Caroline’s Point of View
My husband’s first love ruins our third year anniversary.
I’m sitting by the window of a fancy restaurant, nervously waiting for Knoxx, my husband. I dress up in my favorite black dress. It’s been three years of marriage—three years of hoping, waiting for the man I love to finally see me, to finally understand that I’m more than just a wife of convenience. That it is not all about the arranged marriage.
I fiddle with the napkin in my lap, glancing at the clock, watching as each minute crawls by. Any moment now, Knoxx will walk through the door.
Tonight feels different. Tonight, I feel like something is going to change.
I had seen the headlines earlier this week:
[Wayne Corp Heir Spends Fortune on Rare Ruby Necklace—A Gift for Someone Special!]
"Someone special." Those two words have been ringing in my head ever since I read them. Who is more important to him than me, his wife?
After all the distance between us, the missed anniversaries, the cold silences… perhaps Knoxx*is finally ready to show that he cares. Perhaps tonight is the night he makes it all right.
The restaurant is warm and inviting, there are clinking glasses and soft conversation filling the air. But as time keeps ticking, the hope begins to fray.
Where is he?
Glancing toward the door once more, my heart skips a beat because the doorman straightened.
"Mr. Wayne," he says, and my breath hitches up in my throat.
I see Knoxx step through the door, and my breath catches in my throat. He’s dark-haired, with rich, wavy locks that frame his chiseled face perfectly, drawing attention to his sharp jawline and the faintest hint of stubble that adds an edge to his striking appearance. His deep-set blue eyes sparkle with an intensity that always made me feel seen, as if he could look right into my soul.
Today, he’s wearing a tailored suit, accentuating his broad shoulders and slim waist. The fabric hugs him just right, giving him an air of effortless confidence. As he moves, there’s a grace to him, a natural charm that seems to pull everyone’s attention, including mine. It was this combination of charisma and good looks that made it so hard to let go.
He's holding a bouquet of red roses, their petals like dark, velvety wine. And for a second, everything inside me melts. I knew it. He’s coming. Just like I told my father, Knoxx is learning to love me. Maybe, just maybe, our marriage is going to be what I’ve always dreamed it could be.
I begin to rise, ready to meet him, when something stops me cold.
Knoxx does not walk towards me. He does not even glance my way. My heart starts racing with confusion. Instead, he walks past me, his long strides carrying him towards a table across the room. My brow furrows and a dull throb is beginning to form at the base of my head.
Then, he stops in front of someone else.
A sexy blonde woman. She’s strikingly beautiful, and my heart sinks further as I realize she’s holding her arms open for him. They embrace warmly, smiling at each other like they share a secret the world doesn’t know about. A secret I’m not a part of.
Before I can fully register it, my breath catches in my throat as the woman turns, her profile coming into full view. It’s Dolly—Knoxx's ex-girlfriend. The one I've always known he's kept close, even if he never said it outright.
All of a sudden, my bloodstream rushes to my head, my vision blurs over for a moment, hit by it like a tidal wave of realization—she's wearing the ruby necklace.
The ruby necklace he bought at auction.
The one I thought was for me.
I freeze. It's as if time closes its doors. My hands tremble in my lap, and the noise of the restaurant fades into the background as my entire world crumbles around me. He bought it for her.
Rage burns hot in my chest. Before I can think, I rise from my chair, my fists curling at my sides. I want to storm over, to tear that necklace off her neck and wipe that smirk off her face. I want to confront Knoxx—demand to know what he thinks he’s doing.
My legs move before my brain can catch up, but just as I take a step forward, a waiter gently places his hand on my arm. “Ma’am,” he says softly, his voice like a tether pulling me back to reality. “Is everything alright?”
I stop. The fury boiling inside me cools just enough for me to take a breath. I can’t make a scene. Not here. Not now. I sink back into my chair, my entire body trembling with restrained emotion. I watch as Knoxx leans down to whisper something in Dolly’s ear. She giggles, her fingers brushing against his arm. My throat tightens painfully.
The world feels too bright, too sharp as I turn away from the scene and push myself to stand. I don’t want to be here anymore, to witness whatever connection they still share. The evening that started with so much hope has turned into a nightmare I never imagined.
I hardly remember the ride home. It's the walk through that door where the silence in our house is deafening. The room is appointed just as I envisioned it for tonight, soft candlelight flickers against the walls casting the shadows across the space, the dinner table set for two. Fresh flowers sit in the middle, the scent of roses filling the air.
Everything was for him. For us.
But he wasn’t here.
I kick off my heels and throw my purse onto the sofa, wiping at the tear that finally breaks free. The pain is suffocating, but beneath it, something else simmers. Betrayal. Anger. Desperation.
I pour myself a glass of wine and sit in silence, staring at the room I spent hours preparing. How could I have been so naive? How could I have believed that after everything, he would finally see me? Love me?
After a moment of drinking, the front door clicks open and freezes me. I listen for the all-too-familiar step as Knoxx walks in, his presence filling the room. I don't look up. Not yet.
He pauses, looking at the decorations, the candles, the effort I made to make this night special. His eyes settle on me, and I can feel his glance, but I cannot meet it.
"You forgot, didn't you?" My voice is quiet but the pain in it is unmistakable.
Knoxx doesn't say a word for a moment. Then finally, in a completely flat tone, he utters, “I’m sorry. I forgot the anniversary date.”
The silence stretches between us like a canyon. I hate how cold he looks. How detached. This was supposed to be a special night. A night where we might have finally connected.
“Where were you?” I ask, my voice trembling.
"Celebrating Dolly's birthday," he says, coldness in his voice as always. "I promised her I'd be there."
The words dangle between us, bitter and sharp. I gawk at him, jaw dropped in disbelief.
Dolly. Again.
"Dolly's birthday? Y-You promised her?" My voice breaks. "What about me? Your wife? What about our anniversary? The promises you made to me?"
Knoxx's gaze hardens. He reaches into his suit pocket, pulls out a checkbook, and scrawls his signature across a piece of paper. “Here.” He tears the check from the book and places it on the table in front of me. “One million dollars. Buy whatever you want. Consider it an apology.”
I stare at the check, bile rising in my throat. My tears threaten to blur my vision. One million dollars? This is all he sees this as? He doesn’t get it. He never has.
“I don’t want your money,” I whisper, my voice laced with a bitter laugh. I stand and face him, hands trembling, my heart breaking into a thousand pieces. “This happens every year. You miss our anniversary, you spend it with someone else, and then you throw money at me like it’s supposed to fix everything.”
Knoxx’s expression shifts. His eyes darken as he folds his arms over his chest. The warmth that I imagined earlier when he walked into the restaurant is completely gone. He’s like a block of ice now.
“Isn’t that why you married me?” he says coldly. His words slice through me like knives. “For the money?”
I flinch as if he’s struck me. The air leaves my lungs, and I can’t breathe for a moment. He thinks I’m with him for his money? After everything I’ve done? After three years of humiliation and trying to be the wife he wanted, he still sees me as nothing more than a gold-digger?
“Do you really think that I married you for your money?” I whisper, my voice barely audible.
Caroline’s Point of ViewI sit there, frozen, still reeling from the words that left Knoxx’s mouth just moments ago.“Didn’t you marry me for the money?”The question loops in my mind like a broken record, leaving behind a sting I can’t shake. Did Knoxx always think that? That I only wanted his wealth? That I had trapped him in this marriage? The weight of the accusation presses down on me, suffocating in its cruelty."Is that really what you believe?" I ask quietly, my voice barely audible as I look at him. "That I married you for the money? That I forced you into this?"Knoxx's expression is unreadable, the same cold mask he always wears, but there's a flicker in his eyes—something dark, something cruel. He doesn’t answer immediately. Instead, he picks up my half-finished glass of wine from the table and takes a slow sip. The silence stretches between us, heavy and unbearable.“You don’t love me,” he finally says, setting the empty glass down with a soft clink that echoes in the qui
Caroline’s Point of View“Girl, let me take you somewhere nice,” Penelope, my best friend, says, her voice wrapping around me like a warm hug. She’s leaning against her sleek new sports car, a knowing smile playing on her lips, as if she can see through the mask I’m trying so hard to keep up.I step out of the house, trying to leave the weight of everything behind me, but the hurt sticks. Penelope’s eyes catch on something near the front lawn, and she bends down to pick it up.“What’s this?” she asks, curiosity lacing her voice as she holds up a delicate black box, gold lettering gleaming in the fading evening light.My stomach churns. I know exactly what that box is. The jewelry box—the same kind Knoxx used when he bought Dolly that ruby necklace at the auction. I take it from Penelope, my hands shaking as I pop it open. Inside are two diamond earrings, beautiful but cold. They shine, but not for me.I snap the box shut, my chest tightening.“They were probably for Dolly,” I mutter, m
Caroline’s Point of ViewThe air feels thick as I approach the café. My hands tremble slightly, though I force them to remain at my sides, steady. I’ve run this moment over in my head so many times, imagining the words I’d say, how I’d keep my composure, but now that it’s real, there’s an uncomfortable tightness in my chest. I push open the door, the chime overhead ringing lightly, a sharp contrast to the heaviness I feel inside.Dolly is already there, seated in a corner, legs crossed, looking like she stepped straight out of a magazine. Her hair is perfect, her makeup flawless, and her lips curl into a smile that doesn’t reach her eyes.“Caroline,” she says, her voice dripping with saccharine sweetness, like we’re old friends. “You’re right on time. Why don’t you sit? We have a lot to discuss.”I don’t bother with pleasantries, cutting right to the point. “You’re back, and I want to know why. What are you planning?”She leans back, her smirk growing. “Oh, Caroline,” she sighs, like
Caroline’s Point of ViewAfter that confrontation with Knoxx, I don’t go home. I drive to my childhood estate, the house looming larger than I remember. It sits cold and imposing, framed by perfectly manicured gardens and tall hedges. The driveway stretches ahead of me, lined with palm trees that stand stiffly, like silent sentinels.As I step inside, the chill in the air bites immediately. No laughter, no warmth—just the grand, empty space filled with imposing furniture and unyielding silence. It’s the home of a businessman, a place as reserved as the man who owns it.“Ah, the prodigal daughter returns,” a voice calls from the living room.I follow the sound and find my father seated in his usual spot: a luxurious leather armchair by the fireplace, sipping his tea. His gaze, cold and discerning, doesn’t soften as he looks at me, though a trace of surprise flits across his features.“So,” he says, his voice laced with a blend of sarcasm and faint satisfaction, “the man finally abandone
Caroline’s Point of ViewFor the first time in my marriage, I don’t go home. I can’t. Instead, I find myself in my childhood bedroom, curled up in the familiar but almost stifling atmosphere of my father’s mansion. I try to process everything he said to me when I arrived. The warmth I had once imagined in this place doesn’t exist. He was right in a way I didn’t want to admit; I don’t deserve to be treated like this, but his reminders sting rather than comfort me."You’re the heir of this family," he had said sharply, his voice more cutting than compassionate. "Stop hiding from the world. You were a fool to think that man would ever see your worth.”It’s a familiar kind of pain, this undercurrent of disappointment. His version of love has always felt conditional, tied to expectations I’ve never fully met. Part of me knew coming here would reopen these old wounds, but somehow, it’s grounding. His disappointment is something I’ve grown used to, and it reminds me of why I married Knoxx in
Caroline’s Point of ViewAs I step into my room, my stomach tightens at the sight before me—my suitcases, their contents strewn across the ground. Clothes spill out haphazardly, a few scattered personal items lying in plain view, as though my life here is being rummaged through and dissected.Our maid has been going through my things in a rush, as if looking for something. And in the corner of my bed, I see Karen, Knoxx’s mother, with cross arms.“What are you doing?!” I ask angrily while I start to gather my things and put them in my suitcase.Karen’s sharp eyes narrow as they settle on me, her lips curling with that same disdain I’ve grown accustomed to. Without a word, she strides up and yanks my suitcase from my hand, her grip unyielding. “I need to check if you’ve taken anything that doesn’t belong to you,” she says, each word heavy with contempt, as though she expects to find priceless jewels tucked away in my clothes.I blink, momentarily stunned. “There’s nothing in this house
Caroline’s Point of ViewAdrian?I turn and see Adrian standing in the doorway, his face unreadable but his presence a silent challenge. There’s a determination in his eyes, a calm strength that speaks louder than words.Adrian’s sharp gaze sweeping over Knoxx and then settling on me. His sudden appearance feels like a lifeline and a complication all at once.His unexpected appearance throws me off. I blink in surprise, unsure of how to react. Do they know each other?Knoxx, however, doesn’t waste a moment before his lips curl into a cold, mocking smile. “Well, well,” Knoxx says, his voice thick with disdain. “It wasn’t enough for you to marry me, Caroline. Now you’ve moved on to seducing my stepbrother? How many men are you juggling these days?” I feel the heat rise in my cheeks, a mix of anger and humiliation surging through me. Before I can even find the words to reply, Adrian steps forward, his jaw set and his eyes burning with fury. “Don’t slander Caroline,” Adri
Caroline’s Point of View "Caroline," he begins, his voice uncharacteristically tentative. "I want you to know... I didn’t hide my connection to Knoxx on purpose. I didn’t want to overwhelm you with my past, and, truthfully, I haven’t been in that family’s inner circle for years. Being Knoxx’s brother… it’s complicated.” He pauses, looking away as though gathering his thoughts. “Our father pushed me out of the picture a long time ago. I haven’t had a stake in the family business or influence over them in years.”The sincerity in his tone makes my heart ache a little. Adrian has always been someone I could count on, especially recently, yet he’s been carrying the weight of his own complicated family history this whole time.“I know you didn’t mean to hide anything, Adrian,” I say softly, hoping to reassure him. “And it’s not your fault. I don’t hold any of it against you.”He offers me a small, grateful smile, but his expression grows serious again as he glances toward the door of the l
Caroline Point of ViewThe next day, I arrive at my shop early,expecting another day of long hours of cleaning up and fixing the mess of theday before. But when I emerge onto the sidewalk, I am stopped. The walls thathad been defaced with vulgar graffiti just yesterday are spotless. The crudewords spray-painted across my store’s sign are gone, as if they were neverthere. Even the sidewalk, which had been littered with trash, looks freshlycleaned.I blink, confused. Did the city workersclean it up? No, that wouldn’t make sense. There’s no way they’d work that fastfor a single shop.Then, I hear it.“Miss Hill, we are truly sorry!”I turn sharply toward the voice and see thesame group of men from yesterday—the ones who had demanded a protection fee.The same gangsters who had laughed when I told them I wasn’t paying them asingle cent. But now, instead of smug arrogance, they look… terrified.One of them, a burly man with a scarrunning down his cheek, actually bows. “We had no
Caroline’s Point of ViewI take a step back and look over the shop,pride swelling to the surface of my chest. The glass display cases, recentlyinstalled, shine with gentle light, and walls boast decorations of equally goodtaste carefully selected to enhance the classy image I had envisioned. My ownjewelry studio at last appears to be coming together. It has not been easy andI know there is more to come, but seeing it all begin to come together fills mewith hope.Tomorrow, I will have a soft opening, alow-key announcement to inform people that my brand is here. I don't want a biglaunch—just a steady, solid beginning. My work will speak for itself, and Ibelieve in it enough to know it will.But my happiness does not last long.The instant the front door is flung open, arough looking of men enter. There are three of them—tough-looking,leathery-clad, and with the odor of smoke about them. There is one, the tallestone, with a scar down the left side of his cheek. He advances fo
Dolly’sPoint of ViewIscroll through my phone, tapping my fingers on the screen as I read theannouncement for the jewelry design competition in Italy. A sneer forms on mylips. This company? I've never regarded them highly. They boast about theirtradition and craftsmanship, but they don't stand out to me. Yet, thecompetition is reputable, and the media attention is extensive. It’s the sortof opportunity that could transform someone’s life.Notthat I need them to change mine. I’m already the best. But I need leverage. Ineed a reason for Knoxx to finally take the next step.I turnmy head slightly, stealing a glance at him from across the room. He’s sprawledon the couch, his arm draped casually over the back as he watches my daughterplay with one of her toys. This moment should fill me with warmth, but instead,I feel a surge of frustration.It’sbeen years. Years since Caroline left. Years since I came back. And yet, hestill refuses to marry me. Still refuses to make ‘our’ f
Caroline’sPoint of ViewStaringat the laptop, I sit at my desk; the official announcement of the comingjewelry design contest in Italy blinks in front of me. My fingers hover aboutthe keyboard as I read the details for the tenth time.One ofthe most prestigious competitions in the industry, conducted globally by one ofthe oldest and most well-respected jewelry houses, the grand prize ismembership with them. But that is not why I am interested—more so with therecognition, not a position there. My new studio is just starting to find itsfeet, and to win or even just leave a mark in this competition might meangetting my break.Myheart starts racing as I almost lose my breath. Part of me is eager; that's thedrive to be able to prove myself. Another part lingers-a part that remembersthe hurt of last times.Welteringmemories, both unwelcome and painful, down into my mind-I remember back to whenI was last involved in such a competition. The anticipation and all that joylightin
Caroline’s Point of ViewI step into my home, feeling the warm comfort wraparound me like a warm blanket. Vanilla and the scent of something sweet bakingin the oven fill the air. It makes me feel welcome, relaxing me and comfortingme like I'm at home. It's the kind of warmth I imagined a family wouldhave, this feeling of being at home and comforted that overcomes me. I drop mybag on the floor and take a moment to soak it all in. In a flash, a tiny shaperuns towards me, breaking my moment of tranquility."Mommy! You're home!" My son launcheshimself into my arms, wrapping them around me. I wrap mine around him,breathing in his scent, feeling the strong beat of his little heart againstmine."I'm home, sweetheart," I whisper,leaving a kiss on the crown of his head.He looks at me, his eyes shining. "Daddy'smaking my birthday cake! It'll be out soon. He'll be out in a minute!"Wait!Daddy?I freeze. The warmth in my chest stutters for abrief second.I glance around. The house
Caroline’s Point of ViewI am paralyzed with shock. My breath getsstuck somewhere in the throat and my heart pounds in my chest. This isoverwhelming. I'm not sure what to say or think as thereality of his words sinks in.What?Before I can even process his words, theworld around me blurs, and everything else fades into the background.He said what?I stare at Adrian, my heart pounding, my brainstruggling to process his words."You… what?" I manage to say, my voicetrembling and soft. Did I really hear him correctly? Did he genuinely just tellthe kindergarten that we were engaged? He leans back against the bench, licking his icecream as if he hasn't just dropped a bomb on me and, after a moment, smirks."Relax, I am just kidding."I blink, completely caught off guard."What?" I ask, trying to grasp what just happened. He laughs, obviously getting a kick out of myreaction. "I didn't say we were engaged. I just made a small donation tohelp them build a new playground. They ag
Caroline’s Point of ViewI still feel anxious after leaving thekindergarten. Even when I try to ignore it, it sticks in my mind. The best ofeverything should be offered to my son, and I feel that I failed him today.When we walked out, I still remember the look on his little face. It was atthat point his expression changed, his shoulders drooping like they were heavy.Despite being so young, he had to deal with rejection for something he didn'tdo wrong.That burden falls on me alone.I take a sharp breath and shake my head,trying to dispel the thoughts that haunt me. But they cling on, refusing to letgo.Adrian notices, of course. He always picksup on when something is bothering me. Whenever I am bothered by something, heis the first to pick up on it. Leaning against the kitchen counter, he watchesme poke cold food on my plate. "Caroline," he says, his voice amixture of softness and concern. “Stop overthinking.”I look up, surprised by his insight. “I’mnot—”“You are,” he g
Caroline’s Point of ViewI sit in the principal’s office and clutchthe edge of my chair and listen to her polite but firm refusal. Her expressionis neutral, professional; but I catch the judgement hiding in her meticulouslychosen words.“We thank you for your interest, Miss Hill,” she says with atight-lipped smile. "However, we have very limited spots available, and weprioritize students who come from stable backgrounds. That is morebeneficial for children than providing a quote-unquote stable or consistentenvironment."I stiffen. "My son has a supportiveand consistent environment," I say, keeping my voice calm even though mystomach twists. The principal folds her hands on the deskand nods, though her smile doesn’t meet her eyes. “I’m sure you do your best,but there are some challenges as a single mother that you may not anticipate.We have a very rigorous academic structure here, and we’ve noticed that children from two-parenthouseholds do really well in this kind of env
Caroline’s Point of ViewSilence fills the car, thick and heavy like a blanket. My son's question keeps replaying in my mind, over and over, making it hard to think of anything else.“If Uncle Adrian is not my daddy… then who is?”My breath catches. I feel Adrian still beside me, his hands frozen on the steering wheel.I turn to face my son, but no words come out. My heart pounds as I try to find an answer—one that won’t hurt him. And for the first time in a long time, I realize I don’t know what to say.I never thought he would ask this. I wasn’t ready for it. I had hoped he wouldn’t wonder about it, especially not now when things seemed so steady. I thought he was already seeing Adrian as his father. I thought he wouldn’t even ask about the man who should be here but isn’t. I tried to shield him from this difficult truth. Clearly, I was wrong.I take a deep breath, feeling shaky. I turn to look at him. His big, innocent eyes are focused on me, filled with curiosity and expectation