there was a lot of chatter going on down there. She had no idea who it was, however, because of the way the scorekeeper’s booth was situated. The fan was drowning out all but giggles now and again and the high pitched din of muffled conversation.It wasn’t until Brittany made her way up the stairs halfway through the seventh inning that any of them got a clue. “Hey chicas!” she announced, her blonde, curly hair a little saggy since she’d come from work but otherwise looking pretty and put together. “How&rsq

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Eight

    The silent reverie was broken by the sound of three sets of feet on the ladder. “Oh, my God!” was about all Beth could understand, but she knew she’d be filled in soon enough.“She did look like a ghost, just standing there all still,” Lexy agreed. Beth reached over and flipped the ball button on the scoring machine and then recorded the pitch in the scorebook. The girls resumed their seats, and Beth shushed them, afraid Mr. Cooper would get on to them as well.“She was beautiful, though.” The revelation came from Andi, but Beth kept her eyes forward, locked on the game. Just what she needed—another gorgeous girl to swoop in and make her feel like a loser.“Her lips are so red and pouty…. Her eyes are gold,” Lexy added.“Do you have a crush on her?” Andi laughed, elbowing the other girl.“Maybe&helli

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Nine

    The sound of his voice caught her off guard, and goose flesh sprung up all over her arms. If it wasn’t for the sound of her friends “oh, my God-ing” to her left, Beth would’ve thought she was asleep, that the question had only taken place in a dream.She turned her head to see Sammy standing in the dimly lit parking spot, the moon illuminating his perfect face as he waited for a response. Behind him, Robby and Michael lingered, their arms crossed as they watched, a goofy grin on Robby’s face while Michael looked much more serious.“What was that?” Beth asked, still unable to process what was happening. How in the world was it possible that Sammy was actually asking her out? If this was true, it was a miracle form heaven….“I said, would you go out with me? I mean… I want to go ask Carly out, but these two assholes keep telling me there’s not a girl in

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19
  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter Ten

    Evelyn was up when they snuck in the back door; even her dad tried to avoid making any noise for fear it would wake Beth’s younger sisters, Dani and Lavender, and Evelyn would come undone. But Lavender, who was three and named after her mother’s favorite color, was standing in the kitchen in her Rugrats nightgown while Evelyn filled a sippy cup with tap water.“We won!” Richard announced, patting Lavender’s head. She smiled up at him but didn’t say anything, and Evelyn shushed all of them.“Don’t wake Dani up,” she insisted. Her sisters’ room was far away from where they were standing, across from the living room, in the front part of the house, away from the kitchen, nestled between the parlor and her parents’ bedroom. It was as if whoever designed this house had no blueprints and just started walling spaces off.“Sorry,” Richard replied, op

    Last Updated : 2021-02-19

Latest chapter

  • Pretty Little Monster   Epilogue

    The sun was sweltering the day they put Hannah Day in the ground. It wasn’t a dreary, stormy morning like in the movies, but it seemed fitting that Hannah’s funeral wouldn’t quite fit the mold either. She certainly hadn’t.Beth and Ryan held onto each other as the preacher said a few words about the beautiful girl who had meant so much to so many. There was no mention of the fact that she’d drowned trying to commit murder, and that according to the journal she kept, this was her second such act. Unfortunately for Brock Hill, there’d been no one there to save him.As the preacher finished his remarks, Beth squeezed Ryan’s hand, and they gave the casket one last look as Hannah’s mother began to wail. Beth couldn’t blame her for being unable to accept what her daughter had done—or what her daughter had been through herself. The journals were full of secrets Hannah hadn’t con

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 50

    “Damn,” Beth muttered, hoping she was okay. She might be batshit crazy, but the thought of anything permanently damaging happening to her made Beth sick to her stomach, especially since she’d been the one to push her.“What happened?” Michael asked. “You’re bloody, Beth.”Beth hadn’t realized her face was scratched up so badly until she dragged her hand across her cheek, and it came back pink. Halley had made contact quite a few times while they were under the water, but she had hardly felt it at the time. Now that her adrenaline was starting to die down, she was sure it would all come back to her.Sheriff Bill Jones ran up, flashlight in hand, before Beth could answer Michael. He snaked his way through the fence. “You kids all right?” he shouted, straightening his glasses and running his spread hand across his mustache.“No, we n

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 49

    It wasn’t enough to scare her off, though, and Halley lunged at Beth as Ryan began to float away, still not conscious enough to help himself. Beth was aware that the creek meandered for about a quarter mile before a small, but powerful waterfall merged the creek with the lagoon. She couldn’t let him get away from her, but Halley was coming at her again, and this time, Beth was close enough for Halley to scratch her face.Beth pushed her back as hard as she could, balancing on one leg as she brought her other knee up and made contact with Halley’s gut. The smaller girl groaned, and Beth shoved her backward as hard as she could. Halley stumbled, regained her footing, and came at Beth again, but this time, Beth was out of the way, already moving toward Ryan. She dove into the water, reaching for his outstretched hand when she felt Halley latch on to her ponytail.Halley wasn’t pulling her up, though, she was pushing

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 48

    There was no time. All of it seemed to speed up and slow down, to move backward and forward at once. Beth could hear a struggle, somewhere in the water, and she recognized Ryan’s voice even though it was strained and groggy. She couldn’t make out what he was saying as every word was clipped by the sounds of splashing and gurgling. Frantically, she hunted for the entrance in the fence and was just about to give up and climb over when she spotted it—and spotted them.Beth could see Halley in the water. It was deeper here than Beth had expected as it hit her above the waist. Either that, or the girl was on her hands and knees. Her face was lifted to the sky like she was praying, and though it was difficult to see, in the light reflected off the surface of the water that swirled past her, Beth could tell Halley’s eyes were closed.At first, she was confused, not understanding where Ryan might be, but then his hand ca

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 47

    Rushing over to her friends, she pressed the lid back down on Ryan’s drink. “Lexy, hold onto this. Don’t let it spill, and don’t drink it. Brittany, can you drive Andi down to the pay phone? Call your uncle, the sheriff, and get him down here, okay? I’m not sure what’s going on, but we might need him.”“Do you think it’s that serious?” Lexy asked as the other two started to move.“Maybe. I don’t know.” Beth didn’t have any more time to talk about it. If Ryan really was in trouble, she should’ve already been moving.She took off running, not sure of where she was going, but instinctively, she thought the creek would be the most logical place for Halley to take him if she was really trying to injure him. She hadn’t given him enough of whatever it was floating in his drink to kil

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 46

    “Hey, where’s Ryan?” she called when she was a few feet away from them. All three stood with their arms crossed, serious expressions on their faces.“We aren’t sure,” Lexy admitted. “He got up about ten, maybe fifteen minutes ago, and walked off, that way, into the park. With Halley.”Beth was confused. She peered off into the darkness. There were no lights at all in that section of the park. Across the street that circled the ball field, there was mostly just wide open space where people flew kites or lay on blankets in the shade. A few hundred yards away, off in the distance, she knew there was a chain link fence that separated the creek from the park so that no children accidentally ran into the water, but she couldn’t see it from here.“Why? Where were they going?” Beth asked, trying to keep her voice calm.“We don’t kno

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 45

    The baseball game Thursday night was at home against Juniper, one of the smaller towns in the area, and there was a pretty good chance Barryville would win by the mercy rule. Beth climbed the ladder to the scorekeeper’s box alone since her friends decided they wanted to sit on the bleachers where they could keep a better eye on things. Beth remembered Ryan mentioning he wanted to go to this game back when he’d first won his freedom, and she thought there was a possibility he might show up with Halley. Since Beth wouldn’t be able to see the bleachers from her post, her friends had volunteered to observe, even though they had no idea of the potential threat.Beth hadn’t told them about the pills or all the details of Halley’s mysterious past. They only knew that there was a chance Halley wasn’t who she said she was and that Beth thought she might be up to something no good. Telling Andi, Lexy, and Brittany that she thoug

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 44

    It must’ve been a day for cleaning because that’s what her mother was doing, too. “There you are. Your phone has been ringing nonstop since you left. I really wish it wasn’t so loud.”“Sorry,” Beth muttered wondering who was calling her now. She headed to the door to the stairs, her mother still talking behind her.“Dinner will be ready in a few minutes. Your dad just got home from work. You really should go out in the back yard and play with him and the girls. You never do that anymore.”“Okay,” Beth said, but her hand was on the door. How was she supposed to figure out who was calling so that they’d stop and also spend time outside with her family? Her mother continued to run a rag over the old piano in the corner of the room, the one no one knew how to play, and Beth headed upstairs, hoping whoever had been calling had good news.

  • Pretty Little Monster   Chapter 43

    Mrs. Wilson opened the door on the second knock. A surprised, yet pleasant, look crossed her face. “Beth! How nice to see you. How are you, dear?”“I’m good, Mrs. Wilson. Is Ryan here? I need to talk to him for a few minutes, if he’s not busy.”“Oh, uh, sure.” She looked worried, like she was afraid Ryan might be unduly stressed by having to talk to his unstable friend. “Come on in.” She gestured at the living room, and Beth walked in slowly. In all of the time she’d been neighbors with Ryan, she’d never come to his house before.The living room wasn’t what Beth had expected. It was clean, but the furniture looked much newer than the outside of the house would indicate. The television was small and built into a cabinet that sat on the floor, like the one Beth’s parents had had when she was little. She took a seat on a green and white ch

DMCA.com Protection Status