Home / Mafia / Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers / Chapter 5 : Taken Again

Share

Chapter 5 : Taken Again

Author: Scarlett Rossi
last update Last Updated: 2023-07-01 14:07:03

Eden POV

The police station is ice cold and full of detectives from all sorts of government agencies. I lean forward in my hard, metal chair, wrapped in a pathetic blanket that they give to all the terrified victims. They keep calling me a victim too, and I understand why, but I don't feel very victimized right now.

I feel hollow and lonely.

The detective finally gather's his paperwork, giving up in a resolute sigh after his interview went absolutely nowhere.

I denied knowing anything, just like I said I would, and accepted the fact that life will just have to go back to normal now. One of the other detective's steps into the room, his smile lighthearted like I've been tortured and relentlessly abused.

Instead, my experience was pleasant and thrilling and new.

I've needed new for so long that I didn't think it existed. Now that I've had it in my grasp, that I've tasted its abundance, I'm lost in a flurry of my own thoughts that are filled with Dante and Ryder.

"Ms. Smith," the detective says, standing nearby at just a moment's notice. "Are you okay? Did you hear what I said?"

"No, I'm sorry," I whisper. "I'm just a little… flustered."

"That'se understandable, Ms. Smith. I just wanted to let you know, we called your emergency contact, Jack Ward. He should be on his way to pick you up from the station now."

I stand, tossing the blanket on the table. "I'd prefer to walk now."

His brow furrows. "Is that the safest idea? You've been through something traumatic, Ms. Smith. We really suggest you go home with a trusted relative or friend so they can keep a close eye on you."

Jack is neither close to me, nor worthy of being trusted.

"I'll be fine, I promise. I just need time to decompress. I want to walk alone."

He hesitates with his reply, looking out at the hoard of bees in a rattled hive. I've never seen so many cops in one place, let alone so diligent to work on a heist where the only thing that was taken was a simple, silver box.

"I guess I can lead you out the east entrance," the detective says. "It would help you avoid all of the journalists out front."

I stammer in surprise. "Journalists?"

"You've become a newsworthy sensation, Ms. Smith. Everyone was cheering for your safe return."

Everyone, of course, except for me. I prefer the company of two licentious bank robbers than I do the attention of cops and journalists. Not to mention how desperately I don't want to see Jack after his plot of whimpering on TV.

The alley plagues my mind, my feet dodging gritty potholes and smokers on their breaks from work. I think of the getaway car speeding up to my side, whisking me away in a dangerous format.

I try to remember that fear, but it solely resonated on the unknown, not the intent of those men who took me. After that first night, I don't think I feared them again. Why can't I be afraid now? Looking at my face on the news, at the footage of the bank being robbed, it was troubling.

I laid with the lions once, and now I felt like I had a connection to a pride.

Make it make sense.

I knock on the apartment door. Jack opens it swiftly like he was expecting the pizza delivery man, or another hooker, to be on our stoop.

"Oh, my god, Eden," he says, jumping forward to wrap me in an unnecessarily taut hug. "I just got a call twenty minutes ago that you were at the police station. I was about to come pick you up."

Something really makes me doubt that claim, but I don't mention it.

Why the f*ck would he wait twenty minutes or even twenty seconds?

"Come on, get inside. You look awful, Eden."

I ignore his petting, still consumed in thoughts of my captors.

This newfound case of Stockholm's syndrome is beginning to unravel me.

"Come talk to me," Jack suggests, sitting back down on the couch with the game controller in hand. Sometimes I think it's fused into his palms, wires hooking up to his fingertips and refusing to unplug. "Where are you going?"

"I need a shower, Jack, I was abducted. I need a moment to collect myself."

He snorts a noise and shakes his head. "Oh, god. Don't be so dramatic."

He's gone from concerned to dismissive in record time tonight.

I stop in the doorway of the bedroom. The sheets are pulled halfway off the bed and pillows thrown to the floor, no doubt to make room for other activities than sleeping.

I won't ever lay in that bed again.

I would argue with him, but I can't, my throat closing in shortage of valor. Maybe Dante was right. I've returned to my shy and innocent life. Mason was right, too, in the claim that I came from this shitty life, and I was returned to it.

Through the solace of a shower, I wipe away any scent, any lasting impression of their touch, down the Manhattan sewer system.

I linger out of the bathroom in a comfortable top and loose-fitting jeans. Dressing normal at least feels like the right thing to do right now.

"Are you going to cook dinner?"

I glare holes through the back of Jack's skull. "No, Jack. I'm not."

"Why not?" he grumbles at the screen, playing a shooting game meant for bored teenagers.

"I'm going for a walk instead."

I grab a jacket and head outside, wet hair be damned, so that I don't have to explain the scenario to Jack. He is pathetically immersed in his video games, in his constant cheating, and his innate need to disregard basic human decency.

He cried to the news station about wanting me back, but he left out that he's a child who is incapable of cooking his own dinner and doing his own laundry. That's all our relationship is. I'd say he is more of a nuisance than a boyfriend.

But like I told Dante before, it's not worth the fight that follows when I attempt to break up with him.

We argue, he crosses the line, and I end up apologizing and sleeping on the couch.

I walk aimlessly down the sidewalks, wondering how terrible it would be to just sleep out here for the night instead of returning home. Anywhere but there would be better suited.

"Excuse me?"

I stop, hearing a deep voice. I eye the man standing nearby, his eyes squinted in curiosity. He's burly and thick, unwavering as very few pedestrians pass by between us.

"Are you Eden Smith, the woman who was kidnapped?"

I nod, groaning internally. "Yeah. That's me."

He smiles, popping the door open to the back of the car he leans on. His hand brushes his jacket where a large, silver gun is tucked into his waistband. I stare at the sight, a little numb to the reality of it after my last encounter with a pistol wielding crook.

"Get in."

I struggle to move, and he shoves me hard into the backseat, kicking at my legs to curl out of the way of the door he slams shut. I realize that he isn't anything like the bank robbers. I pull at the door handle and hit the glass, the stranger swinging the pistol backwards into the side of my face.

My body goes limp against the seats. Blood pulses from a cut under my eye.

"Ple—"

"Shut up! Stay down, or I'll hit you again!" He yanks the car into traffic, and I do as I was told, blinking back spots as the blood runs warmly down my jaw and throat. "Stop crying, dammit."

I sniffle, trying to compose myself. No matter how much I loathe Jack, I should have stayed back and put up with his ignorant antics. It would have been better than this.

The car finally screeches to a stop, and I tense, being flung out of the backseat by a firm grip on my arm. I hiss a breath and land on a polished concrete floor, taking in the sight of a fancy parking garage that isn't seeing much use.

Other than the car that I just pulled up, there's no other vehicles around this massive space, only a handful of very domineering and seemingly pissed-off men. They all wear similar suits, in shades that vary from gray to navy.

I don't move out of perpetual anxiety.

"Eden Smith, right?" the man in front of the group asks. He looks down the edge of my cheek, gawking at the bloody scratch that sits there now. "I'm going to need you to be on your best behavior, or there will be more retaliation than that measly cut."

I nod hastily. The man smiles in response.

"Someone take her into the suite."

Another man answers before anyone moves. "The lounge has strict rules on conducting business in—"

"I know the damn rules," he snaps. "It's not business if she behaves. The Donahue's just want to have a few words with her. There is no trouble if she doesn't cause any," he adds, looking down at me from above, "got it?"

"Yes," I chirp. "No trouble. I swear."

"See? She listens well enough. Someone escort her upstairs. Erik and Asher are up there waiting. You know how they are."

I don't recognize those names, but I have an overwhelming urge that tells me they have something to do with the robbery. I consider the countless possibilities while being dragged through an empty hallway and then shoved into a glass elevator. I sink to the floor in exasperation.

It's a long, silent trip down the next hallway before the man throwing me around kicks my knee inward, prompting me to hiss and fall into the wall nearby. I kneel on my wounded, aching leg while the door is yanked open haphazardly.

The specimen behind the door is broad and unwavering. He looks down through his light brown eyelashes to stare plainly at me, much like an exterminator would look at a rat in his path.

The man waves away my escort before coming down onto his knees in front of me. I breathlessly beg for mercy, for an explanation, for anything that would resolve my hyperventilating.

"Eden?"

I nod. At least they are thorough with every step in kidnapping me. They continue to ask if my name is correct. Due to my poor luck, it's correct.

"You don't have to be so scared. I'm harmless. I just want you to come into the room and answer some questions for me. Okay?"

He holds out a hand for me to take but I refuse, mesmerized by the gold flakes of his irises. He's a stoic breed of handsome, the kind that wears a suit and hangs out in fancy hotel rooms.

My only issue with that is… why I'm here with that kind of specimen.

I walk into the room, staggering my pace when I observe an older man with similar features sitting at the desk by the large bed. My heart punches through every pulse in agonizing panic.

"I'm Asher Donahue. This is my father, Erik," the younger man exhales, ushering me to sit on the bed.

He stands behind Erik, a man who doesn't react in legible emotion other than the deep and permanent creases of his rutted brow.

I'm stuck in memory of their last name. My eyes widen in horror.

"Donahue?" I ask. "As in the Donahue family whose safety deposit box was stolen?"

Erik flares his nostrils and snarls his response, "Yeah. That's right. Now, you're going to tell me who stole the contents of that box, and where they took it. Otherwise, we're going to have a f*cking problem here, Eden."

Related chapters

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 6 : Playing Dumb

    Eden POVThere's a weird silence in this hotel room. I used to pray for the same silence in my foster family's home. Everything was loud and chaotic and ever changing. I would sit still while the world blurred in movement around me.This silence is different from that.This is a penetrating, bleeding silence that slowly cuts at my surface until I fall into a lump of shredded discard. There's nowhere to hide in this room, to feel vulnerable, and they see that."I told the police everything that happened," I say at last, breaking the tensile silence.Erik waves his hand in the air, swatting away an imaginary bug. "I'm aware of what you told the police, Eden, but I don't believe you."I swallow. "I don't know anything else; I promise.""So you're gone for three days, but you don't see or hear or know a thing about where you went? Let alone, who took you in the first place? You can see how that seems very unlikely, right?"Trying to avoid Erik's eyes, I look to his son, who

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 7 : Jack Gets What He Deserves

    Eden POVStanding in front of Dante and Ryder Golden, a wash between stress, shock and lust flushes down my face. Everything is warm in my blood, everything is hectic in my mind, and yet they stand here so calm, so collected, like nothing happened."Hey, kitten," Dante purrs.I shudder, having released them as quickly as I'd thrown myself at them, and Ryder grins mischievously."Let me come in and clean that cut," Ryder says, moving past me and into the living room.I press my hand into his chest, eyeing the bedroom doors that are open wide enough for Jack to see, and hear, everything going on. A variety of apprehension builds in my chest. I don't need to wake Jack up right now."The cut is fine," I say, wiping my cheek with my wrist. The amount of blood isn't as bad as it looks: it didn't sting too bad, it just surprised me. "I can't let you come inside. If he wakes up, he will suspect something. I don't want him running to the cops."Ryder surrenders, stepping back inl

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 8 : Reunion

    Eden POVThey're trying to prove a point of some kind, but I can't determine what it is, exactly. I think they want me to feel owned by them, by their lips that swerve all around my shoulders and neck. I breathe deeply, Ryder's hand massaging my inner thigh while Dante is focused on toying with my hardened, enticed nipples.Someone tears me out of my shirt, leaving me naked and at the will of the brothers.Dante pulls me around, pressing my chest into his so he can be at the perfect angle to meet our lips together. Ryder shifts to stand behind me, his throbbing erection begging to be cut loose out of his pants. I beg for it too, dreaming of this moment since Mason kicked me out of the bed."Please," I beg, unsure for what, but it doesn't matter.Ryder latches his hands onto my hips, pushing me even closer against Dante, pinning me between them until I can't breathe. Dante kisses the front of my neck, and I let my head fall back into Ryder's shoulder.Every single touch,

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 9 : Reassurance

    Eden's POVIn my final foster family before getting booted out of the system, I was always expected to do the chores. After a while it became second nature to calm myself down, to center my hectic thoughts, by focusing my energy on cleaning.Jack always laughed when I went into my episodes of deep cleaning, and sometimes, on the days he was more disrespectful than usual, he would knock something over to cause a mess and set my nerves on fire.I'm thankful that even though Mason isn't a huge fan of me being in the brother's penthouse, he steps around me as I scrub the kitchen tiles and try to lighten the dirt in the grout. My attention is threaded between too many tasks at once, my heart racing.A suspect! They think I'm a suspect in a bank robbery!Mason leans on the counter, careful not to step on the soapy tiles of the kitchen floor. "I was thinking about making lunch but…"He gives me an exasperated look as I had spent all morning cleaning, reorganizing and perfecting th

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 10 : Thongs & Threats

    Eden's POVI wake up in Dante's bed, somewhere I know I didn't fall asleep last night. Ryder's bedroom is light in colors ranging from ivory to beige, while Dante's room sports dark gray walls and stark black bedding. No matter whose room I wake up in, I'm just happy I wake up with both brothers beside me.Dante has my back pinned to his chest, our bodies flushed together perfectly while Ryder has a light palm relaxed on my cheek, his touch so warm and electric. There's no easy way for me to get out of bed between them without waking everyone up at once.I stay put until Dante slowly awakens next, kissing the back of my tangled, brunette curls. He drags his hand up my bare thigh, and I realize that although we are under the warmth of his blankets, I'm the only one naked.We didn't do anything sensual after the blowout argument with Mason yesterday, but I think they like making me blush more than they like having sex with me. It works, too.I stop Dante's hand as it brushes my

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 11 : Survival

    Eden's POVI hurry and get dressed, running from the store to see Mason laid out on the concrete next to the car we drove out here. Falling to his side, I can't find the worst wound on his body, finding countless cuts and bloody splotches seeping through his clothes."Ma—Mason," I pant, my eyes blurred with frantic, scared tears. "Can you hear me? Can you move?"He only growls, holding his hip where blood covers his palm. I peel his fingers back, seeing a deep stab wound that gushes crimson. His hand snaps back over the mark, fighting a scream in agony as he does so."I saw the whole thing!" a random pedestrian shouts, speaking quickly into her cell phone. "I called the police! They're sending an ambulance."Mason bats my hand away as I try to help apply pressure to his hip. He speaks through grit teeth, "Go to the penthouse, Eden. You have to leave. You can't be here when the police get here, or it'll look suspicious."I shake my head, my lips cold and quivering. "I can't

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 12 : Reconciliation

    Eden's POVWatching Dante linger in the hallway, watching me writhe against Ryder's lap, I can see there was a reason the brothers put rules in place. He looks so wounded, even though we hadn't even done anything but kiss, the intentions were clear.I climb off Ryder and push myself into Dante's chest, waiting for his arms to extend behind my shoulders as always, but he lazily rests his hand on my hip instead. I can feel the heat of his anger."Dante, it wasn't anything," I breathe, my hands pulling for his face while he gives Ryder one of those typical, wordless stares that they only seem to understand. "Please, look at me."He finally gives in, and I have to struggle on the tips of my toes to crash my lips into his. He hardly kisses me back at first, letting my tongue brush his teeth before I feel him bite me. I pull back, more insulted than I am wounded.Dante looks through his brother, Ryder doing the same back in some weird prowess of intimidation. They're sizing each ot

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01
  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 13 : Dance with the Devil

    Eden's POVEven though Mason was let out of the hospital a few days ago, and any dwindling tension between the brothers had since subsided after their tiff, I still find myself lying awake at night in moderate panic.No one brings up Asher in conversation, or even acknowledges that the Donahue family exists. I can't help but dream of Asher pushing his way into my dressing room and trying to get a taste of what the brothers do to me.With them, it's welcomed. In my dreams with Asher, it's terrifying.I stare at Ryder's ceiling, comfortably laid out between him and Dante in his bed. As we seem to always end up in bed together anyways, I hardly care which room it is that we find ourselves in at the end of the night. As long as we're together, I'm okay.Or so I thought.Tonight's dreams nag at me so much that I can't even fall asleep, watching the minutes tick by aimlessly on the clock behind Ryder's shoulder. When it's finally time for me to give up laying here, I inch my way

    Last Updated : 2023-07-01

Latest chapter

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 50 : Ever After Sunset

    Eden's POV"Come on," I plead, trying to escape both of their roaming, wandering hands. "It's going to be cold and—and what if a boat passes by and they—they will see—""They're in for a show," Dante breathes into my neck and shoulder.I melt at his many, pecking kisses there. "Agh, that's not fair. You know I love that.""I also know you love a lot of things, baby," Ryder hums, pushing my dress upwards and dragging his tongue up the inside of my thighs.I wince, overwhelmed."Come on, guys, please. Let's just go to the bedroom and—and—"My vision sparks spots as Ryder's mauling kisses have moved up my thighs. So far, in fact, that I can't help but dare to collapse as I hook a leg over his broad shoulder. Dante keeps me upright, one of his hands undoing the zipper of my dress.They can't be serious!I panic, looking around the dock and the river, concerned that someone for sure is already watching. I can only imagine the frenzy it would cause if there was a camera any

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 49 : Keep Or Sell

    Eden's POVWe all stand around the kitchen island, unmoving and unspeaking, staring at the flash drive Asher had placed beneath the flowerpot before he died.It's evening now, which is nice because I feel like we do our best productive thought at this hour. We also have the most fun when everyone is asleep but it's not on our minds right now.I'm thinking of the money coming my way, the millions I can't even comprehend, while the brothers are left contemplating the flash drive Asher left behind when he saved me from his father's wine cellar.If they're anything like me, we're all thinking about how stupid we feel.It's been here all this time..."There have to be more Donahue family members," I breathe. "So that means they will come looking for it again, right? Or am I wrong?"Dante leans forward, staring through the drive like it's a foreign object they haven't spent all this time obsessing over selling and retrieving and getting rid of.Ryder hangs an arm over my sho

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 48 : An Intense Interview

    Eden's POVThis police station is colder than the last one I was in. I inch back into my chair, clinging to Dante's jacket while Ryder manages to get me a cup of coffee from the break room. They hang back, pacing through the small interview room while I sit at the cold, metal table.My heels tap on the concrete floors methodically, and I hold the coffee cup just to feel the warmth of it in my palms. My head has been spinning for the last few hours.No one has come to talk to us since bringing us into this little room.I look at the mirror along the side wall, wondering who is in there, and why they are watching us. I can't imagine that this has anything to do with the bank heist, considering we're still near the estate out of Manhattan, but they could be here about the clothes on the yacht.I feel stupid for even forgetting about that stuff.I lay my head down, exhausted, feeling like this is what they want from me. It's working.The Golden brothers are less than worried,

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 47 : All Black Attire

    Eden's POV"Come back here," Ryder snaps.I'd already gathered my robe and slipped inside it, but Ryder is charging through the room when he sees me doing so. I need to go outside, to breathe and process, or maybe pick up a rag and some furniture spray so I can distract my frazzled mind.Ryder loops his arms around my sides and pulls me back into his chest. I struggle to wiggle free and instead of setting me down in bed, he shoves me toward the shower and releases me, ripping my robe away."Ugh, come on," I pant, coming close to slipping on the tile and falling backward.Dante's hands wrap around me next and he pins me under the warm shower water while Ryder leans casually against the shower door."What did she do now?" Dante says in a heavy exhale."The news said the police found her clothes on the Donahue yacht," Ryder grumbles. "They are talking about her and the bank heist and being brought in for questioning again."Dante pouts slightly but manages a soft, gentle k

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 46 : Alone Together

    Eden's POVI collapse into bed, still warm with both of their scents, and it swarms my mind all at once how much I love lying in bed with them both. I dare to go to sleep, a yawn pulling from my lips, but the brothers both make a growling, disapproving noise."You are not going to sleep," Dante huffs, slightly offended. "You better wake up, kitten, or I'll do it for you."Slightly tempted by such a salacious threat, I bury my face into my pillow and snuggle into the blankets. It's easy to tempt both of these affectionate men.Ryder steals the blankets from the bed, stripping it and stripping me next.I shiver, my bare back under their heavy glares, and I don't even have to turn around to know it is true. Dante climbs into bed beside me, and when I think he is going to flip me over so they can have their way with me, he instead grabs my wrists.I aim to sit up, surprised, but Dante yanks my hands behind the small of my back and ties them there. Panic sets in when I feel a ta

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 45 : From Sea to Land

    Eden's POV"Trouble sleeping?"Carol perches on one of the chairs at the dining room table while I have my legs kicked up on the bench, pressed to the bay window that overlooks the river. I can see her through the reflection of the window, adjusting her silk robe and folding her well-manicured hands out before her."Yeah," I admit, though everyone knows it already. "Just got tired of lying there, I guess.""That's understandable," Carol hums. "How about I make some tea and we talk?"I sulk at the thought. She catches it."Well, I'll make tea and we won't talk. Sound good?"I blush but eventually nod long after she is already preparing water to boil over the stovetop. I sit back, eyeing the dark horizon and seeing it absent from the boat that was surrounded by police and coast guard and other boats with red and blue lights.They finally towed the Donahue yacht from hell out of the water after a fishing boat passed by and saw blood draining down the stern. It's been on ev

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 44 : Golden Bullets

    Eden's POVErik Donahue yanks me out of my corner by my bruising, fractured ankle. I release a scream so loud that he snarls for me to stop, and even then, I don't abide until he drops my wounded leg in mercy.My thigh is burned from rubbing against the carpet so hard and my labored breath is causing a throbbing in my throat. The Donahue head boss looms overhead, twitching with a handgun pressed casually in his palm.He eyes me carefully, as I keep a close watch on his pistol. The room, the yacht—the world is silent."I knew you were rotten when I saw the bank robbery footage," he sneers, pacing around my shivering position on the floor. "I should have killed you then. Now, you've done nothing but stir up trouble. You turned my own damn son against me and have sent my ship into chaos."I stifle a reply, knowing if I piss him off right now, it will take nothing for him to kill me.Gunshots ring out downstairs, and I flinch on impulse, expecting one to pierce my body, but the

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 43 : Explosions

    Eden's POVI lean into Asher's side, both of us curled up together in the corner of his room in the belly of the yacht. I feel safe with him, but I know that won't last forever. Eventually, with the sun going down, and there's still no sign of Dante or Ryder— Erik may grow impatient and kill me first.It's naïve to think I'm of any use anymore.Erik has the tracker, and we already managed to make a call to the Golden brothers, so they know I'm okay. If I die now, everything left unsaid will forever be the impression I leave behind."Can we call them again?" I whimper, biting back hefty sobs of defeat. "I'm scared, Asher.""I know you are, but we can't call them again, sweetheart. We don't know if they're already almost here or not. We can't blow their cover like that, Eden. We just have to wait."I turn my face into his warm, clean shirt. I still reek of tequila and blood, the welts on my arm and around my back from Erik's fury earlier broken open along the edges. This dain

  • Trapped Between the Mafia Brothers   Chapter 42 : A Golden Girl

    Dante's POVMy brother and I have gotten good at reading each other's minds over the years. Even when we've had our simple spats, we've stayed intertwined with one another. But this feels different, we are different, and being away from our favorite girl has changed everything.Ryder is laboring over his computer set up in our downtown office, trying to catch a ping off the tracker we had sewn into most of Eden's shorts.She wouldn't have appreciated us doing that, but after she ran off from us the first time, and then was taken by Erik Donahue and returned so beaten, we had to do something. So Ryder had little buttons replaced on her shorts and jeans to track her location at any time, but something is wrong.I can't tell what specifically. Ryder flexes his knuckles at the sides of the computer, working in plain, tensile silence.I take to pacing, Mason halfway across the office, his head buried in his arms. He never liked Eden to begin with, but that seemed to be changing, c

Scan code to read on App
DMCA.com Protection Status