Home / Romance / Keeping Score / Chapter 5: Not the best kind of three way

Share

Chapter 5: Not the best kind of three way

Author: Tawdra Kandle
last update Last Updated: 2024-10-29 19:42:56
NATE

My mood didn't improve the next day. What my father had said lingered in my head, making me both angry and miserable at the same time. I avoided seeing Quinn, which was something I never did, and missing her only made me feel worse.

At lunch, I ignored the cafeteria and instead went outside, planning to spend the forty-five-minute period on one of the more remote benches that were scattered here and there on the school's lawn. I shivered as the autumn wind blew down the collar of my T-shirt and kicked myself for not grabbing my jacket before I left the building.

I'd just spotted an empty seat-and in the sun, no less-when Leo came loping across the grass, heading from the student parking lot toward the side doors of the school. He didn't see me at first; he had his head down and was wearing dark sunglasses. But when he did notice me, his steps slowed, and he paused just short of the sidewalk.

"Hey, Nate. Everything okay?"

"Maybe I should be asking you that. Where were you?" I nodded toward the parking lot. "You're sort of late."

"Yeah, sort of." He laughed once, kind of a harsh bark, and then pinched the bridge of his nose. "Late night, so I slept in a little. I didn't have anything pressing in class this morning, anyway."

I should've kept my mouth shut, but I was so fucking fed up with him. So angry for reasons that he probably wouldn't begin to understand. "Oh, yeah? Last I heard, all our classes require attendance. That's not optional in high school. At least, it isn't for most of us. Maybe for the great Leo the Lion, the teachers make exceptions." I couldn't keep the snarl from creeping into my tone.

"What's wrong with you? Who pissed in your cereal?" He crossed his arms over his chest and scowled at me. "Did I do something that I don't remember? Did I miss someone's birthday or something? Because you and Quinn have both had bugs up your asses."

"Nice of you to notice, Leo. You must've been a real dick to her yesterday, you know? Quinn was pretty upset after school when I walked her home."

He pulled off the sunglasses, and I could see his bloodshot eyes were narrowed. "I didn't do anything. She's the one who's causing all the shit with my friends, and then I stand up for her, and she ends up yelling at me. Saying I don't even know her anymore. I don't know what she expects from me. God, I don't know what either of you want. It's like you want to punish me for having other friends. For playing football. For having a goddamn life."

"You know what, Leo? Keep your fucking friends, your football and your life. Quinn and I don't need you. We have each other."

Leo's lips thinned into a tight line. "You'd like that, wouldn't you? Come to think of it, Nate, maybe you should be thanking me instead of giving me hell. If Quinn's so mad at me, that just makes more room for you, doesn't it? You'll finally have her all to yourself, which is what you've always wanted."

He was so close to the truth, so dangerously near to saying exactly what I was feeling, that my palms began to sweat with both fury and nerves. "At least I'd be smart enough to hold onto her if-if I ever got that chance. I'd never throw away her friendship."

Leo ran a hand through his short hair, making a low noise under his breath. It sounded almost like a growl. "I haven't thrown away anything. I just-it's better for her if I don't spend too much time with her. Quinn's not like the other girls around here, and the chicks who hang around the football team would eat her alive." His lips curled. "If she doesn't stop writing stupid shit about them in the newspaper, that's going to happen anyway. She's making it so the whole school hates her. They all think she's some uptight-" He was going to say something else but broke off. "I just want her to stop and think before she ends up with no friends at all."

"That's not going to happen, because I'll always be there for her. That's what real friends do. So if you can't be that kind of friend, Leo, to both Quinn and me, just stay the hell away from us."

"Are you sure that's what Quinn wants from me?" His jaw tensed. "Because I'd disagree. I think Quinn wants ...even more than friendship. That's the real issue here, isn't it? It's eating you up because even when we're fighting about something, she still wants me more than she'll ever want you." He leaned closer to me, dropping his voice into an intense whisper. "And even if she did go out with you, you'd never really know if she liked you for real or if was just ...pity."

My hands curled into fists, and I wanted to hit him. God, I wanted to knock him down on his smug ass, but even with my blood boiling, I was smart enough to know that wouldn't end well. I was fairly sure Leo would never hit me back, but I also knew I'd be more likely to hurt myself than him if I threw a punch.

Before I could make up my mind, he jammed the glasses back on his face and stalked away, opening the metal door to the school with so much force that it banged against the brick wall as he disappeared into the building.

I stood still for a moment, still too mad to move. All of the jealousy I'd harbored against Leo-years and years of it-surged through my blood, and God, just for one day, I wanted the ability to take off after him, grab him by the arm, spin him around to face me and then pound that arrogant expression off his face. Most of the time, I didn't let what I couldn't do bother me. It was pointless to wish for things that were never going to be. But I'd have given a year of my life to change my body at that moment.

Instead, I did the smarter thing, just like I always did. I found my bench, sat down, and willed my heart to stop pounding. I forced my mind onto something completely unrelated to Leo or Quinn, working out complicated equations in my head. By the time the bell rang, signaling the end of lunch, I didn't feel any better but I was calmer.

I stood up, ignoring the stiffness in my hips, and followed the same path Leo had taken into the school. Both my locker and my first afternoon class were at this end of the building, and I'd learned long ago to plot out any short cuts I could find.

Because I was moving slowly, the hallways were almost empty as I trudged down a short corridor that linked the two wider passages. I'd just turned in front of the steps that led down to the gym when I heard the voice.

"Hey, gimp."

My heart beat sped up. I knew who was talking without even looking up, because it was the same person who'd been torturing me in one way or another since junior high. Brent Collins had taken a special and vicious dislike to me early on, and I wished I could say I had no idea why. But in this case, I'd started it. We'd had math together in eighth grade, and when Brent had made a stupid mistake in front of the whole class, I'd been only too happy to point it out, making him look bad. Those had been the days when I'd channeled all my physical frustration into humiliating my classmates intellectually whenever I could. Unfortunately, some of them hadn't forgotten the embarrassment.

"Running late today? Oh, shit, I forgot, you don't run anywhere, do you?" He came at me from the back, but I didn't turn around. Wildly, I tried to figure out the nearest classroom I could duck into.

"'Sup, Collins?"

I risked a glance up, hoping to see someone-anyone-who might distract Brent long enough for me to get away. But of course, I couldn't catch a break-the two guys who'd wandered our way were Brent's buddies, Karl Hays and Tim Stewart. All three of them were linebackers on the football team, big hulking boys who were probably more accurately described as men now.

"Not much." Brent grinned and held out a fist to be pounded. "Gimp here's having trouble keeping up. I was just gonna give him a hand." The glee in his voice was unmistakable, and my earlier mad boiled back to the surface.

"Just leave me the fuck alone."

All three of them hooted with laughter. "Oooooh, gimp's got a gutter mouth now, huh? Dude, we're just trying to give you a hand." Karl shoved at my back, sending me skittering as I tried to keep my balance.

"Yeah. You just stand still, and we'll push you along the floor. Help you get to class on time, huh? You don't want to be late, right? You're a brain, aren't you? Smarter than the rest of us. So you know if I give you a decent kick in that direction, you're gonna end up getting to class faster. Huh?"

"Tim's a decent punter. Did you see the distance he got a few weeks back?"

Karl laughed. "Yeah, he's good. I don't want to see a lot of his work, you know? But nice to know we have him when we're in need, am I right?"

All three of them grunted in what I assumed was agreement, and I took advantage of their distraction. I began to move away slowly, focusing on the closed door across the hallway.

"Hey, gimp, where d'you think you're going? We were talking with you." Tim stood with his hands on hips, blocking my way. "That's rude. You don't just leave when your bros are shootin' the shit with you."

"Hell, yeah. That's rude." Karl echoed the sentiment.

I could feel my face getting redder, and my lungs were tight. Panic was making it harder to breathe. I reeled forward, almost falling into Tim's massive chest.

"Whoa, bud. What's the matter? You wasted or something? You walk like you are. Not cool, man. Personal space and all." Tim gave me a shove, the kind that a normal guy would be able to absorb. But for me, already off-kilter, that kind of force made me stumble backward into Karl.

The good news was that thanks to his tree trunk-like body, I didn't end up on the floor. The bad news was that he didn't exactly catch me so much as he pushed me away, making the situation even worse. I was basically a helpless body in motion, with no way to stop as long as they kept playing with me.

"Dude! Three way. Send him to me." Brent wiggled his fingers as though he was cajoling them into tossing him a ball. Karl chortled, gripped my upper shoulders with his vice-like fingers and threw me toward Brent.

I probably would've been all right. Even at that point, with the three of them playing monkey in the middle and using me a human football, I was pretty sure they'd get bored in a few minutes, or a teacher would hear the commotion and stick his head out the door of a classroom to shout a warning. I just had to get through it.

But just as Karl sent me toward Brent, we all heard a fourth voice come from the other direction, down the hall.

"Hey! What the fuck?"

It was Leo, and judging by his tone, he was pissed. Still mad at me? I wasn't sure and frankly didn't care. What did matter to me was the fact that when he yelled, Brent looked up at him, an expression of oh-shit on his face, and neatly sidestepped me.

Again, that still wouldn't have been the end of the world. I might've ended up sprawled on the tile floor, my book flying away from my hand, and they probably would've jeered and teased more ...but that would've been the end of it. Humiliation wasn't fun, but it didn't break bones.

But Brent was standing at the top of the short flight of steps that led down into the gym. I'd hated those steps since we'd started high school, because getting down them was awkward and embarrassing for me. There was a ramp alongside them, but more often than not, people stood there chatting, blocking my way, and having to push past was almost worse than navigating the steps. I was lucky that the rest of the school was on one-level, but still ...I detested that staircase.

And now I was getting an up-close and personal look at my nemesis as I pitched down them headfirst.

Panic flooded me, even as I flailed my arms to grab for anything that might slow me down. But the fear didn't last long, because the side of my head banged hard into one of the iron posts that supported the middle railing, and after a cruel, sharp knife of pain, everything went dark and silent.

Related chapters

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 6: I should've just stayed home

    LEOUp until junior year of high school, I'd been pretty good about limiting my partying to Friday and Saturday nights. During football season, of course, Coach was strict about us sticking to a curfew during the week leading up to a Friday night or Saturday afternoon game. But there were ways around that, and I'd become an expert in figuring out those ways. This week, we were playing on Saturday, which meant no one was too worried about Thursday night. I used the excuse of a history group project meeting to convince my parents I needed to be out. In the interest of maintaining plausibility, I did go to the meeting, made some contributions ...and then when it ended, I headed over to Matt's house.Matt Lampert and I had been buddies for years. Not close friends, like Nate and Quinn and me, but more casual-the way only boys seem to be able to manage. We didn't have deep conversations, but we played baseball or soccer or football together-pick-up games, usually-and joked around, like

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 7: What we do for friends

    LEOBehind me, Quinn screamed. "Nate!" I heard the pounding of her feet, and I turned to catch her before she could trip and fall on top of him. My heart was thudding in dread, but I held it together enough to grip Quinn's upper arms, giving her a little shake. "Go get help. Do you have your phone? Call 9-1-1, and get-fuck, I don't know-get the school nurse or the principal or someone." Some of the horror cleared from Quinn's eyes, and she nodded, reaching in her back pocket for her phone even as she took off in the direction of the office. Once I was sure she was on her way, I jogged down the stairs to kneel next to Nate, careful not to jostle him as I tried to remember the little bit of first aid training we'd gotten in health class. Don't move him, in case his neck is broken. Bile rose in my throat. Nate was lying at an odd angle, but I didn't think he'd fallen far enough to have snapped his neck. "Taylor, shit, we didn't mean-" Brent was babbling behind me, fear evident in

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 8: What I was waiting for

    QUINNI fled down the hallway of the hospital and out the automatic doors into the waning afternoon sun. The air was chilly, and I shivered, wrapping my arms around my waist as I leaned against the bumpy stucco wall. My throat was tight with tears, but dammit, I wasn't going to cry. Not here, not where Leo might see me. I wasn't stupid. I'd known for a long time that this guy who wore my best friend's face and spoke with his voice wasn't the same sweet boy I'd known forever. No matter how much I lied to myself, no matter how many times I searched for any hint that Leo was still in there, it was time to face facts once and for all. Leo wasn't my friend. He wasn't Nate's friend, and even though he'd rescued Nate today, the sooner we accepted that truth, the sooner we could move on. Forget him. Pain held a vice-grip on my heart. For me, losing Leo meant more than just having one less friend. It also spelled the death of the dream that someday, he might be even more. I couldn't rememb

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 9: And then this happened

    QUINNLeo's eyes darted to mine, pleading. I knew what he was waiting for; he wanted my permission to tell Nate's mother the story the boys had concocted. The lie that was going to let Brent, Karl and Tim get away with what they'd done to Nate. I pressed my lips together, still tasting him there, and although I wasn't at all sure he was right, I gave a little nod."It was those steps by the gym. I guess Nate was heading to the locker room, and ...I don't know, he just fell. I was down the hall and saw him going down, but I couldn't do anything. Couldn't get there in time." Leo rubbed the back of his neck, giving an excellent impression of friend who was suffering from guilt. Or come to think of it, maybe he wasn't acting. "I think he hit his head on the railing. But the doctor said he was going to be okay. They just want to keep an eye on him. We saw him before he went up for a CT scan, and he was awake. He talked to us. They said maybe a mild concussion." "Oh, my God." Sheri close

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 10: The meds made me do it

    NATEI'd had some killer headaches in my day, thanks to the side effects of medication and other treatments, but this one was a definite contender for the worst one. I lay in my hospital bed, staring at the ceiling tiles and waiting for the dose of painkiller I'd just been given to take effect. "Nate." Quinn's voice was soft and questioning; she wasn't sure if I were truly awake or not. I steeled myself against the pain and turned my head just a little to track her movement toward me."I'm awake." My voice sounded faraway and kind of slurred. Yeah, maybe those meds were kicking in, after all."My mom and I are going to leave in just a minute. Is there anything ...do you need anything before I go?"I managed a smile. "Nah, I'm good." My lips felt dry and numb, and I licked them, wondering idly if Quinn might be turned off by dry lips. Should I ask her? No, I decided. I shouldn't point out any of my deficiencies, on the off chance she might not notice. "Okay. Well ...I guess I'

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 11: Why did I do that?

    LEOBy the time I made it back over to the high school and changed, the afternoon light was gray. Everyone was on the field, running drills, but I stopped on the sidelines where Coach Cramer stood, holding a tablet that looked just like the one the doctor had used at the hospital."Taylor." Coach nodded at me. "Mr. Platten filled me in on where you were. What's the news on the kid?"I shrugged. "Far as I know, doing okay. Doctor said he might have a mild concussion, and they're keeping him overnight, probably." I worked hard to keep the worry out of my voice. This entire afternoon had been a mess, from beginning to end. I wouldn't have minded just forgetting the whole damn day. The image of Quinn's eyes, soft and luminous when she'd looked up at after our kiss, filled my head, reminding me that maybe not all of it had been so bad. But no. Kissing Quinn had been a mistake of monumental proportions, and now I had to figure out an exit strategy. I'd seen the expression on her face ju

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 12: Taking precautions

    LEOI finished the last lap, not breaking stride as I jogged onto the field. Matt met me on the thirty-yard line, punching me in the shoulder. "Heard you had to rescue the gimp, dude. What happened?" I glanced over his shoulder. Tim stood about ten feet away, frowning in my direction. I narrowed my eyes, giving him a steely glare, and then turned back to Matt. "Tell you later, man. Hey, Coach says you warmed up with Simmons. What the fuck, dude, you cheating on me now?"Down the line, Dylan Simmons cracked up, shaking his head. "No worries on my part, Taylor. You and Lampert have something special. Something magical. It's a love for the ages, man. I'm not getting in the way of that.""Damn straight!" Lampert wrapped his arms around my middle and tried to haul me up. "We're like Romeo and fucking Juliet." Without pausing for breath, he added, "Dibs on being Romeo.""No problem, Houdini. You keep delivering your balls right into my waiting hands, and I'll be your Juliet every tim

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 13: Being invisible to the one who counts

    QUINNI hadn't expected to hear from Leo that night after he'd kissed me. Not really. Yes, I'd kept my phone in my pocket and then on my nightstand, and yes, I'd checked the volume and made sure the ringer was turned on about every fifteen minutes or so. But it hadn't surprised me when the phone stayed silent. It hadn't surprised me, but it had hurt. I'd already planned to go to the football game the next day. I went to every game, and I knew my parents wouldn't think twice about me heading there today. I'd texted with Sheri that morning and learned that the doctors wanted to keep Nate one more day, because he was still in a great deal of pain. I could almost feel her anxiety through the phone, even though she assured me that it was nothing to worry about. Go have fun today at the game. Give Leo a hug from me and scream for him like I do, LOL. I'll tell Nate you'll see him later. It felt weird to climb to the upper bleachers on my own, since usually I stuck to the first row, t

Latest chapter

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 131: Days of You and Me

    QUINNThe party was in full swing, with music blaring and the dance floor crowded. I was sitting on Leo's lap, with his arms circling my waist as we chatted with Zelda and Tucker. "Hey, did you see that?" Zelda nodded toward the crush of dancing couples. On the very edge, Gia was slow dancing with Tate Durham. She stared up into his face as he murmured to her, and I glanced back at Zelda with raised brows. "When did that happen?" I'd spent quite a bit of time lately with Zelda and Gia, who were both my bridesmaids, but Gia hadn't mentioned anything about Tate Durham. I didn't even realize she knew him, although thinking back, they must've met at Carolina, when we used to go see Leo and Matt."Got me. But they look mighty cozy.""She deserves a little happiness. And Tate's a good guy." Leo, who had been talking to Tucker about how brutal mini-camp had been this year, picked up on my last words. He followed my gaze to Gia and Tate and smirked. "Well, it's about time." "Hey.

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 130: The best choice I ever made

    QUINNThanks to the security team that we'd hired to keep the media and the curious public at bay, I could only barely see the people lining the perimeter of the roped-off section of the beach. I knew they were there, but it was okay; today of all days, I wanted to share all of my happiness with everyone and anyone. Behind me, the folding chairs that had been arranged on the portable wooden floor-and who knew they had such things!-were filled with our loved ones. We had quite a crowd, for what we'd both termed a small, intimate wedding, but then we were very blessed with both friends and family. My mother sat in the front row, flanked by Joe and Lisa on one side and Mark and Sheri on the other. Leo and I had dispensed with the silly idea of the bride's side and groom's side. We shared so many friends that making them choose which one of us to support would have been crazy. And our parents had decreed early on that they were all going to sit together, forming a united front. The

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 129: We earned this happily ever after

    QUINNWe'd been waiting in the empty, echoing corridor outside the locker room for twenty minutes. The guard had kindly but firmly told us that we couldn't go any further, but after Ellie had cajoled him, he'd promised to give us any update he heard and to talk to the trainer about letting us in as soon as it was possible. People swooshed through the hall, to and fro, but none of them showed us the least bit interest. A couple of reporters straggled down, but a non-life-threatening injury to a second year player who was only just beginning to show his strength wasn't exactly breaking news. I tried not to be bitter about that, thinking of all the times the press had hounded us about stupid stuff since Leo had been in college. One of the journalists was live streaming the game on his phone, with the volume pumped. Apparently the Rebels had made the extra point after Leo's touchdown, but New York had come back to score ten points after that-a fast touch down and then a field goal. Th

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 128: Number 22 is down

    QUINN"There's my boy!" Joe clapped his hands and whistled as the Rebels took the field for their first possession in the second half. We were up by two field goals, but with a team like New York, that wasn't quite a comfortable margin. "I told him we wanted to see him score today." Lisa nudged me. "Both times, it's happened when we weren't at the game. It's starting to give me a complex."I laughed. "I missed one of them, since it was on the road. So don't take it personally." Down on the field, the center snapped the ball into Gideon's hands. The quarterback stutter-stepped backwards, looking for an open receiver and then fired a pass downfield to a wide receiver, who caught the ball and took off. The crowd jumped to its collective feet, cheering him on. He made it to the twenty-eight-yard line before he was forced out of bounds by a New York player. We sat back down as the chains moved, and Joe patted my back. "This is going to be it, this next play. You watch. I've got a

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 127: Family reunion

    QUINN"I never knew it got so cold down south." Lisa Taylor wrapped her scarf a little more securely around her face. "I'm glad I remembered my gloves."On the other side of me, her husband leaned over. "Well, it is December, Lisa. You can't expect beach weather. Virginia isn't that far south."I bit my lip and tried not to laugh. Leo's parents had been down here for the last three days, visiting on what Joe called a 'pre-wedding mini-vacation' and what Lisa referred to as 'Joe's attempt to keep me from killing people'. Although they never really argued, they sniped at each other all the time, which made it less than fun to be around them. Apparently, being the parents of the groom was almost as stressful as being the bride's family. Simon had called us last week, griping about the tensions between Justine's parents and his own."You've got to take them off my hands for a little while, Leo. Please, I'm begging you." Neither of us had ever heard Simon sound so desperate. "All of the

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 126: This is our time

    LEOThe past and present jumbled for a moment in my mind. I had a sudden flash of memory, the feel of those legs wrapped around my back as I sank down into her, the weight of her breasts in my hands, the taste of her ...it was all so vivid and so immediate that I gave myself a little pinch to make sure she was really here now, and that I wasn't in the middle of some psychedelic mind trip. Then she smiled at me and spoke, her voice low and teasing, and I knew this was real. "Are you going to say something, or are you going to just lay there gaping at me? You're kind of freaking me out. I'm starting to worry that you're second-guessing the whole forever thing.""Babe. Never." I sat up and crooked my finger. "Come here. I'd go to you, but I seem to have lost the feeling in my legs."Quinn took a few steps closer to me, just beyond my reach. "You know, I realized something while I was getting changed.""Oh, yeah? What's that?" My eyes were glued to her fingers playing with the hem of

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 125: For the rest of our lives

    LEOI let her body slide down mine until her feet hit the floor. Looping my arms around her waist, I held her to me. "Mia, I know we've still got things to work out. I want to keep at it. I don't want to bury our shit under a rug or pretend we're perfect. But I want to deal with all of it together. I want us to be together, and not just for now, not until we see if things are good. I want you to live with me here, in this house I picked out because I could see you all over it."Quinn rested her cheek against my chest. I felt her tears soaking into my shirt, and I could only hope and pray that they were the happy kind. Swallowing hard, I went on, laying everything on the line and going for broke. In the back of my mind, I heard the old Eatonboro High Eagles chant: Go big or go home."Mia Quinn." I dropped to my knees and held both of her hands tightly in mine. "I love you beyond my ability to express it. I've loved you for so long that I can't remember when my heart didn't beat for y

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 124: Redux

    LEOThe last time Quinn had been in my house, I'd been in agony, wanting her and yet knowing the timing wasn't right yet. So as I led her up the steps and to my front door, I was determined to erase all the bad memories and replace them with only good ones.Before I turned the doorknob, I paused, gazing down at her. "The day I found this townhouse, I'd been looking at places all day. My mom was with me. Everyone had told me not to buy right away, in case I didn't last the season in Richmond or if I got traded or whatever, but I had a hunch. I knew I wanted to buy a place to live and not be just renting. I was ready for something permanent."She nodded, expectant. "I couldn't put my finger on why none of the houses seemed quite right. Then I realized it was because I couldn't see you in any of them. When I stood here for the first time, though, I turned around and looked at the neighborhood, the front lawn ...the view." I steered Quinn by the shoulders, pulling her back against me

  • Keeping Score   Chapter 123: About time

    QUINNBy the second half, Leo seemed to have found his rhythm. He caught several more passes and ran for a decent amount of yardage. When the clock hit all zeros, Richmond had won by ten points. I was ready to sprint down to the locker room, but Ellie caught my arm. "There's no rush, honey. Look." She pointed to the field, where the players were still milling around. "They'll be out there for a bit, doing some on-field interviews, and then they'll be in the locker room for a while before the post-game press conference. I doubt either Leo or Corey will be part of that today, but still-we don't want to be hanging out in the hallway until right before they come out. It's a mess. The press is there, and the jock junkies." She wrinkled her nose. "Okay." I sat down again. "So we just ...stay up here?""Yeah." Ellie lifted one shoulder. "Most of the wives take off and wait in the parking lot or meet their husbands at home. Corey and I have a tradition of meeting in the hall, so I don't

DMCA.com Protection Status