Share

Chapter 5

Author: Teehee
The conversation came to an abrupt halt.

Evelyn, her steps unsteady, walked forward and snatched her phone back, ending the call.

Matteo stared at her in shock, not understanding why she was so worked up. "What's wrong?"

Seeing his confusion, she knew he hadn't heard the rest of what Caroline had said. She let out a quiet sigh of relief, averted her gaze, and tried to sound as calm as possible. "Nothing, I just don't want you guys fighting over me anymore."

For the past few weeks, the Gallagher family had been making a fuss about him being with Evelyn, constantly trying to break them up. Matteo had argued with them several times over it.

Hearing her say that, Matteo didn't press further and instead asked about her test results.

"The doctor said it's nothing serious. I can be discharged."

For the next few days at home, Matteo barely left the house, staying by Evelyn's side.

She wasn't as lively as before, no longer smiling as much. Most of the time, she just sat in a corner, staring off into space, looking uninterested in everything.

Matteo couldn't figure out what was wrong. He tried holding her, hoping to comfort her, but she just got up and went back to the bedroom.

"I'm not feeling well. I'm going to rest for a bit."

Watching her walk away, Matteo was caught off guard.

He thought she was still upset about the apology incident, so he had his assistant prepare a surprise for her.

On her birthday, he threw a party in her honor.

Out of respect for Matteo, most people from their social circle showed up.

They were polite to Evelyn when Matteo was around.

But at the moment he stepped away, they gathered in small groups, whispering and making snide remarks.

"If it weren't for Mr. Gallagher, I wouldn't be caught dead at a maid's daughter's birthday party. It's just embarrassing."

"I don't even get what he sees in her. Look at that cheap, small-town vibe. It makes me sick."

"Mr. Gallagher is just being noble, that's all. If it were me, I'd just throw her some cash and be done with it. But marrying her? That'd be a disgrace to the Gallagher name."

Even though she was supposed to be the center of attention, Evelyn stood alone, completely ignored.

Hearing the insults and mockery from all sides, she just felt exhausted.

If it weren't for the fact that leaving too early would make Matteo suspicious, she wouldn't have come at all.

The deliberate isolation made every minute unbearable.

Then, at exactly 7:00 pm, the atmosphere in the ballroom suddenly shifted.

The entire room turned toward the entrance, their disdain instantly replaced with eager flattery.

In their world, news traveled fast. Everyone had heard about Matteo getting into a fight over Rebecca not long ago. Now, seeing him walk in, they rushed to suck up to him.

"Mr. Gallagher, so you left earlier to go pick up Ms. Pittman? After all these years, your bond is still so strong!"

"Well, of course! They grew up together. They're childhood sweethearts. Just look at Ms. Pittman. She has such elegance and grace. She and Mr. Gallagher are a perfect match."

As speculations ran wild, Evelyn turned to see Rebecca walking in, her arm hooked through Matteo's.

She was dressed in a stunning designer gown and a dazzling diamond necklace, emphasizing her elegant posture. Her delicate, refined features exuded an air of privilege and luxury.

Even standing next to Matteo, with his naturally imposing presence, she didn't seem overshadowed in the slightest.

For no reason at all, an image flashed in Evelyn's mind. It was the faceless sketch Matteo had once drawn after regaining his sight.

Back then, he had brushed it off as just a random doodle. She had thought it was beautiful but didn't think much of it.

But now, looking at Rebecca, she finally understood who had been in that drawing.

This wasn't a case of lost love finding its way back. It was love that had never faded.

Evelyn lowered her gaze and turned away in silence.

However, before she could leave, Rebecca called out to her.

"Ms. Walsh, I heard it's your birthday today. I hope you don't mind me showing up uninvited?"

At her cue, someone led in a small, snow-white puppy. "Its name is Elmo. Isn't it adorable?"

As the fluffy puppy bounced toward her, Evelyn instinctively stepped back, bumping into a table.

Her face went pale, and a wave of fear and panic surged in her eyes.

"Take it away," she said, her voice trembling slightly. "I don't like dogs."

Related chapters

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 6

    Rebecca's face fell when she heard those words."Matteo, is Ms. Walsh still mad at me over what happened last time? If that's the case, I'll just leave so I don't intrude on you two."As she spoke, she turned to leave. Matteo quickly grabbed her arm and frowned at Evelyn."She meant well, Eve. Don't you love animals? Just take it."Seeing the displeasure in his eyes, Evelyn clenched her hands tightly and turned to his assistant, Zachary Warner, instead."Mr. Warner, I'm wearing heels, so it's inconvenient for me to hold the puppy. Could you take care of it for me?"The people around them started making snide remarks again, mocking her for being ungrateful and acting too high and mighty.Matteo also assumed she was deliberately giving Rebecca a hard time. His expression darkened as he led Rebecca inside.The party quickly emptied out, leaving Evelyn alone.She poured herself a glass of water and took a slow sip, trying to calm the panic and anxiety in her chest.She used to lo

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 7

    It was the early hours of the morning when Evelyn finally dragged her exhausted body home.The moment she turned on the lights, her phone buzzed several times.It was a message from Rebecca."You've been liking all my social media posts, so you must already know that Matteo and I are legally married, right? He also promised me a wedding in Mauwai. I saw the venue plans. It's absolutely grand."Every single detail is exactly what we used to dream about when we were younger. I can't believe he still remembers after all these years."I should also thank you. If it weren't for you, Matteo wouldn't have regained his sight. Really, I owe you for taking care of my husband for seven whole years."Reading the blatant mockery, Evelyn didn't even have the energy to be angry anymore.She went straight to her bedroom, lay down, and fell into a deep sleep.That night, Matteo still didn't come home. The only thing he sent was a text message."Eve, I still have some things to take care of. Is

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 8

    A flood of memories surged through Evelyn's mind the moment she pushed open the door.Everything in the room was exactly the same as the day they had left. Not a single thing had changed."Eve, do you remember when we—""I don't." Evelyn lowered her head, her voice barely audible.Matteo froze for a second, then pointed toward a brick model in the corner. "Didn't we put this in the study after we finished building it? Why is it here?"Evelyn didn't follow his gaze. Her voice was calm and indifferent."You couldn't see back then. A lot of your memories must feel like a blur, like illusions that are all mixed up."It was just like how she had once believed that Matteo loved her.But in reality, what he felt for her had only been a mirage. She was something he clung to in desperation.Because he had been blind, he had relied on touch to navigate his world. She had been like a walking cane to him, a guide, a necessity. That was why he had thought she was important.But once he re

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 9

    When Evelyn got home, she pulled out a suitcase and started packing up the last of her things.She kept busy until the early hours of the morning. Matteo still hadn't come back, but she no longer cared.The next day, Evelyn went to the immigration office to collect all her documents.On the way back, she booked a flight for that afternoon.As soon as the car pulled up to the house, she saw a Maybach parked in the driveway. Instinctively, she quickened her pace.The moment she stepped into the bedroom, she saw Matteo standing beside her suitcase, as if about to open it.Panic surged through her, and she blurted out, "Weren't you with Rebecca? Why are you back?"Matteo froze. Slowly, he turned around, and for the first time, there was anger in his eyes.He walked up to her, exasperation clear in his voice."Eve, what are you overthinking this time? I already told you. I have nothing to do with Rebecca anymore."Nothing to do with her anymore? Yet, he married her to protect her.

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 10

    Matteo's sleep was anything but peaceful.Fragments of the past resurfaced in his dreams—the darkness, the helplessness, the pain.However, this time, the woman who had always stayed by his side was gone."Eve…" he murmured her name, frowning. His chest rose and fell erratically, trapped in a nightmare.In his dream, he groped his way forward, desperately searching for the person who was supposed to be there. But no matter how loudly he called, the silence around him remained unbroken.A wave of fear crashed over him, and suddenly, his eyes snapped open.His forehead was drenched in sweat.The blackout curtains kept the room in complete darkness. His heart pounded wildly in his chest, and for a moment, he couldn't tell if he was still dreaming.He sat up, his voice unsteady. "Eve?"Silence.He tried again, louder this time. "Eve!"It was still nothing.Stumbling out of bed, he groped for the light switch, nearly tripping over his own feet.The room was instantly flooded wi

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 11

    In that brief moment, Matteo found himself unable to say no.But before he could speak, Rebecca's eyes brimmed with tears."Matty, am I putting you in a tough spot? It's okay, really. If this is hard for you, I won't go tonight."She expected Matteo to immediately lower his voice and comfort her. But to her shock, he simply let out a breath as if relieved and reached out to pat her head."Tonight is kind of special, so it's better if you don't come with me."Rebecca's eyes widened in disbelief. A flicker of resentment flashed across her face before she quickly masked it with a pitiful expression. The tears that had been about to stop began falling in thick, heavy drops again."Matty…"But Matteo's mind was elsewhere. He barely noticed her reaction, gently pushing her away before looking up at the ceiling."This is the one that's broken?" he asked, nodding toward the light fixture.Rebecca bit her lip, sulking. Since he wasn't giving her the reaction she wanted, she let out a s

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 12

    A sharp jolt ran through Matteo's chest. His eyes darted around the living room, searching desperately for something, or rather, for someone.It was like he was expecting Evelyn to step out at the moment."Eve…"He called her name over and over again, but the panic in his heart only grew stronger.A thought, an impossible, terrifying thought, began to creep into his mind.Did Eve leave him? No. He refused to believe it."Eve, you're messing with me, right? Come on out, this isn't funny." His voice cracked slightly. "I know I messed up this morning, but Becky and I are really just friends. Please, believe me."He kept talking, his feet moving restlessly through the house, scanning every corner like she might be hiding somewhere.But then, he finally noticed it. The estate felt emptier.Their photos together were gone.Evelyn's personal belongings were gone.Everything was gone.How?How could everything be gone?Matteo felt like he was losing his mind.That nightmare from

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 13

    So, Evelyn had understood their conversation that day. She had known all along.She had found out that he and Rebecca were legally married and that they were planning to keep it a secret from her.Panic clawed at Matteo's chest.He had thought he could keep it hidden. He thought that he could juggle both Rebecca and Evelyn without either of them getting hurt.To him, Rebecca was nothing more than a past obsession. He had been furious when she left him for another man, and that fury had turned into an unhealthy need to keep her in his life forever.But she had always been a shadow, someone he kept hidden.As long as Evelyn never found out the truth, it didn't matter.The one he truly loved, and had always loved, was Evelyn. Ever since he lost his sight, she was the only one who mattered.But now, everything had fallen apart.Evelyn had learned Haranese.She understood their conversation.She had figured out everything.But how could she be so heartless?All he had was an un

Latest chapter

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 25

    For the next two New Year's, Evelyn spent them in Algaria.Every year, Sophie's parents would come over to celebrate together, and Sophie would always pull her along to join the family gatherings.As they spent more time together, their personalities and values resonated in harmony, forging a deeper bond. That year, the Reynolds family had officially relocated all their business operations to Satbury, intending to settle there for good. Sophie kept pestering Evelyn, asking if she had any plans to stay as well.Evelyn had thought about this for a long time.Back home, the few close friends she had all had their own families now, married and settled. Her parents and relatives had long since passed, leaving her completely alone, with no property or assets tying her down.From both a social and career standpoint, staying made the most sense.Her career was thriving, and she had even saved enough money to buy a home of her own. She had once considered returning the money Caroline ha

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 24

    Online discussion about Matteo's so-called devotion kept growing, and some extreme netizens even started cursing at Evelyn, accusing her of being ungrateful.Then, the man Matteo had relentlessly targeted, the one he had nearly bankrupted, finally snapped.He began exposing everything he knew."Evelyn is a good woman. Back when Matteo went blind for his ex, she was the one who stayed by his side, helping him out of the darkness. She was there until he regained his sight."But the moment he could see again, Matteo's mother changed her tune completely. She started looking down on Evelyn in every possible way. But Matteo still protected her, and the two of them were happy together."Too bad Rebecca, Matteo's ex, came back. She cried a few tears, and that was all it took for him to lose his damn mind and marry her behind Evelyn's back."During that time, Rebecca kept setting Evelyn up, and that so-called deeply devoted Matteo? He sided with Rebecca every time. He made Evelyn's life a

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 23

    Evelyn had been about to go to bed after freshening up. Just as she finished drying her hair, someone knocked on her door.She froze for a moment, then instinctively opened it.Standing at the door, Sophie pressed her lips tightly together, her usually relaxed expression uncharacteristically serious."Evelyn, you're trending on the domestic hot search."As she spoke, she handed her phone to Evelyn. On the screen, several trending topics had Matteo's name in them. One of them stood out."Matteo's Heartfelt Confession: Where Are You Evelyn?"The feed was flooded with Evelyn's pictures, though, for now, no one seemed to know exactly where she was.Evelyn's expression stiffened.She took the phone from Sophie, frowning as she carefully examined the headlines dominating the trending list.Sophie didn't press for details. Instead, she simply looked at Evelyn, worry evident in her eyes.Evelyn, however, didn't show much reaction. She only let out a small sigh and admitted it outrigh

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 22

    After Wendy started staying by his side, Matteo gradually stopped mentioning Evelyn.He even allowed Wendy to act more recklessly, to the point that she began posting about their daily lives online.The narrative of a powerful CEO rescuing a helpless young woman trapped in the nightlife scene quickly made her account go viral.In her latest post, she shared a video of Matteo throwing her an extravagant birthday party and even proposing to her in front of all the guests.The proposal video exploded online, and within just two months, Wendy's social media following had skyrocketed into the millions.At the end of the video, she excitedly announced that their wedding was set for two weeks later and would be streamed live.Time flew by.Before long, the big day arrived.Despite the short time frame, Matteo didn't cut any corners. The entire wedding venue was lavish beyond imagination, and dozens of media outlets were invited to stream the ceremony in real-time.The event dominated

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 21

    The young woman in front of him took two steps back, frowning slightly in confusion."What did you say?"Her expressions, gestures, and everything about her were eerily similar, even down to her face and voice.For a moment, Matteo truly believed Evelyn was standing in front of him.However, the look in her eyes told a different story.She wasn't Evelyn.She was younger, probably not even 20 yet. She looked more like Evelyn from her college years.He fought back the overwhelming urge to pull her into his arms, his voice trembling. "What's your name?"The young woman seemed startled and retreated two steps. "I'm sorry. I think I walked into the wrong room."She turned to leave, but Matteo grabbed her wrist. His hands were still shaking.A single, warm tear slipped down his face and landed on the back of her hand.The young woman hesitated, stopping in her tracks.After a brief pause, she pulled a napkin from the drink cart and handed it to him. "Are you okay? Here, you shoul

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 20

    Hearing his words, Rebecca completely panicked.She clutched her stomach tightly as if her life depended on it.The Pittman family was no longer what it used to be. They had been teetering on the edge of bankruptcy for a long time.If she couldn't keep this child, she would have no way of securing her position as Mrs. Gallagher.What was worse, she might even end up being handed over to that disgusting old pervert to be toyed with like some object!Her face went as pale as a sheet.Without thinking, she grabbed her phone, ready to call Caroline.Caroline valued children above all else. As soon as she found out Rebecca was pregnant, she would definitely find a way to protect her!But before the call could connect, Matteo kicked the phone away without hesitation.He stood up, nudging Rebecca's chin upward with the tip of his shoe, his voice ice-cold."Be good and get rid of the child. The divorce papers are already finalized. Whether you agree or not doesn't matter. Stop wastin

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 19

    The investigation results and the recovered chat logs were delivered to Matteo's house the next day.He had repurchased every single one of Evelyn's belongings, placing them back exactly where they used to be. Every time he came home, he could almost fool himself into believing she was still there.However, there was no coming back. The entire estate was lifeless without Evelyn, as if it had been drained of its soul.Matteo spent a long time gathering the courage before finally opening the files.The latest message was from the day Evelyn left. It was a secretly recorded video of him and Rebecca sharing a soft kiss in front of the piano.Rebecca had attached a caption. "You probably don't know this, but this is Matty's favorite place. I won't record what happens next. I don't think you'd be able to handle it."Tell me, do you really think playing dumb helps? How does it feel being the mistress? Well, you've been a mistress your whole life, but hey, if you beg me nicely, maybe I'l

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 18

    Rebecca's tears stopped. Her hands hung limply at her sides as she stared at Matteo in disbelief.She didn't understand why his attitude toward her changed so fast.Before, whenever she cried, he was always the first to panic. But now, there was nothing in his eyes except cold indifference. It was as if even if she cried herself dry, he wouldn't care in the slightest.Rebecca didn't dare admit that she had deliberately provoked Evelyn, or worse, that she had set her up.She clamped her mouth shut, silently praying, almost in desperation."Matty, I didn't do anything. Please, believe me, okay? Ms. Walsh is such a kind person, and you've helped me so much. I'm grateful to both of you. Why would I ever do anything to hurt her?"Sure, she never liked me, and maybe she's throwing a bit of a tantrum this time, but Matty, don't treat me like this just because she left."As she spoke, she forced a few more tears out.Matteo had always been easy to manipulate. If she could just make hi

  • Once Upon a Story of Us   Chapter 17

    After spending a few days in the hospital, Matteo decided to check himself out early.The day after Evelyn left, he had scheduled a divorce with Rebecca. Now that the 30-day cooling-off period had passed, he needed to finalize it as soon as possible.That day, Rebecca sobbed, but in the end, she didn't say much.She simply followed him obediently to process the divorce paperwork, her tear-filled eyes staring at him as she told him to be happy.He had been frustrated with her, but seeing her so understanding at that moment, he couldn't bring himself to blame her. He even agreed not to publicly announce their divorce for the time being.Matteo drove to Rebecca's house.Just as he reached the front door and was about to walk in, voices from inside made him pause."That bitch Evelyn should've just killed herself when she saw those messages! Disappearing for a whole month? Why the hell is Matteo still not over her? What the hell is so great about that slut anyway?"Whatever, it does

Scan code to read on App
DMCA.com Protection Status