Waking uncomfortably early, Cassy gazed up at the canopy over her bed and dreaded the coming day. What precious little sleep she’d managed the night before had failed in making her feel even marginally relaxed.
Gray light pressed through the painted windows, and she realized that Gabriel must have already drawn the drapes, which meant he would be returning any moment to help her dress. That moved her to action and she flung herself from the bed and toward the dressing room.
With the dressing room door softly shut, she shed her nightshirt and dressed quickly. Turning in front of the long mirror to look at her appearance with an anxious eye, she noted the faint bluish shadows beneath her eyes and sighed. Thus, all in all, her masquerade was virtually unrecognizable. Even Jonathan could not recognize her for a few moments. Her hair was darker now, then it was white, long and pulled up into a demure chignon. Despite her efforts to keep her curls tamed, they waved in unruly stands in a short cropped style that was popular.
Leaning closer, she gazed at her face with a frown. It should look more like Jonathan’s, but somehow, it didn’t. Her eyes were larger, she supposed and her long lashes curled upward while his jutted straight out in thick spikes, her high cheekbones were curvy instead of angular, her chin was way rounder than her brother’s and of course, Jonathan have a rough scrape of beard in the mornings, where she did not. Well, there was nothing she could possibly do about that, was there?
Perhaps, she thought with a frown, her body could give her secret away. To most casual eyes, she was just a slender youth with well shaped legs. But a clearer view or notice could be evident to her curved hips and tight buff breaches and more so, her small waist could be spanned with a man’s hands. Without the loose, concealing shirt and covering waistcoat, one could glimpse the gentle thrusting of her breasts. Fortunately, the waistcoat and the frock coast gave her the appearance of a 'pouter pigeon.' No one could notice that there was something bizarre to this pigeon than there should have been.
Straightening her shoulders, she decided that she looked masculine enough even to Eastland and thereby, took the stairs down. To Cassy’s relief, the Duke was not in residence that day. Not only did he own the Eastland hall, but also two other country estates and as a tradition, he was accustomed to checking on them after every 25 days. There was much entailed to being a Duke than she had thought. He had more than enough to keep him preoccupied with the aid of his staff, numbered at almost two hundred, the vast grounds and wildlife there, as well as the foodstuffs and dairy products that were raised for the estate, and the redundant salt at market. Of course as his steward, Sheldon bore a lot of responsibilities, thus the Duke who was the helm had the ultimate responsibility of several estates and it’s tenets.
That should be enough to keep him busy for several days, she hoped, though, Sheldon had informed her that Eastland might come back late the next day. This gave her a promising feeling of freedom.
The feelings couldn’t last long. Her first tutor began to pound latin grammar into her medulla immediately after breakfast and later followed by a course in greek literature. Next came her science tutor, who spent a great deal of time explaining the intricate detail woven into nature. He spoke of elements, atoms, and the very fabric of life that Cassy’s head soon began to throb with the overflow of new knowledge. She was all too glad to see him go after nearly an hour.
"It must be Friday," she muttered, and ran her hand through her short, dark curls in exasperation. How could she be expected to learn all this? Unlike Jonathan who was given the chance to study all these as he was growing, she had never been bothered to even glance at a book, except when putting them away. Most of her days were spent learning how to sew, or sitting in the drawing room and knitting beside her mother while she enchanted her with tales of her forbidden love, so full of wonder that Cassy used to imagine what it would be like to care so deeply about someone that she’d be willing to give up everything for their sake.
Saturday dawned bright and crisp with yellow sunshine and a brisk breeze. It was a welcome relief from the rainfall as Cassy anticipated a bracing walk on the ground she had seen stretching for miles. A long, curved drive led to house and was bisected by not only a set but two set of ornate gate completed with gate houses. A heavy iron gate barred the uninvited from Eastland hall.
Deftly eluding Sam, and any suggestions of which he could offer to fill her time, Cassy slipped from the main house and walk slowly down to a beautiful garden. Gardeners worked in the cold, wet soil, some nodding as she walk through. Though she wasn’t sure of what the protocol was, she responded just by nodding back.
She kept walking and found herself near the stables, giving a close look to a hostler exercising one of the blooded animals the Duke owned. It was a splendid beast, a muscled black with a sleek body and proud head. It pranced around in a wide circle inside the rail enclosure, steam rushing from its nostril. It tossed its head as the hostler cracked a whip in the air to keep it galloping.
Cassy leaned against the fence resting her chin atop her cold hands. "That’s a beautiful horse," she ventured to say when the boy paused in keeping the animal trotting at the end of the long line.
He turned and nodded gravely. "Aye! My lord. This is one of his Grace’s favorite." Keeping his hand tight in the loose, the dark haired boy had a broad shoulder and was plump with big eyeballs. He regarded Cassy for quite a moment. "You’re the new earl I suppose?" he asked. Faintly flabbergasted at how gossips quickly spawned like mushrooms, Cassy retort, "Yes, I suppose."
"Then you’ll be glad to hear that his Grace means this horse for you, my Lord. That’s why I’ve got it out."
Cassy couldn’t follow through; she felt an uneasy tightening in her stomach. "For me?" With a perplexing look, the hostler slanted her a curious glance.
"Aye!"
She turned back at the horse, this time it looked like a trifle wild animal which was ready to pounce on her at any moment. It eyes rolled so she could see the whites of them, it kept tossing its head in the direction she was and prancing briskly. Deep dished nostrils flared hot and pink as it snorted and shook its head.
"Which do you mean?" She asked in a faint tone, this time the hostler tilted his head to the east side.
"You’re not scared, are you my Lord?" There was a tinge of mockery in the question which made Cassy to feel that her pride was at stake here and now.
"No! Of course not!" Her quick answer seemed to have satisfied him, but she added; "I am just thunderstruck that his Grace didn’t mind sharing such a valuable animal."
"I don’t mind at all," came a baritone voice behind her, and Cassy did not even bother to turn around to see because she recognized it as belonging to Eastland. She briefly closed her eyes, taking a deep breathe and freeing her mind, then opened them when he added; "Are you an experienced rider, Levington?"
"Live ridden," she replied flatly, not adding that she rode her fat, dapple-gray pony when she was ten years old. She could remember clearly how she cried when she fell off and tore her cinderella pink dress. Jonathan had laughed at her and she was reluctant to ride her pony ever again.
"Excellent," the Duke said with such approval that Cassy suddenly loved would be true. After all, she could remember the rudiments of riding.
Turning slowly, she wasn’t prepared for the full impact of the Duke in casual clothes. Wearing smug breaches, tucked into the top of his high riding boots, a white shirt, navy waistcoat, long tailed riding jacket and a carelessly tied cravat, Eastland looked the epitome of a rugged gentleman.
He was carrying a short riding crop in his strong brown hands and taped it idly against his boots top as he looked from the horse to Cassy. Her heart thumped harder. His tawny hair was wind ruffled, and his green eyes were bright beneath the thick, dark fan of his lashes. Sunlight glided through his hair with pail light and gleamed on his chestnut color skin, and Cassy thought crazily what it must be like for him to look that good; it was appalling that she stared at him in such a way.
She turned away quickly, missing the Duke’s sudden frown at her. He had noticed her wide eyed reaction to him, and hoped that it wasn’t what he thought. Eastland’s mouth tightened, he had met youth who were flirting with him before, usually painted boys with smiling mouth and old eyes, boys who made his skin craw. If Levington had any of those inclinations, he’d better get rid of them!
"Saddle it up, Smith," the Duke said in a rough tone that made Cassy’s eyes swing towards him. "Now, your grace?" she blurted, then wished she hadn’t.
"It’s a fine day for riding, Levington. Are you reluctant to ride?"
"I. . . I . . . My boots, your Grace. They don’t fit, and one cannot ride without proper footwear." She wasn’t quite certain if that could be true, thus, it sounded reasonable and quite promising, she was relieved when Eastland gave a short nod with his head.
"I agree. The boot maker will be here Monday morning, and then you shall ride. I anticipate to see you astride ‘Black’ before the week ends."
Cassy wasn’t certain what aghast her most; the realization she would have to ride astride or that the horse’s name was Black. It was a close tie, she decided with a dismay, watching as the duke pivoted on his heel and strode towards the manor without looking at her again.
Her gaze redirected to Smith, and she noticed that the hostler was looking at her with a pitiful look with his warm brown eyes.
"You ought not to be scared of it. It ain’t a bad sort," he said, and for a moment she thought he was taking about the duke, then she realized he meant the horse and she nodded glumly.
"I suppose that my lack of empathy is apparent."
"Aye!, my Lord. It sticks out of you like a burr on a toad." He hesitated, then asked "would you like me to give you a few pointers?"
"Would you be willing to do that?"
"Aye! There is little or none for me to do today."
"I am game!" Cassy said with a smile.
Grinning, Smith showed Cassy how to mount from the left, though not on Black which was too big to start with. She was a bit chagrined when he trotted out a docile mare for her to ride, but thus saw the sense in it. No point in humiliating herself without at least some practicing.
Riding astride and riding side-saddle were two entirely different proportions, she discovered. One involved the careful arrangement of skirts and a knee hooked on a saddle horn, while the other involved positioning both legs in a very unladylike straddle atop the mount. All her recent training had geared her to keeping her balance by centering her posture on her buttocks. This new method focused on balancing on the balls of her feet and using her knees to superintend the critter.
It was novel and difficult, but was infinitely more rewarding than riding side-saddle. Cassy took to it at once. "I say, my Lord, you’ve never ridden much, have you?" Smith muttered as Cassy faced him with flushed pride on her small features.
She shook her head "Indeed I haven’t, Smith," she affirmed.
"How do they ride in the colonies?"
She was struck by the question, and spontaneously admitted "Similitude I suppose" she leaned closer and said in a low tone, "I just didn’t want his grace to know that I am inept at it. He seems to get upset with me easily."
"Aye! That he does I suppose."
Smith took the mare’s reins and began leading her into the stable and Cassy followed behind more to keep from being found by Sheldon than anything else. She had no interest to study anymore foreign or dead languages, nor the desire to see the duke again. Watching the hostler could be more preferable to anything at that momentum to further ‘Levington’s’ education.
The afternoon was spent quite pleasantly while getting along well with Smith. The tall, sturdy stable boy was the kind of character she had known in Virginia, plain spoken and sensible. There was no subterfuge in him, nor arrogance. He seem to accept the world as it was, with its melee and controversies by doing well to get along with it.
"Do you mind me coming tomorrow again, Smith?" Cassy asked as it began to grow late. He seem startled by her question.
"I am sure that is up to you, my lord. Or to his grace."
She was struck by that simple truth. "Yes Smith, I assume so."
It occurred to her that the Duke seemed to have much more to say about her world than anyone had the right to. Even her parents had not filled her day with such a rigid timetable. From the time she woke in the morning, until she was finally able to lay her head on her pillow at night, she had a full schedule.
She shuddered to think how Jonathan would have reacted if he had accepted and come to England instead. Would he have taken a liking to Smith as she had? Or would he have been more inclined towards earning the Duke’s approval, deftly hanging on his each and every word as though it were the saying of the gods.
That night, she thought about writing a letter to him. But just as the quill reached the parchment, her mind went numb and she crumpled the parchment with a groan and threw it aside.
Sunday, obviously, was not one of those days. It began early, with Sheldon bringing her the information that his Grace expected her to be downstairs within half an hour, dressed and ready for services in the village church."The church?" Cassy was hesitant. "Yes, my lord," he added with a second bow. "The church. I’m sure you must have passed it on your way up here. Everyone goes there for service, even the Duke’s neighbors.""Neighbors?" As far as she could tell, Eastland manor stretched for hundreds of yards, and she hadn’t seen any fence to indicate a separation from another property. "The old Viscount has lived right next to the manor for several years now," Sheldon said, in that slow manner that told Cassy he secretly thought her slow-witted. For all his faults though, he hid it well. Church didn't sound bad at all, though Cassy did wonder sleepily why it began so early. She'd always enjoyed the sermons at the old church near Hampton road, even with its broken panes and cobwebs
"En garde!"Gripping her epee tightly, Cassy flexed her knees and lifted her left arm in the air as her instructor, M. Fournier, had taught her. Her throat closed with nervous apprehension as the small, wiry Frenchman assumed the first position. Sunlight streamed through the tall windows of the ballroom, glittering on the blade of the slender epee she clutched in her right hand. It seemed to sparkle with deadly intent."No, no," he said in a despondent manner. "You are holding the blade wrong." Because of his high, nasal accent, it sounded like he had said, "None, none. Hue are olding ze blade wrong."A large mat had been spread on the floor in the ballroom where she received her fencing lessons, and the instructor had inked a mark on its surface to indicate where she was to stand. Cassy tried to keep her stockinged feet near the mark and concentrate on M. Fournier at the same time.This was her first lesson, and she wore cork told on the blunt end of her blade, as well as a mask and p
Eastland found himself in a towering rage as he strode toward the manor with heavy footsteps, each one heavier and more pronounced than the last. His brows were knitted in annoyance, and he screamed at the doorman when he took half a second too long to open the door. He growled at the steward when he entered his study as well, when the fool had the audacity to ask if anything was wrong with him. "Get out!" He pointed to the door with a fire in his eyes that caused the young lad to take off in a split second. Fuming, Henry sat at his table, surrounded in a cloud of his own contempt. Since when did he allow himself to be irritated past the point of self control by anyone? Not to talk of the foolish boy who couldn’t seem to do anything right. He cursed lightly as he strode to the window, unable to sit still while he anger continued to boil within him. Levington just had such a vulnerable, female look about him. His shy, wide blue eyes, and the way his lashes lowered whenever he though
"You're a fidgety boy, aren't you?" The Dowager Duchess of Eastland remarked, impaling Cassy with a steely glare."I'm sorry, your grace," she muttered and stared glumly down at her untouched dinner plate. Footmen were still serving a variety of meats from salmon to mutton, along with an astonishing array of vegetables, sausages, pickles, and creamed dishes to tempt the appetite. Across the table, numerous conversations flew in all directions, most too confusing for her to understand."Don't apologise," Eastland's Aunt said in a stern voice. "It's a sign of weakness."Cassy glanced up at the jewelled, rather portly woman with a surprised look, and nodded. "Yes, your grace.""And don't be so mealy-mouthed." The duchess snapped. "Where's your spirit?"A rush of resentment washed through her, and Cassy's eyes glittered as she said evenly, "I've been made to understand that spirit is not as important as obedience, your grace. If it offends you, it does not offend the duke.""I see," the do
Cassy watched with mounting horror as Sir Geoffrey walked into the dining hall with an innocent smile on his face. Behind him walked Colin, handsome as ever, his smile a lazy one. Cassy felt her chest tighten at the sight of him, and the entire hall suddenly felt much too small. "No need for the warm welcome," sir Geoffrey said as he stopped right next to the duke. "We just thought we'd swing by since it appears that we didn't receive an invitation."Eastland flexed his fingers slowly, his rage mounting slowly. Cassy could see the irritation in his eyes, and she could tell that he'd deliberately refused to invite the viscount. "Sir Geoffrey," the duchess said with an exaggerated friendliness, "forgive my oversight. I had assumed that, being my nephew’s nearest neighbor, he would have invited you personally. Invitations were sent out to guests who were far away, and I was careless in my assumptions. Forgive my mistake.""I think nothing of it, your grace," sir Geoffrey said with a flo
Henry Blake, odd as it may seem, did not love Rebecca Spencer, nor was he particularly enamoured of her ripe charms. He'd been tired of her for some time and had welcomed the news of her engagement to Viscount Ravanel. It would effectively remove her from his life, he'd hoped.He should have known better, Henry reflected cynically as he removed Rebecca's arms from around his neck and kept his steely grip on her wrists. She gazed up at him with a pout, and let her curves lean forward to brush against his chest. His body immediately responded in spite of his irritation, and Rebecca knew it."See?" She whispered in a triumphant voice, rubbing her hips suggestively against his arousal. "You still want me!""Maybe I'm just too accustomed to having you, Becky," he said with a shrug. "It's not as if we haven't spent a great many hours in bed together.""Didn't you enjoy those times, Henry?""Immensely.""There's no reason why you can't continue," she murmured throatily and leaned into him eve
Cassy sat huddled in one corner of the black lacquered carriage that sped towards London. Eastland sat opposite her, his long legs thrust out in front of him and crossed at the ankles, looking every inch the splendid lord he was.Yet for the first time, she found it hard to admire him. He'd not spoken a civil word to her in a week and until he'd had Sheldon inform her that she was to accompany him to London, had not deigned to take notice of her at all. It was as if Lord Levington, his ward, has ceased to exist for him.Now they were going to London and she had no idea why. It did not seem like a good idea to inquire, with him gazing out the window and ignoring her. She shifted on the plush velvet squabs and wished she'd never agreed to decided to England. Anything else would have been better than that.Only now she was here, and mired in the masquerade, and did not know how to extricate herself. She was afraid of Eastland. Yes, it was true. Oddly enough, she wasn't as afraid of the th
"You... You’re a... a,""I’m a girl," Cassy finished for her, daring to laugh. Anne staggered away from her, confusion suddenly written all over her face. Cassy felt her breath returning to normal almost immediately, although Anne was quite far from there. "A girl?" she blurted out suddenly, still making no attempt to cover her unclad state. "It would appear so," Cassy replied. "My lord, is there... did lady Herenton put you up to this?" she asked. "Did she pay you to humiliate me like this?""I can assure you that there has been a bit misunderstanding," Cassy said quickly. "And none of this was at your expense.""Then explain this," she grated. "Explain how you are a girl, and how you managed to fool them into thinking you’re not.""You might want to sit down for this," Cassy said. "It’s sort of a long story, and I don’t even know where to begin."Anne eyed her suspiciously, clearly debating whether she could trust this strange woman or not. It was bad enough that she had to discov
April 25, 1822"Twins, your grace," the physician said, smiling wearily at the man sprawled in a chair in his study. "Boys. And healthy they are, bawling their lungs out."Henry stood up slowly, running a hand over the half grown stubble on his jaw. Twins? Boys?"How is my wife?" he asked after an instant of stunned silence."Very tired, as she's so small and it was a hard birth for her, but she's well. There seem to be no problems.""There better not be," Henry growled, fixing the doctor with an intent gaze. "You are to remain here until she has completely recovered. I've heard too many times about women who have died within a few days after a normal birth, and I won't have that happen to Cassandra.""But your grace, I have other patients who need me," the doctor protested. "Lady Auberly is nearly..."Henry wasn't listening. He strode across the room and out the door of his study, taking the stairs two at a time. He eased into Cassy's room, his eyes trying to adjust to the dim light.
"I love you so much. . . ."His kisses seared her flesh like glowing brands as his mouth moved around her lips. "You're the best thing to had ever happen to me," he murmured against her lips, before capturing them yet again in a searing kiss.It had never occurred to Cassy that he would want her to touch him as he touched her, and the knowledge was thrilling. She put her hands against his tanned chest, slowly spreading her fingers, amazed when her simple touch made his breath catch.Feeling as if her heart would break with the love bursting in it, Cassy answered him with a melting kiss. It was answer enough.Still holding her, he moved onto his side, then he combed his fingers through her rumpled, satiny hair and brushed a tender kiss against her temple. Cassy’s lashes fluttered up and he felt as if he would drown in the deep blue pools of her eyes."How do you feel?" she teased, smiling as she asked him the same question he had once asked her. With tender solemnity, he replied, "I f
Henry took her home that evening. Cassy smiled all the way back home, looking at him as though he would disappear from her sight. "What is it?" he asked, smiling at her. "Nothing," she replied. "I just want to look at you."His aunt was much too happy to see them returned, and she held Cassy for a bit longer than expected. Jonathan had a long talk with his sister the next day when he arrived, and for the first time since her marriage to Henry, he actually smiled at her husband. "Isn't she amazing?" Adeline asked as she stood beside him by the large hall, both of them gazing at Cassy adoringly as she spoke with the servants; Sheldon and Gabriel included. Ever since they came back, the atmosphere of the estate had changed to a cheerful chatter."She is," Henry agreed without a second thought, and he missed the smile that spread across Adeline's face. "I had no idea she would be this forgiving.""You think she has forgiven you?" Adeline asked swiftly, gazing up at his jade eyes filled
For a long while, Cassy simply stared at him. She could hardly believe that he was actually here, standing before her with his darkened eyes and his tousled hair. "May I come in?" he asked. Cassy stepped aside, knowing there was nothing she could do to stop him. The ruse was over; Zack must have told him where she was. The bastard! How could he betray her like this?Henry walked behind her slowly, unable to take his eyes of her. So she had been at Zack’s this entire time. Zack, who should have had the decency to inform him at once that his wife was hiding here. Zack, who had taken Catherine from him, had also succeeded in taking his wife this time. Fury lashed at his thoughts, but his murderous thoughts were halted immediately whenever he blinked and she came into his view. Cassy lead them into the drawing room she had just vacated with Colin. This time however, she didn’t sit. Neither did Henry. He stood at the doorway, watching her hungrily. He couldn’t soak in the sight of her en
"Colin?"His name was a whisper on her lips, too light and feathery to be real. It had been too long since she last said the name; too long since she last saw the rugged smile and those beautiful eyes staring down at her. "Colin." She said the name again, as if repeating it would make his presence more real. He looked different, and yet somehow the same. The familiarity hit her like a train, sending her world spinning off its axis. "May I come in?" he asked, a nonchalant smirk perched on the edge of his lips. "I hardly think this is the right spot for old friends to entertain each other.""Of course," she said breathlessly, stepping aside. "Forgive my manners. I’m just so surprised to see you here of all places.""I’m surprised to see you here as well," he said, passing the threshold and stepping into the hallway. "Hardwick never told me about you.""Well I only just came to stay with him a few months ago," she replied, leading him to the drawing room. She could feel his eyes on her
Jonathan growled as though he would punch Henry without hearing from him. He had a defensive stance, waiting for the best moment to strike."I have no idea," Henry began, his voice cold. "Perhaps you might know where I can find her, Levington?"Jonathan was seething with rage. "Now you see why I was so against the wedding!" he snapped angrily before punching Henry on the face.If Henry heard him, he gave no sign. His attention was on the door. He didn't bother to reply Jonathan, he didn't care how angry he was. He wanted to fight. It had been a long time since he'd felt this fierce urge to battle another man, but he did now. Few of the duels he'd engaged had been of his choosing and fewer still had he anticipated. Most of the time, he had simply refused to back down when pushed and had given his challenger every opportunity to gracefully extract himself from a fight.But now, Henry wanted a fight desperately. He wanted the satisfaction of clashing blades, not the more detached aiming o
Cassy mounted one of the sedate.The raw pain had eased slightly and was duller now, more easily dealt with now that she wasn't expecting anything, now that she wasn't expecting him to follow her. She had given up already on their love.At first, nothing had helped, then for the past week, she had begun taking her life one day at a time, making it through the day and then congratulating herself for it, spending as much time with Zack as possible. Finally, she had begun taking pains with her appearance again and had begun wearing the new clothes that fit her fuller figure. Her breasts were larger, and her waist, though still small, was not as small as it had been. Her hips were fuller, too, swelling in a curve that would hardly be mistaken as boyish now. She had definitely matured, and pregnancy surely did agree with her.But what good did it do to her if Henry was so far away? And why did she miss him so much when it was obvious he did not miss her? He was with his mistresses, and she
"Why wasn't I told?" Adeline seethed angrily. "Why do I have to find out when things are worse? Henry, do you any idea how helpful I might have been in looking for her?""I don't care to discuss it, Madam," he said coldly, causing her to shiver. "And I'll find my wife myself.""You don't feel it necessary now when she has left already? With a baby? Your baby?" Adeline injected a note of scorn in her voice that made Henry's eyes blaze with fury as she said, "You're a coward, Henry Blake, and I never thought that of you before.""You have no idea what you're talking about!""I most certainly do. You're afraid to admit that you love Cassandra, and you're afraid she doesn't love you back as much as you do. I can tell you that she does."Clasping his hands behind his back, Henry said in a biting tone, "I can tell you, madam, that you are quite mistaken in the matter. Not only does she not care for me; she hates me. If you don't believe me, ask her. I'm certain she will be as free with that
As he held Rebecca in his hands and watched his wife leave, Henry quickly pushed Rebecca away from him. He had no idea why he had done it, no idea why he had felt the compelling urge to hug Rebecca and kiss her as soon as he saw her standing in his study.Maybe he was confused at the words she had said, maybe their argument last night had done that. Point is, he had only caught her in the hands of his cousin, and she was drunk, which meant he might have possibly only helped her like they both said. But now, she had caught him kissing another woman, right in their home.He had wanted to hurt her as much as he was hurting, but definitely not the type of hurt he had seen in her eyes when she saw him kissing Rebecca."Leave," he growled angrily at Rebecca, and Sheldon wasted no time in dragging her out, despite her pleading. He had been pained to have seen Cassy seeing the sinful act, but he couldn't move, nor did he have the slightest idea that she had left. Only Ellen did, and it happene