Why Was Novel The Giver Banned In Some Schools?

2025-04-16 12:38:20 180

4 answers

Amelia
Amelia
2025-04-21 00:33:00
The novel 'The Giver' has been banned in some schools primarily due to its themes of euthanasia, infanticide, and sexual awakening, which some parents and educators find inappropriate for younger readers. The story’s depiction of a dystopian society that practices controlled breeding and the elimination of the elderly or imperfect infants has sparked controversy. Additionally, the book’s exploration of complex moral questions and its portrayal of a world without pain or emotional depth can be unsettling for some audiences. Critics argue that these elements are too mature for middle school students, who are often the target readers. However, supporters of the book believe it provides valuable lessons on individuality, freedom, and the importance of memory and emotions in shaping human experience. The debate continues, with some schools opting to include it in their curriculum while others remove it entirely.
Zane
Zane
2025-04-18 13:07:22
Some schools banned 'The Giver' because of its mature content, including themes of euthanasia and the suppression of emotions. The book’s portrayal of a society that sacrifices individuality for sameness and control has been deemed too intense for younger readers. Parents and educators have expressed concerns about the book’s depiction of a world where babies are killed if they don’t meet certain standards and where the elderly are euthanized. These themes, while thought-provoking, are considered by some to be too heavy for students in middle school. The novel’s exploration of complex ethical dilemmas and its questioning of societal norms can be challenging for young minds to process. Despite these concerns, many argue that the book’s messages about the importance of choice, memory, and human emotion are essential for developing critical thinking skills.
Yara
Yara
2025-04-19 20:54:35
The banning of 'The Giver' in some schools stems from its controversial themes, such as euthanasia and the suppression of individuality. The book’s depiction of a society that controls every aspect of life, including the elimination of those who don’t fit the mold, has been seen as too disturbing for younger readers. Additionally, the novel’s exploration of sexual awakening and the loss of emotional depth has raised concerns among parents and educators. Critics argue that these themes are not suitable for middle school students, who may not be ready to grapple with such complex issues. On the other hand, supporters of the book believe it offers important lessons on the value of individuality, the power of memory, and the necessity of experiencing both pain and joy in life. The debate over its appropriateness continues to divide opinions.
Yolanda
Yolanda
2025-04-18 20:20:53
Some schools have banned 'The Giver' due to its mature themes, including euthanasia and the suppression of emotions. The book’s portrayal of a society that eliminates those who don’t conform to its standards has been deemed too intense for younger readers. Parents and educators have expressed concerns about the book’s depiction of a world where babies are killed if they don’t meet certain criteria and where the elderly are euthanized. These themes, while thought-provoking, are considered by some to be too heavy for students in middle school. Despite these concerns, many argue that the book’s messages about the importance of choice, memory, and human emotion are essential for developing critical thinking skills.

Related Books

The Alpha's Moon Princess
The Alpha's Moon Princess
BOOK ONE OF THE MOON PRINCESS TRILOGY: A Prophecy, spoken by the three Goddesses known as The Fates, foretold of a child born with a white wolf. The child would become the ultimate destruction or the ultimate balance. On the night of a full moon, nearly eighteen years ago, the child was born and she would be known as Kyra, the Moon Princess. Kyra spent her life as a rogue, never belonging anywhere, constantly on the run. Until one fateful event lands her just outside the borders of the Night Blaze pack. The Alpha, Hunter, learns that she is his fated mate, but she doesn't believe it. The truth of who and what she is revealed. Kyra has to decide if she will stay with the devilishly handsome Alpha, who makes her question everything or face her past alone. For the first time in her life, more is at stake than just her life. Will she become their undoing and end up being the one that brings destruction to them? Life as Kyra knew it will never be the same, she will have many obstacles to overcome to learn who she is. Though will it be enough to fulfill her destiny? What will happen when she decides to stop running and face the past that haunts her?
9.6
175 Chapters
IN THE ARMS OF MY ALPHA
IN THE ARMS OF MY ALPHA
A growl escaped his throat as my robe fell and pooled at my feet. I was completely naked. I saw his eyes dilating. He wanted me. That was all that mattered. A seductive smile curled on my lips, hiding the nervousness I felt. "I'm all yours, Alpha..." "Get dressed! And get out!" His breathing hitched as his gaze swept all over my naked form. I walked towards him, biting my lower lip as I reached for his shirt, unbuttoning it while ignoring his anger. He would have pushed me away if he didn't want this, but instead, he moved swiftly and pinned me against the wall. "Is this what you want?" His said hoarsely. His breath brushed against my neck, sending pleasurable tingles between my thighs as he pressed his front against mine. I stared back at him, letting my eyes show the emotions I had kept hidden all these years. "I want you, Caspian." ***** In a world where Alpha Females are pawns for the Claiming, being an Omega Female is considered a blessing. Andrea was born and raised as an Omega. She had the freedom to choose whether to be claimed by her mate or be someone's chosen. And so she thought, until the reality of her past came hunting her.  Alpha Caspian knew from the very beginning that he wanted Andrea, whether they were fated mates or not. But by the time he was ready to make amends for sending her away when she was 15, a secret from her past had resurfaced.  Would he let her go this time? Or was she worth fighting for? ***** A spin-off novel from the Black Shadow Pack Series. While the story is stand-alone, I recommend that you read the Black Shadow Pack Series to gain a better understanding of the characters.
9.9
115 Chapters
Mine - The Alpha's Possession
Mine - The Alpha's Possession
After living with her father and evil stepmother in their werewolf pack for the last year, Taylor is finally asked to return to her mother and her original pack. What she had been wanting the whole time she was living with her father. But upon her return she learns that the pack has been taken over by another pack and is under a new Alpha after the previous Alpha disappeared. She needs to adjust to a whole new pack then the one that she thought she was going home to. But she knew that her friends were there and that's what she was counting on getting her through this terrible time. Little did she know that the terrible times were just starting, and the Alpha, he wasn't the enemy that she was facing. With a lot of betrayal from the people that she trusted the most and the family that she never knew that she had, she is in for a lot of surprises and a lot of suspense and surprises that she never would have seen coming in a million years.
9.1
635 Chapters
STEPUNCLES' ALPHAS, PUNISH ME EVERYNIGHT (STEPSERIES#2)
STEPUNCLES' ALPHAS, PUNISH ME EVERYNIGHT (STEPSERIES#2)
"Tell me, Barbie…" Dante’s voice was a dark caress, low and sinful as he caged me against the wall. His fingers trailed down my neck, slow and teasing, making my breath hitch. "Are you trying to run from us… or are you waiting for one of us to catch you?" I hated how my body reacted, how warmth curled between my thighs despite the warning bells in my mind. "You’re trembling," Dante murmured, his lips brushing the sensitive skin of my neck. Knox chuckled, his grip tightening. "You’re so soft, Little Moon. So easy to tease. Tell me…" His voice dipped lower, "Are you shaking because you’re afraid… or because you’re turned on?" A small gasp escaped before I could stop it. Adonis’s gaze darkened, his thumb dragging over my bottom lip. "We should punish her for trying to leave," he mused. Dante’s smirk was pure sin. "Oh, I have so many ideas." "We could tie her up," Knox added casually, fingers tracing slow, lazy circles against my hip. "Make her beg for mercy." Three ruthless Alphas. Her step-uncles. Her fated mates. In her past life, Adonis, Knox, and Dante Logan hated her—tormented her, rejected her, and cast her aside. She died knowing they had never loved her. But fate has given her a second chance. Now, she’s running before they realize the truth—that she is their mate. Because once the Logan Brothers find out? They’ll never let her go.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
3 Chapters
My Ex Wife Is a Mysterious Billionaire Doctor
My Ex Wife Is a Mysterious Billionaire Doctor
After a painful divorce and six months off the radar, FL returns to the city with a new energy, and a mysterious aura. She’s the billionaire doctor Dominic, her ex husband has been looking for.
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
15 Chapters
Two Months Before Leaving You
Two Months Before Leaving You
Kara Hatchett once dreamed of Derrick Whitney’s love. Why shouldn’t she? He married her after all. But three years have passed since her secret marriage to the billionaire, and Derrick seems to dislike her more than ever. Even worse, his ex-college sweetheart, Jade Black is back in town after breaking his heart and stealing from his family before she left, but Derrick seems to have forgiven her. Even worse, he’s publicly in love with her, and acting like the doting boyfriend even if he refuses to acknowledge her as his girlfriend. So, with only two months left in their contract, Kara knows their marriage is over. She’s ready to bury the remnants of her unrequited love for him and move on with her life, ready to divorce Derrick and leave him without looking back. But Derrick isn’t letting her go…
คะแนนไม่เพียงพอ
10 Chapters

Related Questions

What is the climax of the novel the giver?

3 answers2025-04-16 06:02:01
The climax of 'The Giver' hits hard when Jonas decides to escape the community with baby Gabriel. This moment is intense because it’s not just about running away—it’s about rejecting the entire system of sameness and control. Jonas realizes the truth about release and can’t stomach the idea of Gabriel being killed. The weight of his decision is crushing, but it’s also liberating. He’s choosing uncertainty and pain over the false comfort of his world. The scene where he leaves is filled with tension, especially when he hears the search planes overhead. It’s a turning point that shows the power of individual choice, even in the face of overwhelming conformity.

What are the major symbols in the novel the giver?

4 answers2025-04-16 10:30:24
In 'The Giver', the major symbols are deeply woven into the narrative, each carrying profound meaning. The sled represents both the joy of freedom and the pain of knowledge. It’s the first memory Jonas receives, a thrilling ride down a snowy hill, but it also foreshadows the harsh realities he’ll face. The color red symbolizes emotions and individuality, things stripped away in the community. When Jonas first sees an apple change, it’s a glimpse into a world of vibrancy and choice. The Gabriel is another powerful symbol, embodying hope and the future. His presence pushes Jonas to question the society’s norms and ultimately to escape. The river, on the other hand, stands for boundaries and the unknown. It’s both a barrier and a pathway, reflecting Jonas’s journey from ignorance to enlightenment. These symbols collectively highlight the themes of memory, emotion, and the cost of conformity.

What is the main conflict in novel the giver?

3 answers2025-04-16 20:38:34
In 'The Giver', the main conflict revolves around Jonas, a young boy living in a seemingly perfect, controlled society. As he begins his training to become the Receiver of Memory, he uncovers the dark truths behind his community’s utopian facade. The conflict is internal and external—Jonas struggles with the moral weight of the memories he inherits, which reveal emotions, pain, and beauty that his society has erased. Externally, he faces the challenge of deciding whether to conform to the system or rebel against it. The novel explores themes of individuality, freedom, and the cost of sameness, making Jonas’s journey a gripping exploration of what it means to truly live.

What are the rules of the community in the novel the giver?

4 answers2025-04-16 23:49:56
In 'The Giver', the community operates under strict rules designed to maintain order and eliminate conflict. Everyone is assigned a role at the Ceremony of Twelve, and personal choices are almost nonexistent. Families are created through application, and children are assigned to them. Emotions are suppressed, and 'Stirrings'—early signs of puberty—are treated with medication. Precision of language is enforced to avoid misunderstandings, and lying is forbidden, though the Elders themselves lie to maintain control. The community also practices 'Sameness,' erasing differences in appearance, climate, and even memory. The Giver holds the collective memories of the past, both painful and joyful, to shield the community from discomfort. Release—a euphemism for euthanasia—is used for the elderly, rule-breakers, and even infants who don’t meet standards. The rules create a facade of harmony, but they strip away individuality and freedom, leaving a hollow existence.

What is the role of the Receiver in the novel the giver?

4 answers2025-04-16 21:57:28
In 'The Giver', the Receiver of Memory is a unique and crucial role in the community. This person is chosen to hold all the memories of the past—both the beautiful and the painful—so that the rest of society can live in a controlled, emotionless state of 'Sameness'. The Receiver carries the burden of knowledge, experiencing things like color, love, and pain, which others are shielded from. This role is essential because it allows the community to function without the chaos of history, but it also isolates the Receiver, making them the sole keeper of truth. Jonas, the protagonist, is selected as the new Receiver, and through his training with The Giver, he begins to understand the depth of what has been lost. The memories awaken him to the richness of life, but also to the cruelty of the system. The Receiver’s role is not just to store memories but to advise the Elders when they face decisions that require historical context. Ultimately, Jonas’s journey as the Receiver leads him to question the very foundations of his society, pushing him to make a choice that could change everything.

How does novel the giver end and what does it mean?

4 answers2025-04-16 10:27:46
In 'The Giver', the story ends with Jonas and Gabriel escaping their controlled, emotionless community, heading toward 'Elsewhere'—a place Jonas believes holds freedom and true life. The final scene is ambiguous: Jonas sleds down a snowy hill, hears music, and sees a warm, glowing house. Some interpret this as him reaching a new, vibrant society; others see it as a hopeful yet uncertain moment, possibly even his death. The ending challenges readers to decide whether Jonas’s journey is a triumph or a tragedy. What makes this ending profound is its exploration of choice and humanity. Jonas’s escape symbolizes the rejection of conformity and the pursuit of individuality, even at great risk. The ambiguity reflects life’s uncertainties—sometimes, the bravest acts don’t guarantee clear outcomes. It’s a reminder that true freedom comes with both beauty and danger, and that the unknown, while terrifying, is where real life begins.

What are the most memorable moments in 'The Giver' novel?

3 answers2025-04-14 09:00:27
The most unforgettable moment in 'The Giver' for me is when Jonas receives his first memory of snow and a sled ride. It’s a stark contrast to the colorless, controlled world he’s always known. The vividness of the experience—the cold, the speed, the joy—awakens something in him. It’s not just about the memory itself but what it represents: the beauty of individuality and emotion, things his society has stripped away. This moment plants the seed of rebellion in Jonas, making him question the cost of their so-called utopia. If you’re into dystopian novels that explore the human spirit, 'Brave New World' by Aldous Huxley is a must-read.

What is the significance of color in novel the giver?

5 answers2025-04-16 22:23:02
In 'The Giver', color is a symbol of emotion, individuality, and the richness of life that the community has sacrificed for sameness and control. The absence of color in their world reflects the suppression of feelings and experiences, making everything bland and uniform. When Jonas starts seeing flashes of red, it’s like a crack in the facade of their controlled society. It’s not just about the color itself but what it represents—the ability to feel, to choose, to see beauty and pain. The apple, the sled, Fiona’s hair—these glimpses of color awaken something in him that he can’t ignore. It’s the first step toward understanding the depth of what’s been taken from them. The Giver explains that color was removed to eliminate differences, but Jonas realizes that those differences are what make life meaningful. Color becomes his rebellion, his connection to a world that’s vibrant and alive, not just functional. It’s a reminder that without color, without choice, life is just existence, not living. For me, this theme resonates deeply because it’s not just about the literal absence of color but the metaphorical loss of diversity and freedom. It’s a commentary on how societies can strip away what makes us human in the name of order. The way Jonas’s perception of color evolves mirrors his growing awareness of the world’s complexities. It’s a powerful reminder that beauty and pain are intertwined, and that a life without either is incomplete. The significance of color in 'The Giver' is a call to embrace the messiness of life, to cherish the differences that make us unique, and to fight for the freedom to feel and choose.
สำรวจและอ่านนวนิยายดีๆ ได้ฟรี
เข้าถึงนวนิยายดีๆ จำนวนมากได้ฟรีบนแอป GoodNovel ดาวน์โหลดหนังสือที่คุณชอบและอ่านได้ทุกที่ทุกเวลา
อ่านหนังสือฟรีบนแอป
สแกนรหัสเพื่ออ่านบนแอป
DMCA.com Protection Status