Share

20

Author: bestie
last update Last Updated: 2025-03-05 22:21:17

Mike had his head in his hands. He felt lower than a slug. He had to say something, to explain somehow, to make it right.

"I'm sorry," they said in unison, each surprising the other.

"What?" she asked quietly. "Why are you sorry?"

He sighed deeply, obviously wracked with guilt about what had happened. "Last night, I just..." he began, but then fell silent. What the hell could he possibly say?

He lifted his head, determined to make this right between them. "Last night was the best night of sleep I ever had," he said, his voice full of sincerity. "Even with all the bruises and cuts, I wouldn't trade the memory of holding you all night for anything. I'd gladly do it again to have another night like that." He sighed, turning to look at her. "I didn't mean to ruin everything that happened last night, I didn't mean to..." He lowered his head again, "I didn't mean to get excited. Last night just felt too pure, too innocent and then I had to get erect and ruin...," She raised her hand to his lips.

"Mike, I don't know how to explain how it felt being next to you. I've hated you for so long, and never really wanted to get know you. After last night, though, it's like I've known you forever. Whenever I try to sleep and you aren't there, I have flashbacks. I don't know what I would have done if it hadn't been for you, so I don't care that you were erect. You didn't abuse anything last night. I kissed you," she said, lowering her head, a tear winding its way down her cheek. "I'm the one that should be sorry." She reached up and brushed the tear away.

"Whenever I kiss you, it feels like a charge of energy shoots through me. It's so exciting and it makes me feel so special, something no one else has ever done for me. I can't describe it, it's like everything else goes away when we kiss. I'm so ashamed," she said, another tear running down her cheek. "The one person that makes me feel like that is my brother, and I feel like I'm abusing our relationship when I kiss you." he raised his hand to her lips this time, quieting her

"Danni, I feel the electricity too. My body goes numb whenever you kiss me. I've never felt... whatever it is." He slid off the bed and onto his knees in front of her. He lifted her chin and ran a hand over her cheek, wiping away a tear. "I don't care how we are related, I'm not afraid of letting this happen. It feels wonderful." He leaned over and kissed her forehead, drawing a smile from her face. "Besides, we're only kissing. It's not like we're going shopping together or something intimate like that."

She giggled at this, and he smiled at the sound. "Are you sure?" she asked. "I certainly don't want to destroy any bridges we've built."

"Danni, all we've done together is sleep next to each other and kiss a little. It's understandable, considering all you've been through, that you're having mixed emotions." He sat back on his feet, placing his hands on her knees.

"I'll be here tonight, if you need me. The door will be unlocked, and it will stay that way until you decide you don't need someone to sleep next to you. I just wanna try and make it all better for you."

"When did you get to be so sweet?" she asked, smiling for the first time. "I used to hate you so much."

"I know, I have the scars to prove it," he said, smiling. She rolled her eyes briefly at him, scowling playfully. He leaned forward, softly touching the side of her face and leaned forward, gently kissing her again.

"I'm gonna go shower," he said, standing. "I need to see how fucked up I actually am."

"Ok," she said. She rose and started to leave his room, but then stopped at the doorway and turned, "I'll see you tonight then." She turned and went to her room, closing the door behind her.

The shower was a combination of pain and relaxation. Mike had slowly gotten undressed, not wanting to cause himself any other pain than was necessary. Bruises and ugly red scrapes dotted his ribcage and back. No wonder he was in pain, he looked like someone had colored a paint-by-number with a shotgun.

He stood in the shower for nearly an hour, letting the hot water course over his muscles and slowly ease the tension out of them, the events of the past couple of days coming back to him. It was only the day before yesterday that Emma had caught him masturbating, and had heard him call out Danni's name in the shower. She still hadn't said anything and he was beginning to wonder when that conversation would take place. It seemed so insignificant now, in light of all that had happened after it.

Sarah came into his mind. He'd never have thought that Sarah would be the sister that he'd start fooling around with. It just didn't seem like her, it wasn't in her normal routine. The thought of a sex filled normal routine for Sarah caused a chuckle and then a wince of pain as his ribs ached. Those assholes had really taken the boot to him. He was suddenly very glad that he'd been conciliatory to the guy working the door that night.

His thoughts drifted back to the second oldest sibling. So much had happened to her in so little time. He knew she was having a hard time. Normally, he suddenly realized, the voice would have chimed in with some lewd advice, but it had been strangely silent. Remembering that he'd just had three orgasms with an actual woman, he knew why. It always got quieter after he masturbated; the same would certainly be true when an actual woman did the deed.

Deciding he'd spent enough time in the shower, he grabbed his towel and pushed the faucet off, stepping out of the tub and rubbing the water off.

A knock at the door startled him briefly.

"Decent?" Emma called

Related chapters

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   21

    Wrapping the towel around his waist, he reached over for his toothbrush."Yeah," he called, reaching for the toothpaste.She came in, holding some freshly folded towels and opened the cabinet to put them up. "How're you holding up?"He shrugged. "Better than I could be, I guess. It's Monday, right?"Emma nodded, not looking at her brother, fiddling with the towels in the cabinet and stalling for time."So..." she said, turning and pretending to straighten something else.He sighed, 'Here it comes,' he thought. "Go ahead, get it out of your system," he said, lowering his head and rubbing a hand through his hair.She laughed. "So, yeah... sorry about the other day." She fidgeted around for a few seconds, biting her lip and trying not to start laughing. A few seconds passed in awkward silence. He could feel it coming."Oh Danni, huh?" she asked, still trying to contain her laughter.He sighed, an embarrassed grin finding its way to his face and began to slowly shake his head. "I don't ev

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   22

    "Grab a handful of that, now damn you!""I wasn't trying to make things difficult for you," she said, turning on the blender."I know," he replied, feeling his eyes inevitably dropping back to her impressive cleavage."I wish I didn't have these damn things," she said, looking down at her breasts."Blasphemy!""Huh? Why?" Mike asked, truly surprised."Well, I just wish that someone who would get some actual use out of them had gotten them. I..." she trailed off. "Danni or Emma would be much better suited for these. They just seem wasted on me."Mike was quiet, not really knowing what to say. He didn't agree of course."Boobs are good."'Thank you, Captain Obvious,' Mike thought."I just don't really know how to go about, talking I guess. I mean, the few guys that do talk to me are only interested in gawking at these giant things and usually don't' have a brain in their heads. You are the smartest guy I know, and that's not really saying much."Beth really couldn't sugar coat the truth

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   23

    He went into his room, letting Sarah enter after him and shutting the door behind her. She was on him immediately, eagerly pressing her lips to his in a hurried embrace. He felt her run her hands down his back and to his butt, pulling his hips forward and grinding her crotch against his erection."Throw her down and fuck her"'You've said that before,' he thought at it. 'Don't you ever come up with new ones?'"The classics never change"He laid his head back on the door with a dull thud. She began to drop to her knees as she quickly began to unzip him. He glanced down at her a second later, confused as to why she stopped."I just remembered, I told you last time that you were gonna have to earn one," she said, with a wicked grin.He groaned as images of him washing dishes and doing laundry filled his mind. "Dishes or laundry," he said, completely missing her innuendo."Oh no," she said, chuckling at him. "I'm not going to waste it on anything like that."She stood up and stepped back

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   24

    She nodded, smiling sweetly again. He pulled the condom wrapper off and began to try and pull it over his dick, then turned it over when he realized it was inverted, rolling his eyes as it slid easily over his dick. Sarah was watching him with an amused expression on her face.She gently lifted her shirt off her head as he pulled his lounge pants around his ankles. She was lying on her back, her elbows propping up her upper body, her breasts pointing up at him and nipples hardening in the cool air. She slowly spread her legs and licked her lips as he came forwards, positioning himself at her vagina."Just go slow at first, and then do whatever feels good to you," she told him, pulling him close and reaching up to kiss him. He nodded, shuffling his feet closer. He began to rub the head of his cock against her still moist pussy lips. She closed her eyes and sighed softly, eagerly awaiting the cock that was poised for a plunge into her snatch.A loud knock on his door sent him scrambling

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   25

    Mike immediately knew that he wanted to go. Definitely needed to get away from this house that had been corrupting his brain and making him defile his sisters. It was easy for them to go on vacation. After his parents had been killed, the 5 kids had received a large insurance payment from their parents' life insurance policies along with the money that they had saved while they still had their medical practice. Sarah had sought financial advice about what to do and they were now living off investments and still had very large chunk of the original sum they had inherited. Sarah could stretch a dollar farther than anyone else he knew.They had rarely gone on vacation, usually because the twins were still in high school, or Beth was taking summer classes, or Danni had some other engagement to go to. This summer marked the first time they'd all been off at the same time. It seemed like a perfect time for vacation."I think that'd be a great idea," Mike said, after a few seconds of silence

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   26

    The next few days passed by quickly, and relatively normally. Mike tried to keep himself occupied, working out and running with Emma when his bruises had healed enough. Normal enough, all things considered. Sarah kept trying to seduce him, wearing low cut tops and her magic sex apron that he found so damn alluring. He had to keep finding excuses to keep her greedy little sex starved fingers off of him, which, of course, only seem to encourage her to pursue him more aggressively. Emma was strangely quiet around him. She wasn't rude, or indifferent, but not her usual self. Then again, she'd never been very talkative, so it didn't really bother him.Every night, Danni would come into his room when he went to bed and curl up next to him. They kissed each other tenderly for a few minutes every night as they were falling asleep, waking up embracing each other again and kissing for a few minutes every morning. They'd lay there for as long as they could each morning before they heard the othe

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   27

    Danni came out of the bathroom in her sports bra and panties and headed over to Mike's bed. The rest of the family had accepted her need for someone understanding to sleep next to. Emma watched as her sister crawled into bed next to him and curled up on a pillow, waiting for Mike to get in.Emma pulled herself into bed, feeling a bolt of jealousy fleetingly pass through her. She couldn't hold it against her sister, though, knowing how much she'd been through. She felt her heart warm as she saw how her sister responded to Mike just being near. She knew that Mike wouldn't ever hurt Danni, wouldn't force anything on her, would just be there for her whenever she needed him. She found herself desperately wishing she could be held in his arms as well. She turned over, trying to go to sleep, but couldn't and soon turned back to her siblings.Mike yawned, stretching his arms. It had been a long day, but a good one. He pulled the covers up and lay down beside Danni, relishing the feeling of he

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05
  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   28

    Handing Emma his life vest, he put her broken one over him. Satisfied they were safe enough, they took off again, heading back up the beach towards the rental place. Emma immediately leaned forward and laid her head on his back, running a hand across a muscle. She lifted her head suddenly and leaned forward. "I was so envious of Danni last night. It looked so warm and safe lying next to you. It made me a little jealous."She sat back and laid her head back down. How far did she dare take this? She'd wanted to slide her bathing suit aside and pull him inside, but knew that would've been impossible, even without her being a virgin. She could still have a little fun she decided, providing she didn't cause him to wreck. He throttled up, taking the lead over and ogling Beth as she bounced along beside him, holding to Danni who was smiling wildly.Emma, slowly ran her hand along her brother's stomach, feeling around gently near his pants. She felt him jerk as her hand touched his dick, stil

    Last Updated : 2025-03-05

Latest chapter

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   50

    She moaned and sighed happily. "You are getting so damn good at this." she admitted.He smiled, and began to move southwards, but she stopped him. "As much as I want you to do that, it's my turn," she said, drawing a wide grin from him. She quickly maneuvered him to his bed, pulling herself on top of him. She popped the button of his jeans and lifted his shirt over his head, finishing by pulling off his boxers, freeing his dick and smiling as it poked upwards, fully erect."I've wanted to do this to you since our vacation," she said, looking up at him.She grabbed his cock in her hand, pulling her face close and holding it before her. Her tongue snaked out, licking slowly up his shaft and causing him to throw his head back in pleasure. Her tongue felt like warm velvet as it stroked up and down his cock.Mike was in heaven. Danni was finally sucking his cock and it felt even better than he'd felt with his other sisters. Okay well, maybe not better, but it was sure different, and it was

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   49

    "So why are you going to put yourself through this?" she asked, "you could have already had sex several times today. I don't understand it. You've got three women that love you and want to fuck you regularly, and they all know about each other and are more than willing to share you. Men have killed for less.""Listen to her, she's a fucking genius."He shrugged. "I've just got to prove to myself that I can resist some of these impulses.""Some?" she asked, smiling and drawing close to him.He chuckled again as she drew even closer, straddling the machine and him to come to rest on his lap. She wrapped her arms around him and kissed him, but quickly remembered they were in public. Fearing suddenly someone they knew might see them, she quickly dismounted."It's even easier now to forget that you're my brother," she said quietly.She turned and headed for the bathroom, stopping at the doorway and winking at him. Mike grinned. She reappeared a few seconds later, biting her lip nervously a

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   48

    His eyes popped open and his head shot up as he lifted himself to his elbows. Sarah was at the foot of his bed, his rock-hard cock in her mouth, her eyes locked on his."Damn it, Sarah," he said, and put a hand on her head in the beginnings of an attempt at pushing her off.She grinned and gently exposed her teeth against the skin of his dick, causing him to freeze."You wouldn't," he said, shocked at his eldest sister.Pulling her brother's cock almost out of her mouth, she smiled and winked at him. "Try me, stud," she said, and pulled him right back into her depths of her throat.He groaned as she pulled him deeper, feeling her tongue caress the head of his shaft. He moaned again as she pulled him out, then quickly back in once again, her lips pursed as she sucked forcefully on his rod. She began to pick up speed as she bobbed up and down on him, pulling him farther and farther into her mouth until the tip of his dick was poking the back of her throat repeatedly every few seconds.H

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   47

    "Like I said, I hate you."***********Mike cautiously crept into the kitchen, expecting a female ninja sex attack from all angles. His sisters were all seated in their customary positions, plates filled with a dish Beth had conjured up. He fixed himself a plate and quietly took a seat.Emma, Danni, and Sarah all had grins on their faces, though Beth was oblivious to what was going on. She had found a shirt, though it did little to conceal her large breasts and ample cleavage. Mike felt like his brain was thinking a thousand different things at once. 'Emma's ass pressing against his lap, or Sarah's tongue wrapped around the head of his cock those few weeks ago, or Danni's arched back pushing her breasts into the air as he gave her an orgasm, or Beth's massive cleavage.'"Get a double handful of that, will ya"He shook his head again, drawing smiles from three of the four girls at the table. He cursed himself silently. Except for the voice, they knew exactly what was going on in his he

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   46

    Mike's eyes were locked on Beth's impressive breasts barely contained inside the bra from breakfast. Her tits seemed to be straining against the thin material as if they would rip through the fabric at any second.Emma grabbed Beth by the shoulders and turned her slightly. Lowering her head, she snaked out her tongue and began licking upwards on Beth's cleavage, slurping up the chocolate and continuing to lick up and down her breast. She cupped one in her hand and kissed it, before licking upwards again."Fuck them both, they're just begging for it."Beth's eyes involuntarily closed as she felt her younger sister's warm tongue on her skin. It was so wet and smooth, and it sent tingles across her skin. She sighed softly as Emma cupped her breast and pushed it upwards slightly, which slightly pulled it from the confines of her top.Mike's eyes nearly popped out of his head and his pecker was pleading with him to go join in the fun. He was transfixed on the scene in front of him, his dic

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   45

    He ignored the voice. There wasn't going to be anything helpful coming from it. Standing, he stretched and headed to the kitchen for breakfast. A few minutes later, Emma came downstairs followed by Danni. They both leaned over and gave Mike a kiss on the cheek. He ignored them and focused on his cereal. Danni was wearing her sports bra and panties. She went to the fridge and opened it. Bending over, she surveyed the inside.Her spectacular ass taunted him as she peered into the fridge, looking for something to eat. She shifted her weight, which moved her hips, which shifted her ass cheeks back and forth. She pulled something out of the fridge and sat it on the counter, followed by a few more items. Mike didn't have a clue as to what they were, and he didn't care. His eyes were locked on that amazing ass that seemed to be just beckoning him."Go fuck it wimp."'DAMN IT,' he swore internally. He forced his gaze elsewhere.At the same moment, Sarah came back in the room, dressed, sort of

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   44

    "Fine, as long as you fuck her."Just then, the door to Sarah's room opened and she came out wearing only half a cut off t-shirt and panties. Smiling she walked over to the couch and sat down next to Mike and cuddled up, then drew her face close to his. She went to give him a morning kiss but counter to their recent behaviors, he turned his head causing her to only contact his cheek.Raising an eyebrow and pulling her head back, she asked, "Is there something wrong?" She put her hand to her face as she blew on it, "Morning breath?""It's complicated," he said, but then pulled her close for a hug as a consolation."Throw her to the floor and fuck her."Mike sighed. This was going to be a long two weeks."I don't think we should be having sex anymore," he said flatly, then quickly decided that he should've thought that sentence out before he said it. That's not exactly what he meant."Wow. You are such an idiot."Sarah sat back against the cushions, with her eyebrow still raised and put

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   43

    Mike headed to the kitchen for a glass of milk, grabbing some chocolate chip cookies from the cabinet and headed to the den where he flipped through the sports channels."So go get some pussy, already."'I had some not two hours ago,' he thought, glancing at the clock on the wall."And, YOUR point is?"Mike sighed, shaking his head. 'I'm not Superman, I do need to rest.'"Says who? You can rest when we're dead. Go back up there and get some damn you!"'Why are you being so insistent?' he asked."Just go get some pussy already!"'I'd like to know what the point of all this is,' Mike said, deciding to take a stand."The point?"'Yeah,' Mike replied."The point is having your dick surrounded and enveloped by a sweet young wet pussy? Have you lost all of your marbles?"'I'm just concerned with how persistent you're becoming. What do you get out of all of this?' asked Mike."PUSSY!"'So, the only thing you want for us is pussy?' asked Mike."No, but pussy is at the top of that list."Mike

  • A Love That Shouldn't Be   42

    He pulled back a bit and lifted her chin, looking into her eyes. "I love you," he said, staring at her, not blinking and waiting for her reaction. He knew that she understood exactly what he was saying. He loved her, and not just as a sister anymore.She smiled and kissed him briefly, then pulled back and looked up at him. "I love you too, Mike, with all of my heart, forever.""There's something else that I've wanted to tell you," he said.She looked at him curiously, but then smiled when she realized what was bothering him. Nuzzling close again, she kissed his chest."Mike, I know about the others. I've known since the first, when you and Sarah fooled around together." She giggled as she lay next to him, thinking back to the sexual encounters she'd heard and witnessed.Mike didn't have a clue as to how to even begin an explanation for his recent behavior."You finished cleaning the pool and I watched you and Sarah at the door, and I saw you run upstairs. I went inside after a bit for

Scan code to read on App
DMCA.com Protection Status